Bexley Pizza Plus

I’ve lived in the Bexley area for 11 years and am kicking myself for just now trying Bexley Pizza Plus! Delicious pizza… and they deliver! I highly recommend. It’s not the usual cracker crust Columbus pizza. And the sauce is delicious!

This was my first time visiting this pizza place, got an 8 inch Philly cheesesteak pizza (to go) on my lunch. I knew from the first bite it was going to be amazing, not like any pizza had before. Ingredients were fresh — I love the garlic — and the crust was definitely homemade. I’ll definitely be back to try another specialty pizza.

I’ve been enjoying Bexley Pizza Plus for years. Every time I come visit my sister in Bexley, we (I try to) get a pizza delivered of time permits. The crust is crispy, ingredients are super fresh, & the people are always nice.

This has been and always will be my absolute favorite pizza. The crust it crisp and fresh. The way they place their pepperoni (in an overlapping straight line across the pizza in rows) is perfect and signature. The best topping is their house crumbled sausage. Having it crumbled ensures sausage in every single bite! The sauce has just a touch of sweetness without being overwhelming. I just moved back to bexley after moving as a child and it’s just a good as I remember it 15 years ago. I cannot praise this place enough.

It’s great pizza. They have that kind of peperoni that curls up when it’s cooked just right. Yum. And it has plenty of seating for you to enjoy a quick meal. The staff is friendly and the pizza menu is lengthy.
Lunch specials are available on weekends. Pizzazz pizza is pretty good.

Best pizza ive ever had I always order the same thing bacon pineapple but the kids at the bexley pizza plus are all hooligans ill tell ye I would give them a worse review if those kids didn’t make the best damn pizza i ever ate. Their trained by the best I suppose always satisfying and ive become a regular myself

I have tried this place about 4 or 5 times in the 2 years I’ve lived in bexley, hoping for improvement. Not once has it been good. The pizza has zero flavor and I’ve tried everything from the classic pepperoni and sausage to multiple specialty pies. Didn’t know that any pizza could be bad but this place has proven me wrong. Really wish I understood why others enjoy this place but I have given up. Unfortunately my wife enjoys it but she agrees that robinos is much better! Also a fan of Anthony’s which is around the corner. Anywhere but here

Pizza was great! Nice thick crust but not deep dish. Excellent sauce. Good amount of toppings! Delivered hot and quick!

their ultimate pizza (2 types of pep and 2 types of mushrooms) is our favorite pizza, crunchy crust, lots of toppings nice balanced sauce. Delivery is a huge help too

Great bread! They deliver! Mom and Pop Family owned! Always fresh and great!

if you’re not eating this pizza you don’t know what amazing pizza is…
their ingredients are so fresh & hearty
the pizzas are gourmet without being pretentious
so amazing we want it almost every night
the maximum pepperoni, the ultimate — omg those mushrooms — EVERYTHING we’ve ordered is food coma inducing in all the best ways

This place is within walking distance of my house. I have had it half of a dozen times and It never disappoints. It is the right amount of thickness to not be a thin crust but also not thick doughy crust. I would recommend a bacon and pineapple pizza or maximum pepperoni. If I had one gripe it would be the price. Almost $ 15 for a one topping 12″ pizza is a little steep.

I’ve been eating Bexley Pizza Plus since I was a kid and it never gets old. I’m not a very adventurous pizza lover, but I’ll eat a supreme from here. Thick crusts with tons of fresh toppings. Their subs are great for lunch too.

The guys behind the counter were great. Pizza came out quick. Had a small sausage pepperoni onions. Crust was crispy which I liked. Sauce had a great flavor.
Great pizza for the money.
I would recommend it for anyone any time.

The food was great, the price is ridiculous! Yes there are a decent amount toppings but I have never in my life spent $ 25 on the pizza. That said however the ingredients were all delicious fresh crispy the white sauce is awesome, it had all the right amounts of garlic, and the mushrooms were fresh not canned. Great pizza but is the only place that makes Donatos look cheap lol!

hands down the best pizza place in Columbus. I have tried almost eveything on the menu, and have never been disappointed. My personal favorite is the mushroom and peporoni with extra cheese, absolutely delicous. Only downfall is they do not offer a gluten free crust at this point.

This new «blend» of cheese that they’re supposedly using must be made out of awesomesauce because this place still serves one of the best pizzas in Columbus.
They’re a little higher priced than other places, but thats because they’re kind of a «gourmet» pizza place. They serve the «standards» but I’d really recommend trying out one of their specialty pizzas. I’ve never had one I didn’t like.
We were pleasantly surprised how cute the interior of the restaurant was. It was cozy with lots of natural light and all the tables set near the windows so we could enjoy our pie while people watching or ogling over the cute birds in the flower bushes in the back. There were also several TVs to watch whatever sporting event you fancy. It was pretty quiet and it was SO clean!
Our pizza took a little longer than say, a Pizza Hut pizza, but that’s to be expected on a busy Saturday afternoon. Which we were ok with because the end result was worth the wait. We had the Steak and Portobello pizza and this was quite possibly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. (Their version of the Mexican pizza is also to die for!)
Their crust is crispy on the bottom, but chewy on the inside, which is a great combo in my opinion! We’re not in the area much, but this is my #1 choice place to eat when we are!

I don’t like to be negative. And because of that, I keep trying the pizza here thinking it will improve. I know lots of people who prefer it as their favorite Bexley pizza. It isn’t bad. The toppings are all fresh. It’s just my opinion that the crust borders between thin and thick in an awkward middle-​ground and the sauce doesn’t taste like a whole lot. Put simply, it just isn’t anywhere near the delicious pizza next door at Rubinos. Because the two are so close together, it is hard not to compare them when ordering a pizza.
Having eaten here several times, I thought about what brought me there, and realized that there are a few pros.
— In the summer, if you want to dine-​in, there is air conditioning, whereas Rubinos reaches what feels like 100 degrees. Simple choice.
— If you want your pizza delivered, this is your option. I can recall many Bexley pizza parties with their pizza, mostly because they will bring it to your door, and in a box, whereas Rubinos has pickup only and wraps it in a tented bag, making it impossible to stack multiple pizzas for, say, a party.
— Everyone working there is very nice and the place is clean and new. Rubino’s is a bit more rough around the edges, but heck, that one’s going to be up to you.
These are just my thoughts. Changes are very good that I will be at party with their pizza or friends will insist on going there, and I will do so without protest. It’s not worth avoiding, but not one that I will seek out, personally.

Columbus Pizza Score = 5 Stars
World Pizza Score = 2 Stars
Compromise — I’ll give BPP 3 stars here.
I’m a pizza snob. I’m from all over. When I moved to Columbus, I could NOT find any good pizza. After a year of trying and asking around, I realized that Columbus-​style pizza attempts to mimic bad, lifeless, cardboard-​crust, cheapo, frozen pizza at the super market. That’s what it’s like…
Columbus, but the whole five years I lived here, I never found a good pizza. Apologies to the locals.
On a relative-​to-​Columbus scale, Bexley Pizza Plus is my go-​to. The crust is the least offensive (thin, non-​crispy) of the Columbus-​style pizzas. The toppings are fresh and plentiful, and they make the pizza work. Sauce is okay. I would prefer a bit more (but again, it’s Columbus-​style-​pizza, so maybe I just don’t get it).

This is my husband’s and my go-​to place for pizza. We live in Bexley and this is the best pizza for us in the area. Yes, it’s a little expensive, but very good. The mega meat is RIDICULOUS.
They’ve also been good to me in terms of switching out the regular pizza cheese for feta cheese ’cause I can’t have cow’s milk.
I’ll be honest, though. If Dewey’s, Harvest, or Bono were near by, I’d go there instead. Or if they delivered. But they don’t.