Original Brooklyn Pizza

I’m going to start off by saying I have been wanting to try this place out for a long time but since I started working 2 jobs it is very difficult to get around and try good food, well I was in the area on my day off and was like it’s time I try it and I am glad I did, I walk in I was greeted very pleasantly and I asked for a slice and 2 knots not to hot, pizza was amazing the sauce was perfect that sweet sauce not that overly oregano-​ee salty sauce and both pizza and knots were cooked perfectly I will def be back cat wait to try a whole pie!!!
(Pizza fatto grande lavoro giusto!!)

I order a pie… with peperoni and meatball on it… to be delivered… Almost 30 dollars… BUT…there was one slice of pepperoni and one slice of meatball per slice… I dont mind paying… but for what I got… it was ridiculous. I will never go there again… if I paid 30 bucks and it was loaded like most every other place… I would not mind… but once sliver of each per slice for that price… you are out of your mind… there are too many other places that are really good and dont rob you for toppings… you lost a customer today by saving a few pennies on toppings… insanity…

They have the best garlic knots. They are small so get at least a dozen. It’s hard to just eat one. They have a great plain slice. Whenever I’m in the area, It’s a must have.

Not my favorite place and I think the prices are a little high. A couple years ago there was a temporary increase on the price of chicken and Original Brooklyn raised the prices of all food containing with chicken.
The service is generally slow and small proportions.
On the positive side, I believe they deliver with a minimum payment.
I dispute the post that says the people that work here are rude, they have always treated me great!

Awful, cold pizza and even worse service.

They are a bunch of assholes. They screwed up my order and when I called they basically hung up on me and I was polite. Screw you Brooklyn.

This is great pizza. I even took it on an 8 hour car ride to Buffalo so I can have some New York pizza up there. That’s another story, but I would definitely recommend this pizzeria. I also love their baked ziti pasta slice, but it is a little filling for lunch. They have ample seating in the back.

Best pizza in the neighborhood, fast delivery. The calzones, pizza and rolls are excellent too! Looking forward to dining there and trying more of the menu.
Extra points for very friendly and accommodating staff

Ohhhhh Brooklyn Pizza, you have no idea how much I tend to miss your baked ziti when I fly back to Miami. Brooklyn Pizza is awesome. I’m a fan of their pizza, calzones and baked ziti. The other day however, I think I ordered wrong, because I asked for my baked ziti to have meatball sauce. I’m not sure how I messed up, I’ve ordered it once or twice like that before, but instead of their regular tomato sauce I wanted beef in it; they sent me actual meatballs aside from the baked ziti. I ate the meatballs anyways and they were delicious too.
We always order delivery, and the delivery person usually arrives within 20 minutes. Never takes any longer than that and food always arrives hot. Love the service and the food.

Way too over priced. They dont make the pizza look too appitizing, specialty slices lack topping and u have to bend down or look over the counter to see what they have. One of those places where they try to ring u up and u already paid already via another employee. Dont let their spiffy name throw u off. Lame pizza for commack IMO. Rather travel few more miles to dolce vita in DP.

Great gluten free pizza! Which is hard to find for us with gluten sensitivity. All other food was great too.

Their food is delicious and I was served by an excellent waitress named Katie. She was very pleasant and knowledgable of the menu. I had the chicken parmigiana and it was one of the best I ever had. If you are near the Mayfair shopping center definitely worth stopping in.

Worst pizza I’ve ever had!!! BROOKLYN PIZZA WOW WHAT A LIE!!! Grossly over priced! I would never recommend this place nor will I ever go there again! What a mess!!!

Their delivery sucks. I plceed an order was told 45 – 60 mins, I waited an hour and forty minutes before I called to complain because at this point I have been more then reasonable and they cope an attitude and say its because the snow then they deliver soggy food and a cold hero that for some reason they heated up after 2 hours. I only order from there because I’m at work. I will never order from there again because 3 weeks ago my coworkers order a pie, calzone and soda, took over 2 hours15 minutes pizza was cold, calzone cold and had to be thrown out it was soggy on the bottom and the cheese fell through the bottom and they forgot the soda. We cant leave to pick it up as we are at work. Never again.

Plain pizza and garlic knots = delicious! Will definitely be back. Garlic knots are small so you probably want to order more Recommend trying it!

This is my local Pizza joint. Its a family ran business bringing the best Pizza an Italian family can give. Much better than the cross town favorite of many, Emilios.

Went there because outback steakhouse in the area was crowded. But this turned out to be a really good pizza! The crust was crispy. The cheese was perfect. We had pepperoni and mushroom and it was amazing! will definitely come back here the next time I want a good pizza.

New fav pizza place. Brooklyn pizza is actually legit. Thin crusted plain pie, not overloaded with sauce or cheese. This is how pizza should be made. If they had a brick oven this place would be (uhoh) **orgasmic***!!!

Great Pizza!!! We ordererd half plain, half pepperoni. Garlic knots are delicious, not too garlicky or salty, just right. They were kinda small, so order enough! Pepperoni pinwheels are good too. I highly recommend!
The best part about this pizza place, is the fact that yesterday we had a blizzard and today while other locations are still digging out, bklyn pizza is delivering! That’s dedication. They made our day!!! Thank you Brooklyn Pizza!