Mozzarella’s Italian Eatery

It is GONE!!! Loved this place and the owners, but they went back home to NY.

We ordered pizza to be delivered to us while we were staying at Anthony’s on the Beach Motel and our group agreed the pizza was great! Wish we were closer to have it again rather than just tonight.

So thrilled to find New York style pizza right here in Cocoa Beach! I’m from NYC and the pizza at Mozzarella’s is as good, if not better, than any pizza I have had in the city.
The crust is exceptional. Bravo!!!

Very good pizza. They only have a couple tables so seating is limited. Not cheap, but not expensive. Worth the $ 35 for a couple large pizzas. I would recommend to a friend.

I’m from new haven ct and haven’t had good pizza since I’ve been in FL and I his pizza is so yummy!!! We orders spicy sausage and garlic pizza and it was spot on!!! Thank you!

Ordered the Mediterranean salad, super super good. Restaurant is clean and staff is very nice. Nothing like the negative reviews I read.

Terrific, down home kind of pizzeria with friendly staff and reasonable prices. Beer was cold and the pizza was hot. Great for kids, but the place is rather small so you may encounter a small wait… but don’t worry it’s worth it.

We stopped in for their two — slice special and found that the pizza was amazing, and the staff very friendly. We enjoyed it so much that we returned for dinner!

Rude, Rude, Rude people !!
So, my friend stopped by today and asked me to join her for a lunch at Mozzarella’s, she knows I will never refuse an invitation to eat even though I already had a little something to eat… we love trying new places and never heard about this one, so here we go !! It was a Saturday and we are having a very hard time finding parking, driving around several times looking for a spot… yay, we found a spot, but it is not really a parking spot, we notice… what the heck… hopefully we will not get a ticket higher than the tab and here we go !
We walk in kind of lost with a pizza display as we are looking forward a full menu, we are not really greeted but a lady (which is the owner, I guess) point us to the dinner. We sit down and our waiter comes with the menu, we make small talks and order drinks. We look at the menu and do not immediately see anything that catch our STOMACH and end up deciding to share mozzarella sticks as an appetizer, shrimp scampi pasta and garlic knots. The waiter says they have a side of 3 knots but they are not garlic knots… we order 2 sides, 6 knots… as long as we have butter we are fine (she is a butter lover) !
Mozzarella Stick comes first it is home made and delicious ! Knots came next, and a little side dish with 4 thin slices of butter cut from a stick, she immediately says she will need more. Then THE OWNER comes with another dish with 3 extra thin slices asking whether or not we got our butter BUT clearly annoyed that we asked for more. We do not like her tone and is still not enough butter… my friend is not shy to ask again when the waiter re-​appear and he says = I WILL HAVE TO CHARGE YOU FOR A SIDE… THAT’S A LOT, YOU ATE ALMOST A STICK OF BUTTER !!! My friend gets beet red… I can not believe this and tell him we absolutely do not mind the charge.
Did you think it was bad ?? Well, he then return with the butter we are paying for and says, THIS IS THE VERY LAST BUTTER YOU ARE GETTING… WE NEED BUTTER TO COOK !!! Are you kidding me ?? This is all beyond rude… and my stomach is turning by now. I am glad we are sharing because it was hard to enjoy the last dish (the shrimp scampi).
He returns and ask how was everything and she answers it was OK, although she is never coming back and he asks WHY. (what ??) She says in all these years I have been eating out I was never called down because of the butter I use, nor had anyone controlling the amounts. And it was never a stick of butter, more like a quarter. I then finished saying that he could charge us whatever and would not be a problem, but hear what he said was disgraceful and unprofessional. You are running out of butter, you can go to the store and get more, matter of a fact, I doubt that a Italian Restaurant would have only 1 stick… I have more than that in my fridge !
Bottom line, the meal was ok, but this whole experience could not be more unpleasant ! If there was NO STARS, that would be my choice for this one !

We had 10 there for dinner tonight and people raved about the lasagna and the chicken riggies. The pizza is excellent too!
We have dined at almost every Italian in Cocoa Beach over the last two winters and Mozzarella’s is our favorite. You will not be disappointed!
Its is small and a little quiet but at least you can get a seat in the height of the tourist season!

Poor restaurant. We should have known when we walked in at noon and it was empty that it was a bad choice.
I ordered spaghetti with meatballs. Meatballs were good but noodles were tired and sauce was mostly water with no flavor– but a red color.
Other members of my party got sandwiches with pasta or chips as a side. The portion of sides was pathetic. About a teaspoon of side pasta and I don’t know how the chips were measured, but it was about the same as a teaspoon.
I will definitely not return to this spot.

Yehhh Finally GREAT Pizza in Cocoa Beach… we had the Greek Pizza — crust was thin to medium, toppings tastey, real cheese, Olives on the Greek Pizza (to die for), and this pizza is made with love.
We had previously ordered Pizza from Papa Vito’s (which I gave a 3)… Mozzarella’s Italian Eatery is th real deal when it comes to Pizza
Crispy crust (not soggy)…not thick dough — just right — dough complements the toppings.
Thanks to the other Unilocalers — as I wouldn’t have known about this place.
Its a small family run operation and the pizza does have excellent quality ingredients and perfect dough/​crust (consistency)
Definitely a must for pizza

You should avoid this place like the plague! The people who work there are rude. The pizza was cold and old and they didn’t want to honor their coupons. I will never go back. They will be out of business soon.

Came by after walking around Friday Fest. Son got 2 slices and a soda for 5 bucks, not bad for dinner. Wife and I shared two salads, both very fresh. Easy to walk to from just about anywhere on the beach. Friendly service.

My boyfriend and I have been here twice now. The service is good and the food is great! The first time we ordered a pizza which was really good. We’re both from New Jersey and are picky about pizza. The second time we tried something different. I had a meatball sub and my boyfriend had a pasta dish that is one of their New York specialties. He absolutely loved it. I thought the meatballs were great. We have definitely added this to our list of favorites and best of all its a short distance from his house.