Nancy’s Pizza

Wow. This place truly sucks. Ill never order feom here again. I ordered an italian beef for delivery. im at work. I work at a store here in a plaza literally 2 blocks away from the place. I ordered an italian beef for delivery. They took a hole hour and 30 minutes to deliver 1 measly beef. Why did it take so long when italian beefs r already ready to eat. O call the driver and he says they gave him the wrong address. Wtf. I was honestly gona keep ordering from here for my lunch break everyday but ill be ordering from the other pizza spot now. Forget this place.

Best pizza around. We order pizzas from there all the time and it’s ALWAYS AWESOME. Love this place!

I like this place’s deep dish pizza WAY better than Giordonos and Lou malnatis or other places I have tried. IT HAS SAUSE GAME and actually is more cheesier and has more flavor than the other joints I been too…

This place is destroying my waistline. But it’s totally worth it. We’ve only gotten the thin crust carryout — it’s seriously so freaking good. They send coupons in the mail and how could I possibly turn it down and NOT save $ 3 on an 18 inch?! So, as long as they keep sending coupons, I’ll keep making My Fitness Pal hate me.

Just had Hawaiian pizza and it was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Instead of tomato sauce there was ketchup. Cheese was awful. I’ve ordered without bacon so it was just awful cheese pineapple and this ketchup thing under the cheese. I gave them 2 stars instead of one because of the breaded cauliflower which was fine (dipping sauce they are adding it’s also not eatable)

Had pizza delivered. It was quick and still warm when received. It’s been a long time since we ordered from here and food was good like we remembered. Would order from here again, maybe even eat in their restaurant.

Pizza and calamari are amazing! We order from here 2 – 4 times a month.

Nancy’s pizza is one of the best in the western suburbs of Chicago. We order from them almost every week! Their pastas, entrees (chicken Marsala is my favorite), salads, soups and service are all excellent and consistent (both delivery and dinning in the restaurant — called Melina’s Trattoria). They always know my name when I call and offer great coupons. Dinning room is nice, delivery people are always friendly and have not delivered a cold or dropped pizza yet! If you’re looking for delicious, traditional italian food this is a great value!

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it once more. The stuffed pizza at this place is the best in the world. I simply don’t see how it can be improved. This is a classy joint all and all, with a solid menu. I really like how you’re treated by the employees and even the management. It’s a Great spot, I will be going back again and again. The general manager Nick deserves a shout out for running an awesome restaurant. Thanks a bunch, you’ve earned my continuous business.

I really liked the pizza here a lot. It was darn good. I split a large garlic, mushrooms and ½ sausage stuffed pizza w/​two of my friends and we were all satisfied by its taste, texture, portion and looks. ;-) The pizza sauce was blanketing the pizza pie properly and it had just the right savory taste. Wasn’t tangy or sweet. The cheese was oozing out, showing us that there was plenty of it. It was a good balance of sauce & cheese which is a must for me. What I didn’t find satisfying was the lack of garlic taste & flavorful enough sausage. Unlike the Niles location, this Nancy’s was reasonably priced. Service was great. I will be going back again for sure. It’s definitely worth your visit if you like Chicago style pizza. Check it out.

Gemma Disclaimer: This review is related to the delivery personnel only.
It is true; it has been awhile since I enjoyed a Nancy’s pizza. Location being the primary reason; and the advent of other prime pizza spots that peaked my interest and taste buds.
But on this occasion, when the wind was blowing horizontally, as we have grown to love here in the Chicago land area, I have one point. Thank you to the Nancy’s delivery driver in that giant red SUV who tailgated me mercilessly down Ardmore Avenue. I mean, where is the fire? We still both hit the North Avenue red at the same time. This is where those advertising miracles on the tops of vehicles come in handy.
Respectfully, my opinion about «Nancy» and her pizza offerings is still the same: I recall they were very good. Does this change my potential of ordering from «Nancy» again. No, not really. Perhaps they should consider some thermal packs that are a little more heavy duty, so the drivers don’t feel so much pressure. Perhaps, during the Holiday season, for the sake of peace on Earth a reminder is in order to take care.

Staff is rude on the phone so I decided to drop in. Staff is mean and treated me like I was not keeping their business open with my money, host is mean and arrogant. Wrap it up with the suburban joint.

We had a luncheon there yesterday. Twenty plus folks. Food was delicious, staff was attentive, and price was right. We ordered from the menu which is highly unusual for so many people in the party. We had burgers, pizza, pasta, chicken, and ribs. I heard not one complaint. I would highly recommend this place for a great and inexpensive meal.

CLOSED… well, sort of. Now known as Melina’s Trattoria and Lounge. Yep, that’s right: lounge. Hard to shake the image of a hi downtown nightclub when you say «lounge». Okay, I’ll move on now. Despite management/​ownership/​name change, Nancy’s lives on. At least in spirit. A quick glance of the new Melina’s Tratorria menu and you see the old, now retro-​looking, Nancy’s Pizza logo. However, their regular menu includes no mention of pizza. You can request the separate menu, which is pizza only. So, in this time of transition, it seems that Nancy’s is going through some sort of identity crisis.
Melina, whomever you are, don’t hide Nancy in the basement, the locals miss her and her stuffed pizza. I understand you’re the new kid in town and you need to prove yourself, but this town is big enough for the two of you.

Stuffed pizza in suburbs !!
This is the place people. Ordered for my family a medium stuffed and large thin pizza. Lots of toppings to go for and seems like the place is under new management.
The order was made correctly and everybody was very satisfied with the purchase. Definitely going back here for pizza when I am in Elmhurst !!

STUFFED PIZZA! woo-​hoo! we order our stuffed pizzas from Nancy’s all the time– Sausage, ricotta, mushrooms and delicious!
Look for coupons all over the place! behind the receipt at dominick’s, valupak and other like it!
I haven’t tried Melina’s next door, but will review it when I do!

Good pizza with a great variety of toppings. Other fare is just so-​so. Nice place for family or groups and a good bang for the buck.

They have new servers and a female bartender on Wednesdays. She was very weird. I was with my girlfriend and a friend and she treated me and my buddy like crap. NEVER going there again. Dont understand it but there are many other quality places in that area to go to. The food was ok. But I cant get past the crap experience with that bartender.