Forever Yogurt

Still love it here! Awesome flavor rotations. Coconut, peanut butter, and pistachio nailed it!

The yogurt was so watery, it would have barely passed for a slushy. Plenty of other yogurt places within 1 block of this spot, so go to one of those instead and save yourself the pain of trying to muscle through $ 8 of watery tasteless mush.

For some reason, the people of La Grange really like frozen yogurt, ice cream and those sorts of treats A LOT. Enough to put four different but very similar places all on one block. Since we had been to the others, we decided to try this yogurt shop out. The first thing we noticed was the smell– to be honest, it smelled like a dog… a wet dog. However, I looked past that as much as I could once I saw the row of treats. There were many flavors to choose from, including pistachio, watermelon, cheesecake and the usual flavors. Along with this, there were two stations for toppings– one with lots of candies, the other with candies AND fruits. There were plenty of selections and they were quite delicious, I must say. However, the stench was quite strong, so if you are pregnant or have a particularly strong sense of smell, you may want to think twice before heading there to indulge in your frozen yogurt craving.

I was actually too full from dinner to order a proper serving of yogurt here, but I did sample three flavors.
Tart: I thought this tasted like cream cheese, which weirded me out a little. It was different from the expected Asian-​tart flavor. I’d give this a rating of .
Green Tea Honey: literally tastes like the name, so this gets a ⁵⁄₅.
Mango: 5/​5, for being so delicious and true to the mango flavor.
I’m slightly apologetic for trying more than two flavors (sorry-​not-​sorry), but after the Tart, I just felt disappointed and knew I needed to try one more… I am incredibly impressed that they offer nondairy selections as well. Someday I’ll come back with an empty stomach :)

Went here at 7 pm on a Thursday and they had no basic flavors. No chocolate, no vanilla, etc. Poor planning.

So, in general, its good. My wife and I loooove froyo but honestly, I found it hard to find a great flavor. The dutch chocolate was great but I wasn’t particularly impressed with the flavours. The location is amazing! It is in the middle of a couple of cute shops and during the weekend it is filled with families and kids running around. It’s a fun location but the flavours aren’t impressive.

Though I found this place to be pricy for yogurt, I loved their flavors and toppings. Worth every penny. They also have lychee, which was an extra special treat with my traditional tart. I also recommend the Green tea. It’s like a frozen latte. Fantastic!

I recently had my son’s birthday party at Forever Yogurt and loved it! The back room with the chalkboard was clean, spacious and the perfect spot for a bunch of rowdy boys. The staff was polite, helpful and cheerful. The frozen yogurt is delicious, and the kids loved it! Definitely would recommend this!

Thought my kids were crazy to pop in for an after school snack on a cold day… boy was I wrong. The Hot Chocolate was too delicious thanks to the employee Meliza who recommended it! Also, the place wasn’t very crowded and the boys had fun drawing on the chalkboard walls. Soo many seasonal flavors of yogurt were fun to try (candy cane, pumpkin pie, eggnog). I’ll be back soon :)

I’m not hugely obsessed like some people are with frozen yogurt, but I had wanted to give this place a fair shake. There are 3 froyo options within a block in LaGrange, this is my second place I’ve tried.
Go figure, the place was totally empty on a Wednesday afternoon in December! It was nice for me, because I needed time to survey all my options– there were plenty to consider! The kind store worker gave me 3 mini cups to try a few samples of flavors.
Overall, I found the flavor options FAR superior to Red Mango (I found Red Mango to be very sour/​yogurty with their flavors). The yogurt/​cup/​toppings are weighed at the end to calculate your price, so if you go crazy on everything, it’ll cost you.
My favorite flavors were the Barista, Dutch Chocolate (OMG), and the Thin Mint. They were the «strongest» flavors I tried, which I loved. They have almost every kind of topping you can imagine as well! I feel like the toppings were sorted by «more kid friendly” — lots of cereal options, sprinkles and gummy candy, and «adult options” — salted caramel chocolates. raspberry chocolate, brownies, fruit pieces.
I will definitely return for a lighter fruit option next time, I think I overdid it with the chocolate this time (rookie mistake!!). Cute shop, really warmed up my day!

We love Forever Yogurt! They have great customer service and We love the ever-​changing flavor sand toppings. Definitely recommend! Much better than the small amount of flavors and toppings red mango has!

.29 cents an ounce
This place has become a regular stop when I am strolling around in Lagrange which is often during the summer. Splitting my time between Forever Yogurt and Red Mango has not been easy. Whenever I go to one, I feel guilty from missing the other. I feel the need for a yogurt threesome… Its a complicated affair. If this blows up I risk the chance of losing both. But continuing on, torn between Pecan Praline and Summer Peach, is about as hard as it gets. Since both places are only like 50 feet apart, this is what needs to be done. I promise to practice safe dairy techniques… clean cup… separate spoons… wiping off the table before and after the engagement. I will update this review if anything changes.

This place just opened this summer and I was waiting to try this place out since the first time I saw the sign up.
They did not disappoint. We were immediately greeted and asked if we wanted to learn about how the place works.
It works just about any other fro yo place.
There is a good flow so it doesn’t feel like a crowded mess when picking toppings.
They also have many different flavors, more then the red mango up the street and different, unique types toppings.
I purchased a groupon for $ 5 for $ 10 worth of fro yo and it was well worth.
They also have a rewards card, you get 1 point for ever $ 1 spent and when you get 50 points you get $ 5 rewards which is not hard to rack up considering it is 49 cents a ounce.

There are SO MANY different kinds of yogurt and they change them out regularly so every time you go there’s something different. The consistency of the yogurt is always great and the yogurt is a thousand times better than red mango. While this may be the third (or is it the fourth?) yogurt shop on Lagrange road, it is certainly the best.

I just received a wonderful message from the owner, the beads are coming back, I know I’m being a big baby but those popping beads made the experience so much better! Thanks Sam, we will be there next week!

Well. I can happily say that Forever Yogurt does have a customer rewards program and I just signed up online! For that I’ve upgraded them to 5 stars! Just go to
, click on Forever Fan and follow the prompt. Good Stuff!

Forever Yogurt is another fun self-​service frozen yogurt place. I think they are better than Red Mango, I don’t think they beat out Yogurt Land. But I do like them better than every other frozen yogurt place that is out there now. We had their pink lemonade and watermelon which was a great combination. I felt their yogurt was bit on the icy side but the flavors were tasty and fun.

There’s quite the froyo competition here in La Grange. Red Mango is right next door but if you have to choose, I’m inclined to go for Forever Yogurt. There seems to be a more varied selection, and the staff is super friendly.
The staff were quick to greet my family and offer us sample cups to try the different flavors available. There was even a maple bacon flavored yogurt. Apparently the bacon craze has gone mainstream. No matter how many flavors they have, I always find myself going back to the tried and true, original euro tart froyo. Topped with some strawberries and mochi, and I’m in summer heaven.
There’s tons of seating indoors, and there’s even a wall made out of chalk board which you can doodle on.
Fun place to come to calm your stomach and shoot the breeze!

amazing design and great yogurt! the staff is super friendly too

Great selection of yogurt and toppings.