Blue Egg Bakery

I order from here frequently for my business meetings! They are always fresh and taste great. It is great prices and fabulous service.

Blue Egg bakery donuts are like heaven. They Crunch pretzel is the most amazing thing I have ever tasted. I love this small town bakery and my stomach is showing it.

The longer this place is here the worse it gets. When they first took over Dons Bakery I would have given them 4. Big shoes for them to fill. They were really good really supported them. Over time this place has gotten worse and worse. The lady fingers didn’t have any filling in them. They were all different shapes and sizes, there was no standard. Some smushed and some not. The cream cheese stick has no filling. Barely any chocolate drizzle on top. The fillings seemed like they were trying to get buy with as little as they could and were very sloppy when they were put in extremely uneven. It almost seemed like they were running out of filling and were trying to get buy without making another batch. I also got a cinnamon tube which is basically a tube of bread. There was barely any cinnamon in it at all. On top of which they used to have it already sliced for you and I guess now they don’t. I was extremely disappointed. I just really felt like they were trying to do the bare minimum on everything.

Wanted to like this local bakery but didn’t. Their cupcakes have too much Crisco frosting in ratio to the cake. Sorry, but $ 2.25 for a tiny cupcake that is mostly cheap frosting is simply too expensive.

Love Blue Egg Bakery for pastries. Recently bought a pumpkin pie and it was so good, I purchased another to serve for Thanksgiving.

I was in the area and came across these guys on Facebook. Admittedly, we came closer to closing time so the selection wasn’t as large, but I did enjoy the items we purchased.
The loaf of Wisconsin Cheddar bread we bought didn’t even last one day. It was THAT good. Hoping if I’m ever in the area again that they’ll have more of a selection available (or that I’m in town earlier!)

The caramel rolls, cinnamon rolls, and donuts are divine. Tried the cakes at my last visit and enjoyed those, too! Would be nice to have some room to sit and enjoy, but otherwise — a delicious treat!

Here’s the good: LOVE their cinnamon crunch cake donuts and cream cheese lady fingers. They are the real deal, super cute, local neighborhood bakery. New owners are offering expanded baked good options including slices of layered cake, cupcakes, different varieties of donuts, danishes and cookies. Here’s the could be better: consistency of product — we’ve tried new things and liked them never to find them again; seating area could have more stools, counters and floors could be cleaned more frequently; new staff isn’t as friendly as previous, are uninformed, and should use common sense when packaging product. Here’s the bad: they commonly run out of popular items before 9 am and don’t restock even though they are open until 6 pm then they make excuses if you mention it; the brewed coffee (the only coffee option) is weak and flavorless and sits in a glass carafe on a burner; they obviously use a mix of homemade and convenience items like frostings from a tub-​yuck!, and parking can be an issue sometimes. Still, I LOVE this bakery and go here every Thursday for the Red Velvet donuts.