Eddie’s Pizzeria & Eatery

Went here last night and the service was really good however the pizza was so-​so and a bit overpriced. We had a small magherita and a medium luigis luau along with a pitcher of hanger 24 and garlic puff… $ 70.34. I guess I will continue to search for New York or Chicago style pizza which I miss so much

I ordered for take-​out a large pepperoni pizza and garlic puffs for dinner. My family loves loves loves the garlic puffs. I have to give a shout out to Manny — excellent customer service. Thank you.

Service was superb, I recognized well training and she was very pleasant. We also had a mgr/​supervisor greet us and he was very attentive and pleasant. The food was really really good. The sauces and dressings were spot on, fresh parm and pepper was served. Pasta was on point. The beer was cold and I noticed good wines on the menu. Hopefully, I’ll try one next time.

WOW! Is all I can say. Good pizza is hard to find, but search no further. Some pizza joints are a lot of hype. I hate hidden toppings. I like to see my pepperoni. Don’t care much for toppings under the cheese. Or when everything goes sliding off my pizza slice. Eddie’s pizza is the Best! The employees are awesome. Here you can have pizza, finely crafted burgers, lasagna, salads and much much more. Huge menu items. Desserts are sinful. This is our new favorite eating place.

If you only get one thing get the pizza, no question some of the best in the area. Prices were fair and the pie was spot on. If you can get something else the canolis were also amazing very traditional, a little on the small side but fantastic

Our first time eating here. I ordered over the phone and picked it up. The staff was very nice and gave me my order quickly. Went home to eat and it was delicious. The crust was nice crisp and the flavors of the sauce and meats were awesome. Pizza even tasted great cold later that night. The rolls with garlic and bacon were to die for. Should have ordered 2. The salad was fresh and lettuce was crisp. The only down fall the size of pizza isn’t as large as I thought. They are pricey but if you want awesome pizza then it’s worth it. Would put 5 star but didn’t experience the staff enough but next time will eat their.

My wife and I had a great night out here. Everyone was friendly, helpful and attentive. We loved our meals, I got the jambalaya, which came with pasta instead of rice, for an Italian twist. My wife got the chicken med. So delicious… I will be returning for this one. Did not have the pizzas, but they looked good. Same for the desserts. Looks like we’ll be returning for these misses! Very tasty food, all done very well.

My experience didn’t start out very positive. A couple that walked in after us were seated before us. We were seated and wanted pint sized beers but they ran out of cups due to a large party. How’s that my problem? Our server Alicia, truly saved our dining experience. She was friendly, patient and very apologetic for our experience. The pizza was yummy and the ranch was good too.

6:30pm 12−12−15. A friend of mine Just spent $ 100 in pizza, salads, and wings and on the way out asked for extra ranch. The polite young employee went back and got us some but was stopped by either the owner or manager and told him to charge us $ 1.50 more. DUDE!!! He just spent $ 100 !!!

VERY good! We had great service from our wonderful waitress. Food was yummy. Love the pizza!

Pretty solid place. Those garlic puffs are pretty amazing. It was a smidge on the pricy side but the service and food was good so it didn’t really bother. Oh, their lil Italian donut dessert is also to die for. Do it.

All I wanted was a pizza, and they wouldn’t bring it to me.
I attempted to eat here tonight, and I was even seated at a table for about a half hour. They were kind enough to bring me a water.
Unfortunately, all I wanted was a pizza, and they wouldn’t bring it to me. All I wanted was a pizza, and they wouldn’t bring it to me. So, I left. Thank you for the complimentary water. I accept the water as partial payment for wasting my time.
Round Table pizza is just down the street, and Sara more than made it up to me at Round Table all I wanted was a pizza, and Round Table La Verne brought it to me.

The calamari Fritti is great! The marinara sauce was also very good. The linguine with clams was delicious! It was a take out order. Unfortunately, the linguine sauce got out of the container and spilled into bag which had a hole in it! I had the sauce everywhere in the car, on me and floor. Best to have food double bagged.

Friendly staff, plenty of choices on the menu. Love the updated dining area. My wife loves the gluten free pizza while I find the Italian Sub fantastic!

Online Buyer Beware! Don’t expect to get your Red Button discount when ordering take out online. They don’t have a code on the coupon so there’s no way to get the discount and once you enter your credit card they got your money! Call in your order the old fashion way like it was 1990 again! Deduct 2 stars for being unclear before completing the order!
Pizza is delicious and I like the wings.

Great place for lunch when having a pizza craving. Don’t sell by the slice but they do have a lunch small pizza that comes with a fresh salad that hits the spot! Best pizza in Claremont so far.

Came here for lunch with my college, we ordered margarita and pepperoni pizza. I have to say, their crust are pretty darn delicious.
Price is decent too!
I will come back for more different flavours!

Good bruschetta.
Great pizza — I had the thin crust gorgonzola-​grape. Fantastic!
OUTSTANDING bread pudding! I am really, really picky about bread pudding & their version is my version of perfection. It’s baked just right, not at all mushy, and none of that gross egginess that is sometimes present in an inferior incarnation. It’s loaded with raisins and served in a bourbon-​caramel-​cream sauce. I’d recommend getting a scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side.
Also, the staff is wonderful. Clearly, most of the customers while I was there were regulars but I was treated with the same care and consideration.
Restrooms are clean & well-​maintained.
Several TVs — ESPN (thank you!).
Parking lot is adequate — restaurant shares the parking areas with a strip mall that includes a grocery store and many other businesses.

My Sister recommended this place because it’s right by her house and I will say that it’s definitely a mom and pop pizza shop. as for the pizza we kept it really simple.
one supreme pizza and a meat pizza. both were pretty good. one thing I like about their pizza was that the cheese was really gooey stringy cheese and the flavor of the pizza was good. as far as crust is concerned it wasn’t anything special. It would be comparable to any other mom and pop pizza shop
only thing I will say that is for 2 pizzas to be $ 50 that’s super expensive. good thing my sister had a coupon from shopping at the market nearby so it came out to $ 40 give or take a few bucks. but if you want some good New York style pizza it’s definitely a solid option I just don’t think it will be memorable because nothing about this place stands out. except the cheese! lol

Still working my way through the menu. First time here I had the Italian Beef Dip. The next three or four times I visited Eddies, I had the Italian Beef Dip. Finally I decided to venture out of my comfort zone and explore their menu. So far, I have not been disappointed. The Chicken Parmesan is spectacular! Lasagna is to die for. I had the meat sauce with both dishes, although they offer a marinara sauce as well. Caesar salad is perfect too…
The atmosphere is casual yet classy. The staff are very friendly and attentive. Honestly, couldn’t come up with a single negative criticism even if I tried. Highly recommended restaurant! 5 stars all the way!