Pizza Palermo

Extremely nice on the phone. Ordering was quick and easy. Delivery was super quick which was surprising with the time that I placed my order. I ordered a small Steak Calzone and it tasted amazing. Definitely recommend to anyone in the Crafton area. Easily one of my favorites around.

Pizza Palermo, you are by far the best pizza shop I’ve ever eaten at. You have the best ingredients and great cooks and they are really friendly and polite. Quick takeout and delivery times and always on time or before the time they give to you for delivery. Keep doing what you’re doing!

Fresh, fast, delicious! Using only the freshest ingredients! Home made ranch the best in town!!! Prices always reasonable, food never expensive!

Ordered here before and it’s decent pizza for a reasonable price. Ordered tonight and two long hairs in my half hoagie… Called to let them know and I was told that only men were working and there is no way it could’ve been from there… Disappointed in how they reacted and made it seem like I was lying about hair in my hoagie. Think I’ll be taking my business elsewhere from now on.

We get pizza from here every Sunday and well never again. We pulled in at 12:10 am and the door the says open till 1 am. Once the employees seen us they ran to shut the lights off. Really change your hours if you are not open till 1 am.

When Pizza Palermo first moved in to the old KFC location, I was skeptical. With a slogan like «Its X-​Traordinary!» I wasn’t very hopeful. The fact that their takeout special of a large pizza with one topping went up a buck within the first couple of weeks wasn’t exactly a confidence booster, either. But, as things will happen, I finally got curious enough to give it a shot a few months after its initial opening.
I have to say, I was pleasantly surprised with the pizza here. The sauce is a little on the sweeter side, the cheese is just greasy enough, and the dough isn’t overly chewy. The pies I’ve had with pepperoni have been quite good, and the Italian sausage that Palermo’s uses is mildly spicy, which I found to be a nice surprise. I also like the little cup of ranch dressing you get with every pizza. It complements the taste of the slices nicely.
The breadsticks are also quite good with just enough of a garlic dusting and not overly greasy. However, the rest of the stuff I have had at Pizza Palermo is just mediocre. The chicken wings are nothing to get excited about. They taste exactly like you would imagine them to. Kind of gummy (they’re not fried here) with too much sauce dumped on top (a little BBQ sauce goes a long way, guys) and a bit of stretchy skin. Meh.
The sandwiches are hit and miss as well. The first time I had the steak and ranch hoagie, it was rather tasty. The second time there wasn’t as much meat and not enough dressing on it, so it was rather dry. The chicken parm hoagie was a complete miss. It’s made with chicken tenders, most of the ones which wound up on mine were rubbery and had way too much gristle on them. Pass.
The staff here is friendly, and whether I’ve ordered by phone or line, the quoted time to pick it up given to me was always correct. This is usually an average of 20 minutes. In fact, every time I’ve gone in to pick up my order, it was ready before I even got there, so I will say that these guys are efficient at cranking out ordes for pickup. I haven’t tried delivery, so I can’t comment on that.
There are some tables at this location, but it doesn’t really feel like a place you’d want to eat in, just as much as the old KFC there was mainly about takeout. It is nice and clean though, probably more so than when it was a KFC, so if you do decide to eat here, you don’t have to worry about crummy tables, sticky floors and the like.
So pizza and breadsticks = good, and everything else = done better elsewhere. I do like how close this location is to my apartment, but then I’m kind of in the center of everything in Crafton, so location is never much of something to complain about for me. But if you’re looking for pretty tasty pizza, Pizza Palermo is good, so give it a shot.

Friendly service (on phone, for delivery only), friendly manager who delivers and great pizza, Pizza Palermo doesn’t disappoint.
We order from here almost everyday for work meetings. The salads are fresh and can be customized to every ingredient level. 1 star subtracted since sometimes the instructions aren’t followed to a T, but ah well!

Don’t waste your time getting take out from here. When you actually eat at the restaurant. They actually take care of you, but the take out is a whole other thing. They say 45 min and I don’t expect them to be actually precise but it was am hr and a half. And the pizza and wings were horrible. There’s better pizza places out there For your value. Like Portofinos. Betos and. fioris top the list