Massey’s Pizza

I have been meaning to order this soon. This is Massey’s Godfather deep dish pizza and I guess I can say it was worth the wait. It’s not Donato or Domino’s or Pizza Hut. It’s distinct on its own and the flavors are there. It is satisfying and delicious.

By far the best pizza I have ever had. I used to be a fan of Donatos because I prefer a thin & crispy crust, but Massey’s tops Donatos by far. Their cheese & sauce is amazing & the crust is perfect! I particularly LOVE their BLT pizza & I always get my regular (pepperoni, mushroom, & banana pepper). My dad lives in Florida now & when he comes home he would always request Donatos, but now he is a Massey’s guy ever since I put him on to their pizza. Seriously best pizza I have ever had, hands down!

Ordered a sub for the fourth time this summer and waited an hour and a half for it when they said an hour. Asked if I could have a discount or a free sub for my weight and they said no way. Don’t understand the business model of having a customer and multiple customers at my business frequent their place and now they want to not how about a customer. Wish I could still go there because the sub quality is very good but it seems like they don’t care about the customers. just order Jimmy John’s it’ll be way faster

This Massey’s buffet has a better variety of pizza compared to the one in Westerville. That’s odd considering it the same owner. The buffet is great. Pizza, sub, salad, pasta and a drink. The punch card is a great pick-​up for the lunch buffet. I’ll be back again and again.

We ordered the large thin crust pepperoni pizza and the Pizza Deluxe sub. When I first had Masseys it was eleven years ago and I wasn’t a fan. However after trying more pizza places I have to say I really liked it. The crust is crisp the pepporonis are ample and the sauce is tomatoey. I could use more sauce and cheese but I really liked it especially with lots of pepporonis and the crisp crust. The sub was loaded with lots of toppings and was very good not excellent one I’ve had elsewhere but very good. Anyhow now that I realize I do like their offerings I’m going to try more in the near future with my family’s blessings!

always needs more sauce for me. the crust can be hard at times. pepperonis are toasted well. again I have had the best pizza in NYC so im comparing them to Lombardos.

Had a large pepp, guido sub and cheesy bread. Can’t go wrong with the pizza. Cadillac of pizza! The sub was wayyyy above average. One of the best I’ve tasted

I love their pepperoni pizza!

Friendly delivery guy… pizza was meh. I couldn’t eat it and won’t order from them again.

I went back again the other night to get another sub. It was the same one I had the last time, the Italian. I’m not sure what the problem was but this time it wasn’t nearly as good. Undercooked, is my guess. So I’m nocking it down a couple of stars and probably not going to come back here for a good while. Maybe never.

Massey’s is yummy pizza for a good price.
Try their lunch buffet, its $ 7.50 for all you can eat pizza, salad, and pasta, and that includes a soda whether you want it or not.
Sometimes they are a bit slow getting pizzas out but they’re delicious so you won’t mind much.

Growing up my parents rarely ate out. Maybe every four to six weeks we would get a pizza and our occasional family treat was a Massey’s pepperoni pizza. As a little kid, Friday night Massey’s pizza night was about the best way to start a weekend. Over the course of living in central Ohio all my life I have tried almost all of the Massey’s Pizza locations and the Beechcroft location is my personal favorite. But I’m concerned that might not continue to be the case.
From the mid-​2000s to 2012, my wife and I have walked into this Massey’s location enough to get to know the people that were making our pizza. Our two family favorites are the pepperoni extra cheese and mexican Pizza. Over time, in talking about how we preferred their location they told us the «secret» of how they make their crust crispier than other locations. And for an edge-​to-​edge style pizza this has always been one of my top all-​time pizza’s. And this Massey’s location was a bit better than the others.
But during 2013 it seems like there has been significant personnel changes and the pizza seems to have lost a little bit. Maybe they didn’t leave their secret in the notes. A few months ago we ordered a pizza that was almost devoid of sauce and when we called them back, thinking that perhaps we had been given the wrong pizza, the person explained, «The pizza sauce tonight was really watery» so cooking the pizza probably «caused it to evaporate.» Really? You served watery pizza sauce to paying customers? Hmmm… here is an idea… throw away the bad can of pizza sauce before serving it to anyone. Open a new can of sauce. Don’t serve watery sauce to paying customers.
They did end up replacing our pizza and in all fairness we have tried the pepperoni pizza twice since then and it’s been fine so hopefully the problem won’t occur again. But still… the new employees decision making is kind of worrisome.
My other concern is the neighborhood. I personally feel that the neighborhood and that strip mall are not safe a night… or, apparently even early evening if recent experience is anything. I was there with my wife a few weeks ago around 7 pm… still plenty of daylight left, and over the course of 5 minutes there were cars driving through the strip mall at 50 miles an hour, squealing to a stop outside of a story, running in… then two more cars pulled up, ran in… they all left and returned one more time again at speeds approaching 50 mph. I peeked over to see the store clerk or owner appearing relaxed and not… afraid like there was a gun pointed at his head. I mentally was preparing to grab my wife and run back into the kitchen if bullets started flying. I could see the local news crew interviewing me… «So what were you doing when the gun fire began…» and trying to think what I would say that wouldn’t sound stupid… «Uh… getting a pizza.» Awesome. Man risks life, wife’s life for pizza. Film at 11. I was about 60 seconds from grabbing my wife, leaving dinner behind and just getting the heck out of Dodge when our pizza was pulled out of the oven. My wife grabbed the pizza box and heard me yell, «Don’t bother to check it, we gotta’ go.»
So, enjoy this location during the day. Up through 2012 I would have given this location 5 stars. But in 2013, this has definitely been a 4 star location.

Good Neighborhood pizza place, very glad they are still in the neighborhood. Love the plentiful pepperoni and corn dusted crust.

Not quite the Cadillac of Pizza their ads boast. Palatable, but the sauce is unremarkable, the crust is standard issue, and the two times i’ve gone to the lunch buffet, it seems they expect people to wait for an hour as they slowly expedite pizzas to the feeding trough. And the price was high for so little mediocre food.