NYPD Pizza

I’ve been coming here for at least 5 years. The main dude there knows who I am and often asks me how my job is. Even though I only order a couple times a month at most, it’s nice that I don’t feel like just another wallet at times. So lets talk about the food here.
First, obviously this is a pizza place, so we’ll talk about the pizza. The sauce is more of a garlicky sweet sauce. The toppings and cheese are all pretty standard fare for a non gourmet pizza place. Nothing to complain about. I have noticed that the larger size pizza you get the better it tastes. Perhaps it’s just my imagination. The prices for pizza here are competitive with the other big names in the industry. The extra large double pepperoni is only ~11−12 $ and feeds 4 – 5 hungry adults.
Second, let’s talk about the sandwiches. NYPDs subs and hoagies make other pizza places taste like bland subway sandwiches. Even larosas can’t hold a candle to the Italian sub here. The subs are super messy to eat, but to me its a good thing. They give you all the vegetables in a nice side bag so you can decide for yourself if you want the fixins.
The wings and cheesesticks aren’t anything to write home about here. They aren’t bad but they aren’t great either. They compare to pizza hut wings in quality. Cheesesticks are hard to screw up.
Overall NYPD is a good small pizza place to carry out from in the Colerain or White Oak area. Don’t come here expecting Deweys or some other gourmet pizza and you’ll likely end up enjoying the food.

I love this pizza, and you can’t beat the price! Super cheesy and not too much sauce. My only complaint is that it is very greasy so don’t eat this if you’re a calorie counter and trying to be healthy.

We actually have come to like NYPD pizza over Five Boroughs. Both are good, but the sauce and crust at NYPD are just a little better. I also like the price-​you can get a large pie, breadsticks, and chicken wings without going broke.

This pizza is better than the hometown brand. Topping and crust are fresh and the sauce has a good taste. Never had any problems

Not that great, I really expected better. The sauce had too sharp taste to it. To me it tasted of little more than tomato and a lot of garlic. Otherwise pretty unremarkable. Scratching this one off my list