Your Pie

The pizza from here is amazing. Went with a friend and had the special for this month peach bruschetta and the spicy chicken both were excellent. Tuesday nights is a special you get chips and drink with your pizza. Very good!

The pizza I got from here was probably the most average pizza I’ve ever had. It was good, but the thing about bad pizza is that it’s still pretty good. It’s definitely subway-​like in that you can pick all the ingredients on your pizza, but it’s also subway like quality. I’d eat here again, but would not seek it out.

Taste: B+
Service: B+
Quality: B+
Cleanliness: A–
This place is like Subway for Pizza; you get it your way (more or less). After you place your order for one of their special «pies,» you can tell the person behind the counter exactly what you want on your pizza. The only thing I didn’t like was the fact that some toppings like sausage costed extra and they didn’t tell me until I was at the cash register. You can choose the pizza dough as white or wheat. Both are made right in front of you. My only complaint is that it is made a little too thin, almost to the point where the pizza slices just droop and snap off when you pick them up. Prices are reasonable with most pizzas coming out to about $ 8 – 9. But these pizzas are small enough that one person should be able to finish one off solo. So in that respect some may consider them pricey. Taste is good, especially because you choose what you want on top. But with the short amount of time the pizza spends in a shallow oven, you can’t really expect it to taste like genuine New York pizzas. After the workers ring you up and serves you your pizza, there is zero additional service. Not even a «thank you come again!» when you leave.

See this right here is why I love Unilocal!I got a surprise call from the Mister asking me to drive down to Columbus for the Fourth og July weekend.
I wanted to try a new spot and in less than 5 minutes other Unilocalers lead me here. I am so happy that I listened to y’all. We left Fido at the hotel and decided to grab a bite
My eyes are wider than my belly so the first thing I said was 6 inches? WTH am I gonna do with that? Yes only 6 inches ladies. :)
Anyway, you pick your dought white or wheat, then your sauce, and then you come to the Subway like veggie spread and pick out your toppings. I got a bunch of veggies, chicken, gorgonzola cheese on regular dough w marinara sauce. He got wheat dough with every meat known to man and a few veggies.
The pizza was assume. The music was GREAT. The create your oen flavor Coke soda machine was fun as usual. You can sit inside or out. Pets were welcome outside on a leash. There is seating up and down the strip for eating or relaxing.
I must say that I give this place a 3.5 Star because a lot of the veggies were not as fresh looking as I’d like for them to be. But they were still good.

This was a great stop for a custom thin crust pizza and I loved the Nat special. We also had 3 other custom combos that were awesome. The staff were friendly. It is in a great area and has outdoor seating too. It was a memorable stop before leaving this town! Thank you!

It’s okay but I do not see what the hype is all about. One girl wrote that it is like «subway for pizza» but gave it 4 stars. For the price it does not deserve 4 stars. The crust is not very good and the toppings just did not seem that fresh or tasty. Honestly, even though its a chain, go to Mellow Mushroom and get a MUCH better pizza.

Food is insanely good. Service is nice. Gelato is a nice touch to great food! I love coming here when I have time off from work bc my kids always have a great time!

Excellent pizza and at a kick ass price. Thin, crips and tasty crust with no flop when picked up. Outstanding favors on the Southern Heat version. Will be back when in town.

My friend described it best: Your Pie is like Subway for pizza. I’m so glad we made this stop for lunch on our way through downtown Columbus. Just like Subway, you can choose from the menu or you can build your own. I kept it simple and ordered The Nat, basically because I’m obsessed with anything that has feta cheese. It was delicious! The only difference between Subway and Your Pie (besides the obvious sandwich vs. pizza) is they actually bring your food out to you when it’s done.
They also have one of those Coke machines where you can choose from like a zillion flavors, but I had to go for the sweet tea because it’s the south, duh. I just wish there were some locations closer to my home!

Good and service was great! Wish there was one near me. Loved the pizza and a great salad.

Awesome pizza and quick!

I was looking for a quick dinner spot for the family. My daughter is 19 months old and she losses what patiences she does have after 30 minutes or so. When we got there the service was good and the food selection for a small pizza place was great. We ordered our food and had dinner delivered within 10 minutes.
Good things– close to river walk!, good selection of food, great service, fast delivery time.
Not so good things– the restaurant gets extremely warm in the summer and there is no real air circulation, pizza size is only 12 inches, smaller restaurant and seating can be a issue.
If your looking for quick food that is good with great service this restaurant is for you!

Excellent place for lunch! Menu is very clear and they have plenty of options to create your own pizza. Gelato is a bit expensive with a small serving size but definitely worth it. Good atmosphere and friendly and helpful wait staff. Doesn’t take too long for food to come either.

Sunday night in Columbus doesn’t have many options. We ate here on valentine’s day weekend after a long day on the Riverwalk. Create your own pizza, what’s not to love? We enjoyed the food, but I had an awesome time playing foosball in the back!

First time here, wasn’t expecting the «subway» of the pizza world. But We ordered two of their signature pizzas and they were made pretty fast. They also sell beer. So that’s always a plus when you have pizza. I like this place. I would recommend it for anyone that likes a brick oven pizza.

Very friendly staff. Good pizza… and awesome drink machine :) all you need in a restaurant

While in Columbus on business, I needed a change of pace from fried Southern food. Fired up the trusty Unilocal app, and this branch of Your Pie was less than a block away from my hotel. It was a good find, a fast-​casual brick oven pizza outlet. Ordered a personal size pie with several meats and veggies. Added a mini flight of microbrew 4 oz samples, total cost less than $ 20. Good deal! Both beer & pizza were very tasty and hit the spot! Definitely head back here the next time work takes me back to Columbus! Someplace to repeat and recommend!

Not too bad. Apparently this is a small-​ish chain, and considering that, it feels like pretty good pizza (but not excellent).
Thin crust and brick oven-​style. You can choose one of their recommended pizzas or can build your own without a lot of difficulty or complicated pricing.
Pizzas are individually sized.
Worth a try.

Really surprised at this place!
Like other fellow Unilocalers have already said, it’s kind of like a Subway restaurant, but for (personal-​sized) pizzas! The pizzas we ordered here were delicious and the ingredients were super fresh. The employees were also very helpful and knowledgeable and explained their concept to me so that I knew what I was doing.
If you want beer and wine, Your Pie has you covered.
They also have gelato available! It was pretty good, but I wouldn’t stop here just for the gelato.
Very cool concept!

3.5 stars, maybe 3.75 for the overall experience.
Good pizza, designed by you, cooked to order with lots of fresh ingredients to choose from. Great for Columbus. If you’ve ever had truly world-​class, 5 star pizza, though, you’ll agree that YP is simply 3.5 stars.
YP also has a nice selection of craft brews on tap.
For the best of the best look for Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana certification, or when in ATL try Antico for pizza that is as close to 5 stars as you’ll find anywhere. Also try Taconelli’s in PHL, Frank Pepe’s in New Haven, or maybe Grimaldi’s in Brooklyn.