Bennolli’s Pizza

I have been several times and the quality varies from great to ok. Different people making the pizzas? Not bad for a slice of pizza.

I really enjoyed the pizza here. We went with the take and bake option. Because it is small business I definitely recommend calling ahead. We walked in on a Saturday Night and it took about 20 minutes but well worth it. The fresh ingredients make this a more expensive option to Papa Murphy’s but definitely worth it. Also we had a coupon from the 2015 Entertainment Book.

Bread sticks are ok — they would benefit from a cheesy center. Chicken wings where well proportioned and fairly tasty. Pesto perfect pizza was good but was a little chewy.

I thought the pizza was delicious! You could tell it was homemade from the crust to the toppings. We tried the breadsticks and those were kind of bland. I wouldn’t recommend those but the pizza was great. I would definitely eat here again.

Good food but the staff isn’t friendly and food preparations were very unsanitary. They prepare everything with bare hands and one guy was rubbing his nose and then putting his hands into cheese and making pizzas, another was working the register touching dollar bills and getting back to making pizza with no washing hands in between. Really unpleasant to see.

I love the pizza from here! They use good ingredients, are quick, and reasonably priced. My favorite pizza is the All American, no black olives :) they also deliver or do take n bake. I’m glad they are just right down the road from me!

If you like NY style pizza, this is the best za in the lake country area. They also deliver! Always go with the large, leftovers are bomb.

Pretty tasty. I would say personally I enjoyed the buffalo chicken pizza the best. Price wise it isn’t bad at all. It has that pizza taste we all crave but can’t find. I would most definitely come back again.

Great pizza! Best pizza I’ve had since Italy! My husband and I have searched for a pizza like Italy… By far the best stateside :)

If you’re looking for great artisan pizza, look else where, however if mediocrity is satisfactory then look no further. It’s a shame because they have the crust perfected with a thin, soft, new York style, yet the toppings bear the same quality as those of pizza hut or dominos. In my opinion the toppings alone can make or break the pizza and in this case the perfectly square, flavorless pieces of sausage did it for me. Service is average, expect to wait 45 minutes for your pizza. Yet as I stated above the crust is perfect. I would order again based on the crust but would stick with a very simple pizza such as cheese.

The pizza is delicious. One of the best I’ve ever had. The prices are pretty steep though so I only eat it on special occasions.

Ive had this pizza a couple of times. A friend lives about 2 minutes down the road, so we picked one up, when they cooked it, it was good. So a few weeks went by and I ordered a par bake to take home, I was told no par bakes, only take and bake, Thats fine. I got home, put in the pizza stone and fired up the oven. Read the instructions, and cooked pizza for twice the amount of time as instructed. I guess that you cant use a pizza stone {that would have been nice to know} The toppings just slid off the bread {not really crust, think little caesars doughy} What a waste of 20 bucks! I also believe that this pizza is a «Papa Murphys take and Bake» that would only cost half as much, but in Delafield no one would buy a papa murphys pizza, so you call it another name and charge twice as much, Never ever going back there

Delicious pizza. Crust is amazing & they have lots of interesting toppings. Love the personal size pizzas too. If you are ordering for a group, it’s fun to get a couple different types so you can mix & match.

Honestly love this place. The food is wonderful and they have great wings as well. They have great personal pizzas. I work in a local business and I’m constantly going here to pick up food for my coworkers because everyone loves the food. You have the option of eating there as well which I’ve only done once and it’s cute. They don’t really wait on you but they do bring your pizza out. It’s nice in the summer though to sit in the outside area and eat as we’ll. but I highly recommend it. The pizza is grey and well seasoned. I’ve had pizza at Tony and Mia’s and its nothing compared to this. Also price wise it isn’t bad either!

After reading all the positive reviews, we were quite disappointed in the pizza. We ordered two large, one sausage onion and one pepperoni. Crust wasn’t crisp but rather soft and chewy, almost soggy. Very little flavor to the sauce and the sausage looked like the variety that you find on a frozen pizza. The pepperoni was very good with a fresh good flavor. Sorry to say, nothing about this pizza makes me want to return. Nothing wrong with the place was very clean and nice looking. the server was very polite. The pizza was just not up to our expectation. Nothing to make you say wow, this is great.

So delicious. We were pleasantly surprised by how good the pizza was. Would definitely eat here again.

Great pizza! Hand made and FRESH! Will go there again when in the area!

This place is a total mindfreak! Here’s why. It’s in Delafield, Wisconsin, and it has amazing pizza. MINDFREAK!
Seriously though, when I first tried a pie from this little joint in a strip mall, I wasn’t expecting much, mainly because if you run a very average restaurant in Lake Country, it’s usually in the running for best-​in-​class for the area. This pizza, however, would be delicious anywhere.
I love all pizza. The style served up at Bennolli’s is definitely my favorite, though. I love the thin yet puffy crust that is just a little crisp around the edges with super fresh toppings. This is a total win for me, and the marinara they’re putting out is bomb.
Speaking of marinara, you have to get some garlic breadsticks! They come hot and fresh, like little puffy straws of dough that are literally making my mouth water just thinking about them.
Fun Fact: you can take-​and-​bake, but I recommend getting it hot if you live close enough. Just try not to eat it all on the way home. Get some gelato, too!

I’ve missed Bennolli’s since I moved out of Delafield and was quite happy to get it for a Packer watching party at my in-​laws.
This place is pizza. Simply. As it should be: Hand-​made, real ingredients, and options ranging from the simple (and delicious) pizza margherita to the (quite American) Kitchen Sink or Barbecue Chicken.
The place is small, so don’t expect a large restaurant atmosphere. Still, there are a few tables inside and out if you are interested. I usually take it to go, so this rating is based on that. You could expect a four-​star experience inside.
Regardless, I can’t but recommend Bennolli’s. Go, take it or sit down, enjoy, and support a local business who does it better than any chain out there.

I live right down the street from this place, so the convenience makes it worth walking down the street for a pizza when I don’t feel like making one myself (which I do quite often) and as far as pizza goes, they make some good ones. I like the barbecue chicken pizza myself. They are not open as late as a late-​night pizza place, but Delafield is a small town, and really, if you’re in Downtown Delafield, this is your choice.