Fat Sully’s Pizza

I had a great experience here! Came in a group of three and ordered the family style salad and some slices.
I love how simple the menu is — salad and choose your own topping slices. That’s it. The salad was fine, but nothing special. There were some interesting dressings to choose from. The pizza was delicious! Thin, crispy crust while still maintaining good substance. And the slices are enormous. Highly recommend trying some pizza from here!

We’re both from Brooklyn, and have had every pizza in the neighborhood and surrounding areas, looking for a cheese pie similar to home. This is it. Disclosure, we didn’t like the pie we ordered with toppings, the toppings were too heavy for the thin slices… and then we tried the cheese. Very, very good. Very similar to NYC pizza. Bubbles on top, cheese almost dripping from grease (definitely not as greasy as NYC, where the oil drips off into cheesy goodness… but my arteries thank Fat Sully for using less oil). We’ve had them deliver many times, sometimes the pizza arrives not as hot as it should be but always as tasty as it should be. Skip the disappointing salad, make your own at home, and try the cheese pie.

Perhaps it is a better experience dining in, but we had a terrible delivery service. We live about four blocks away, however, it was cold and we were already in pajamas so we decided to try Fat Sully’s out for the first time and have a pizza delivered. It took two solid hours to deliver the pizza on a slow Wednesday night to a house that was a two minute drive away. Additionally, they didn’t read the delivery instructions telling them that the house was split into two apartments and to come to the apartment upstairs — instead, they woke up the tenants downstairs who were ill and in bed already. We heard them knocking at the wrong door and rushed out in the cold to make them stop.
Next up, the pizza was lukewarm, and nothing special — I would have been just as happy with Papa Johns, and it would have come a lot faster — but then the kicker was finding a hair in my first slice. We went and ate some left over rice and veggies after that. We won’t be ordering again.

Top shelf pizza!!! It takes a while (about 45 minutes) but it is well worth the wait. Service is outstanding and the beer/​drink selection is excellent. I’ve eaten at all three locations and they are all on par with each other. If you like/​want good pizza – I mean pizza that actually tastes good, looks good and is in a really fun yet relaxed environment – then this is the place for you. If you skip over this place you are making a huge mistake.

Came here on a Wednesday evening at 6:30. This large and scenic place had maybe 4 other groups there, so we did not have to wait at all. Conversely, Hops n Pie told us it would be an hour wait for two people! I’m glad we walked down the block to Fat Sully’s. The beer selection was decent, but the pizza was excellent. One of their huge slices was enough for me. I cannot imagine ordering a whole pizza unless you’re with a large group who all want the same thing. I had artichoke and sausage on my thin slice, and it was tasty. The staff was friendly enough. I’ll be back!

What isn’t there to love about Fat Sully’s? The vibe of the space is just fun and though this location is a bit more family-​oriented, it makes no difference. There’s still plenty of beer options, a centralized bar and of course, that GIANT pizza. We stopped in on a Friday night and though there were quite a bit of people waiting for tables, we were seated within 20 minutes. We ordered that 26″ pizza (because it’s so hard NOT to) and it was worth the wait. I hope to take advantage of the slice window one of these days.

Friendly on the phone and initially looked like a lovely pizza delivered to our door. Unfortunately, found a long hair in a slice – no recovering from that :(

We’ve eaten Fat Sully’s pizza more times than we should admit but it’s sooo good! Thin NY HUGE slices and you don’t have to wait long — less than 10 minutes — so you can get your pizza fix fast. The salad is great too — wouldn’t think to put banana peppers on a salad but it works! The whole pies are ridiculously large but somehow it will all get eaten. Eat here now and often :)

The slices are great and all the ingredients are really good. The salads look good too so I’m looking forward to trying one soon. One thing I wish they had was chicken as a pizza topping.

The service here was awesome as was the pizza. The slices and pies are HUGE! Good stuff.

Second time from this place. Online ordering is great. Pizza is great and it’s consistent. I’m from NY and can say this is spot on. But Forget New York, this pizza is just dang good. Try it!

I really like this place. I really do. It’s combines three of my favorite things under one roof. Service is always great, drink options are good. I just had one issue with the lack of toppings (only 3 small pieces of sausage on the slice) that I wish they would have fixed but instead the server argued with me that there was more under the cheese (there was not). It would’ve been an easy fix, but instead it turned me off to the place.

NY style, crisp, chewy crust. Ordered a slice of pepperoni and sausage for $ 5.25 — a little pricey, for a two topping slice, but it was pretty large. The locally made sausage was great. I was just disappointed there were only four pieces of sausage, but they made this right after I mentioned it. I thought the were going to bring me a couple more pieces, but they brought me a second slice. Next time, I plan to skip the pepperoni and order double sausage. If they cover the slice, I’ll be hooked.