Andy’s Frozen Custard

I did the drive-​thru. I ordered a small vanilla cone, and the summer special, strawberry shortcake. The service was a bit slow, and the server didn’t seem to care much. However, I found my strawberry shortcake satisfying, and my baby happy with his cone. That’s all that really matters I guess.

Came in for icecream for my babysit 3^rd birth day. place is nice. And I got the stolen brawny. its very good. Loved it. this place is very family orientated and will come back every chance I get…

Absolutely SHIT!!! Poor service … They CANNOT handle the crowd !!! Poor management!!! Dirty uniform… OVERALL $ 12 shot to shit… I could have wiped my ass with my money and have made better use of my dollars !!!

After driving past Andy’s numerous times since it opened, yesterday evening my fiancé and I decided to go in for a sweet treat after running errands. I was surprised with the great customer service we received. I have absolutely no idea what I wanted and I informed the cashier I would need a while as I sat down to look at the menu. She asked me questions about what I like and what I don’t, and I ended up with the strawberry-​banana custard with a mix of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. My fiancé then went through the same and we ended up with delicious treats. The woman who helped us was so friendly and nice, we had a great whole experience. We will be back!

OKAY, so i’ve been coming here since opening day. SOME workers are nice and very friendly. I usually come here in the afternoons with friends. This recent visit I had was different. The black girls working there were just plain out RUDE. Piece of advise to who ever is hiring these hoodrats, please do your JOB INTERVIEWS RIGHT. Good customer service will keep business running.
Piece of advice to the hoodrats, this is country side, meaning calm upper class town, this is not the hood, this is not the ghetto, this is not the projects where you get to come and act trashy and uneducated. Get your little ghetto rolling eyes attitude right before they get stuck in the back of your head. Never encounter bad attitude here UNTIL these trashy ghetto girls. Treat your customers with respect, not the way you would treat your mother. Don’t forget, its US THE CUSTOMER that puts money in your wallet, and if you don’t like serving frozen custard and its to hard for you quit and go flip burgers. As easy as 1 2 3.
When I walked in I waited for about 5 minutes before the chick came out from the back, mind you, the other one was making the frozen custard, didn’t greet us didn’t say anything just kept working, i’m looking at her like are you going to do your job or do I have to go around and serve my self? Keep in mind, NO ONE WAS IN THERE BUT US. Than here comes the other one from the back, «IS YALL READY?»… What? really? oh god its one of those… I ordered a large vanilla frozen custard and the chick said what kind? VANILLA FROZEN CUSTARD was she deaf? she said CUP OR CONE with her ghetto attitude, thats not a KIND stupid. When I got my cup, it was filled almost all the way up, really this is a large? I guess making it and serving it is hard. I could of said something and make her do her job right so she can LEARN and get it right the next time but why should I do someone else’s job. Train these slow workers right andy.
I will continue to come here because I can not allow two disrespectful tricks to take over my patience and hopefully I wont encounter the same issue with these low class trash of workers or it will be a problem. ANDY’S get it right when hiring road kill. I know you have to hire all races but come on you couldn’t have missed the ignorance when you did interviews with these two. By the way this was a week ago.
Other than that, I LOVE ANDY’S FROZEN CUSTARD. It is the best ever, and i am so glad they stay open during winter. Good job andy’s, on the secret frozen custard recipe, of course.

I love a good zebra cone — Andy’s doesn’t do soft serve, only scoops. So I will get a simple cone with one scoop choc and one scoop vanilla. In it’s simplicity, it is so perfect. Creamy, wholesome, delicious flavor. Silky on your tongue. Satisfying. Yum. Andy’s has the best frozen custard.
You order at the window if you use drive thru.

Andy’s will redefine what you believe to be good ice cream. They serve thick, rich frozen custard that puts all other ice creams to shame. Their menu consists of different sundaes, concrete mixers, and bottled sodas. Though the price is slightly more than you’re used to paying, it is well worth it!

They offer anything and everything ice cream at Andy’s! Sundaes, shakes, malts, concretes, cones, floats, Italian ice… I’ve been to this location a couple times and always have been satisfied.
Service is quick and they’re open pretty late. It’s really, really cold inside. So order your ice cream of choice and head outside to enjoy!

I love this place. The customer service is friendly and fast. I do feel that some items are a bit over priced. But hey. I don’t mind paying a bit more for great service and a yummy treat.

Went back to Andy’s yesterday for a custard and asked if they had an itty bitty cone to I had something to give my pooch’s in the car They have a FREE sample cone. I was willing to pay for it but they gave it to me for free.
NICE JOB Andy’s…really NICE JOB.

Fresh custard with eggs and whole milk topped with CANNED fruit.

Stopped in after seeing the rotating ice cream cone sign while in town visiting family. My mom and I both ordered ice cream sodas (vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup & seltzer water) — she got the small, I got a large. While the flavor was good, the employee only filled our cups barely ²⁄₃ full! The restaurant was totally empty, we were the only ones in there, so it’s not like she was in a rush and accidentally didn’t fill the cups all the way with seltzer. For the price, I expected a full cup, not ²⁄₃ of a cup.
Overall, this place is nothing special. They only have vanilla and chocolate… Sure, they have lots of toppings, but I don’t see how Andy’s is any better than Culvers frozen custard.

I wonder why this place is rated lower than I thought. Otherwise, this is a wonderful ice cream shop! The ice cream is absolutely delicious. I would prefer any flavor on their menu! Ice cream is creamy, and has good flavor! The service is good, and the staff are friendly. I actually saw a person I know working there one afternoon (didn’t expect)! I recommend it to anyone who hasn’t been to Andy’s Frozen Custard.

It’s all in the density. This is THICK frozen custard. And it tastes great. Andy’s calls their specialty treats «concrete», but I’m not in love w/​the toppings. I’m a purist. I go straight for the vanilla frozen custard.

Mmmmm, be prepared to indulge. I had a Mint Oreo concrete which was incredible — you definitely do not need anything larger than the smallest size. I tasted a bite of my friends strawberry as well which was delicious. Service was fast and friendly.

Eh my vanilla custard was no better than a vanilla cone from McDonalds, I’m sad to report, since I was pretty excited about this place. This doesn’t mean I won’t come back to try other flavors… will have an update later…

I lived in Wisconsin for 4 years so I am probably a more critical on my custard. First off, I have never seen such expensive custard in my life, especially since they only really carry one distinct flavor of custard. When I first walked in and saw the exuberant prices, I thought either this was not custard or there was something extremely special about it. Nope nope.
I ordered some sort of sundae. I never had a custard sundae before and I will probably never have one again from Andy’s. I didn’t hate it, but I felt it was overpriced and had a terrible ratio of custard to brownie/​cake. It started off tasting really good with a sweet cold mix of chocolate and custard. It became more and more difficult to eat as you realize that there was hardly any custard to begin with and the sundae turned into a soggy brownie/​cake.
Andy’s is probably just as good as Culver’s custard. Yeah, Andy’s has a pretty sweet atmosphere, and I would probably bring a date to Andy’s instead of Culver’s, but it just hurts paying such a premium for some average custard.

I love, love, love their vanilla custard. I can eat it with fresh fruits or even plain it’s awesome.

I really liked the custard here. I had the Bootdigger which was a concrete with oreos, caramel crème and hot fudge. I think the custard is better here than at Culver’s, but I like having the other food options at Culver’s. However, overall I still prefer DQ blizzards over a concrete :)
The restaurant itself has a drive-​thru and plenty of parking. I was a little put-​off that the cashier took all of our orders without entering them into the computer, then tried to recite them back to us, got a few things wrong, and then entered them into the computer… we still ended up getting large concretes instead of mediums, which is a small thing, but was more calories and cash than we intended on spending. I’ll probably be back if I am in the area as an impulse, but I don’t think Andy’s will ever be an intended destination.

Stopped in tonight with the kids for a treat and we were very impressed. Kids both had the Lil Digger Kids Sundae and they loved the gummi worms and Oreo «dirt». We shared the turtle sundae and probably should have each gotten our own, it was so good! I see the other reviews comparing the cost to Culvers, we have never had dessert at Culvers, but we found the cost to be on par with Cold Stone or Red Mango. Kids sundaes were $ 3, the large turtle was $ 6.70.