Randy’s Pizza

What a joke! I went to this place at 12:30pm, the slice pies that they were selling slices from were at least 4 hours old. I suspect they were leftover from the previous evening. The guy behind the counter gave me some song and dance about them being made just before lunch. Needless to say, the slice was a greasy mess. I love NY Style pizza but, trust me, this isn’t it. This is pizza being sold by a careless owner to high school students! It’s clear why the dining room was 90% empty at 12:45.
Bottom line, save your money, go elsewhere.

Great and cheap NY style pizza, definitely hits the spot!
New york pizza is definitely my favorite style and Randy’s does it right. I’ve stopped by here a few times for a late takeout dinner around 9 and have always been satisfied. A single slice of cheese is 2.75 but their slices are enourmous, I usually just get 1, or 2 if i’m super hungry. Their pizza is great, topped with a bunch of melted cheese and a thin, crunchy, and chewy crust.
If you’re craving a super cheesy pizza that won’t break the bank I’d highly recommend you stop by Randys!

This has to be the reject of the Randy’s pizza chain. Not only did I wait 30 min for them to «reheat» the pizza, it still was cold and doughy. The female employee had on bracelets (more than 4) on her wrists which is not allowed per NC Food Code. Her hair was also floating around which could possibly have contaminated patrons pizza. Get it together people! I’ve never had this happen at the TW Alexander location!!!

Pizza ok, people taking and preparing the orders not great. Our pizza came late but was still warm. Would have been fine, but screwed up dressing, even though was written correctly on ticket.

I would definitely recommend Randy’s for New York style pizza. They have specials that change every weekday that are worth checking out, especially if you’re going with a couple other people, like their 16′ one topping pizza plus a full tossed salad for $ 19.99 on Thursdays. But to be honest, you’re almost better off getting their constantly available special, the 2 slices, a drink and garlic knot for I believe $ 6.99. The 2 slices are like a half of a pizza by themselves; it is truly outrageous. Foldably thin and almost unconscionably greasy but packs a super punch of flavor. The pizza is among my favorite in the area and being right next to Growler Grlz makes for a fun potential night of pizza and beer.

Best pizza place we have found in the triangle, and since I loved in New York I know what im looking for in a pizza. This place is so good they even put the other Randy’s locations to shame. Keep up the great work guys!

Best NY slice in the area! Slices tend to be better than pies, but not by too much. First extra topping on a slice is inexpensive. Other food is fine, but pizza is the main event here.

Took over an hour and half to get my two sandwiches delivered. Was told 45 mins. Food came cold and soggy. Didn’t even get everything we ordered and when we called back to let them know they argued with us. Will not be going back.

Great pizza! I almost cried on the pizza but I held back. Pizza slices are so large they sit on several plates. I wouldn’t lie to you! I’d put this 3^rd on my favorite pizza list for now. Never know when something else will pop up. I’ll definitely be visiting this location again. Tucked away in a quiet little location.

This was the first and last time I will attempt to eat at this establishment! Was told 10 – 15 min for my medium pepperoni pizza. 3 muscle bound Italian guys came in 10 min later, sat down and had their medium pizza at their table in 5 min! After waiting another 10 min I asked what the problem was. I was told my pizza had been put «on hold» but would be out shortly. I requested my money back needless to say… waste of time and disappointed to say the least.

We live ten minutes away from Randy’s.
We placed an order for delivery, and our address was confirmed by the operator. For delivery.
We waited 45 minutes.
We received a phone call telling us the pizza was ready but could not be delivered because «we do not live within the delivery area.»
We live ten minutes away from Randy’s.

This was my first visit to this location and my 3^rd visit total to Randy’s Pizza. I wanted to try the stromboli since I’ve already tried the pizza (pepperoni).
I walked in to place my order because I like my food to be piping hot when I take it home. It was a Friday night so I was happy to see it wasn’t overly crowded but there were plenty of people dining in. I waited about 10 – 12 minutes for my order which was fine because I was watching one of my favorite shows Diners, Drive-​Ins and Dives on the flat screen in the dining area. I’m such a foodie.
So back to the stromboli, it was exactly what I had been craving. Coming from a New Yorker, the stromboli actually tastes better than the pizza. The crust was nice and crisp on the outside but still soft on the inside. The stromboli was filled with plenty of mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms. Yes, it may be a little on the greasy side but it’s so worth it.
I would definitely return for the stromboli over the pizza.

The pizza was good but not great. Maybe it’s because I’m bitter from getting a $ 63 bill for two pizzas and a salad. Ummmmm what?!

If I could give this Randys location 10 stars I would. I called in today to place an order for delivery and Elijah I think that’s how you spell his name answered the phone he was very courteous very knowledgeable on their specials and their offerings and the best part is they deliver to my business location which is great news because I am so tired of eating chain restaurant pizzas I would definitely recommend this to anyone who lives in the area once a pizza from somewhere besides papa johns or even worse dominios. Everytime I order from this Randys the food and the service is great but todays order put them on list of Favorites. Honestly one thing that will keep me coming back is the customer service (and the pizza).

HUGE slices of NY Style pizza! The best around at great prices and great service. Always consistent. Lasagna pizza is really good. Chicken pita is awesome. A slice of anything will leave you happy!

Delicious pizza! The actual restaurant is a hole-​in-​the-​wall. I’d definitely recommend getting takeout.

What pizza can I buy that not only tastes ridiculous-​amazing and will last me for days? Randy’s Pizza!
I have ordered pizza from them countless times at this point, and have loved it each time. The way the pizzas are made are perfect — not too greasy, not all bonkers on the toppings or sauce, but just the right amount per slice. The 18″ size is totally worth the price. If the world ended in 3 days, I would have enough pizza to die with a full stomach.
My favorite?
The New York White with Spinach & Tomato:
Ricotta and Mozzarella Cheeses, Fresh Spinach, Diced Tomatoes, Chopped Garlic & Extra Virgin Olive Oil Infused Crust
Yep, now you wanna go and order one, don’t you?!
Weekends can get insanely busy, especially during football season. So call for a delivery or pick up before your stomach starts yelling at you. The garlic knots are a nice free add-​on, though they are a little too heavy/​carby for one serving. But they come free with a pizza purchase so why not?!
Mmmm… Dang it, now I want a Randy’s Pizza…

The only Randy’s pizza I eat at. I love this place when I want something quick. I’ve been coming here since high-​school and even then they had deals specifically for the students. Truly a business that cares!

If you consider grease to be a flavor, go to Randy’s. The pizza slices are the size of your head, but you’ll go through a mountain of napkins to blot the grease. The rest of the menu is pretty tasteless.

Unfortunately, this review is based on nothing but the service because my fiancé and I did not have the opportunity to eat the food after being so appalled by the way we were treated while at this place. We were both excited to grab a slice of pizza and heard good things about Randy’s so we ventured in.
When we walked in, there was a line of about 6 people ahead of us (not too bad). We stood in line and it was not moving… it probably took about 10 minutes for us to make it to the front of the line. Not once were we acknowledged for the entire 10 minutes… no «we’ll be with your shortly», NOTHING.
When we had finally made it to the front, we tried to order their number one meal (2 slices of pizza and something else) and we were told that they didn’t have slices right now!!! I’m sorry, but don’t advertise slices on your menu if you’re not going to sell them at certain times or when you’re busy. I didn’t wait 10 minutes in line just to be told I can’t order what I want! I probably will not be back (and if I am, it’s simply for the convenience of being near my house).