The Siren’s Song Tavern

We loved that they had some off the normal menu for beer, including Founders out of Michigan. We didn’t spend much time here just got a beer and left but overall an enjoyable experience.

It’s a good little bar. Great selection of beers. Nothing fancy here.
The cheese plate seems locally sourced but basic.
Live music!
I am glad I came upon this bar!

Neat little bar. They have some great brews too. Love the atmosphere in here. They even have sour ales which I’ve found are hard to come by in bars. Definitely check it out

A cool local beer pub/​tavern located in old town. We happened in here one late afternoon after spending the day running errands around town. Siren’s Song was just the ticket. Lots of choices to drink and a comfortable adult environment.
This bar has a very knowledgeable staff, and the owner is often on hand during business hours. We sat at the bar and I had a couple cold brews while the wife found a glass of wine that she thoroughly enjoyed.
This tavern has a really nice selection of both bottle and tap beers available from a wide variety of locales. Some interesting often obscure bottle beers can be had here, and they even have a nitro tap set-​up. The afternoon of our visit I had an amazing nitro porter that was full bodied, rich and thick a great porter brew.
From the signage all around this pub and on the windows and front door — they have a great variety of live music or live entertainment most nights as well.
Worth a visit and one of the best import selections of bottle and taps around.
a Solid 4 stars and definitely worth a stop.
290

Ok … Hit or miss. Great locally crafted beers, awesome entertainment … Great service … Weird venue… Just … Always seems difficult to grab s space/​table/​chair that is comfortable or works for any length of time. Restrooms are out in building corridor. A lot of confusion in getting comfortable altogether

Great selection of unique ales and beers. Had two unique stout a sour and an almond very tasty. Growing up in the Bay Area which has an enormous selection of pub this was a great surprise for the north coast. We also had a great cheese, veggie and meat tray that really hit the spot.

My favorite place in Eureka by far.
The local breweries of Humboldt do produce great quality trademark beers, but they become monotonous quickly as EVERYWHERE carries the same basic spread with little to no outside variation. Siren’s Song brings fresh, obscure, and amplified taste to the connoisseurs with tuned palates craving stimulation that is much needed in this area, as well as always having something for everyone no matter what the stage of brew drinker. My mom, for instance, hates beer and yet manages to consistently enjoy a drink here, whereas I have been spoiled by dramatic habañero IPAs and extremely hard to find ales from Dogfish Head and Stone. Then there’s my dad, who’s a mid-​level porter and stout lover who never ceases to embrace something off of their prolific draft and bottle list.
Aside from how electric their selection of beverages is, this place offers a wonderful and unique environment in which to enjoy them. In the theme of a ship going down, in a building that watched the entire century take its first steps back in the late 1800s, with wonderfully vivid employees, it’s a great place to step in and disconnect from repetition. Even if it’s a routine part of your day, it’s always refreshing.
Also a venue for many live talents. As I work most nights they have music, I haven’t been able to clock out timely enough to run down the road and enjoy as much as I’d like. But you can see anything from spoken word to local hip hop, twangy guitars to livid bands.
The place as a whole is incredibly versatile. And you can get bottles to go :) So happy about Siren’s Song b

I’d rate them much higher, if you could get some service. The building is beautifully decorated, rich colors while still being comfortably dark and bar like. Plenty of tables and seats. They do have a great selection of beers and ciders. If you don’t like what’s on tap check the bottle selection. There’re a few gems. All this is assuming you get the chance to order. Lower your expectations considerably if the vacant-​eyed woman is working. She’ll wander by aimlessly, ignoring your attempts to get her attention, then be startled by your presence a few minutes later. Or just be on her phone with her back to you despite the fact that you’re one of the only patrons in the bar. I’d want to like the Siren’s Song, but since they seem like they can hardly be bothered to serve people, I can hardly be bothered to go.

It’s a great place to visit

I love the ambiance, the beer and the knowledgable and nice people who work here. One of my favorite spots in Old town.

Sexy bar, they onyl have beer/​wine, and the drinks are a little overpriced. But Ithink you go to Siren’s song tavern for the ambiance, their specialty them parties, and to pick up some tail. Dark wood, red drapings, it’s an intimate and mood-​lighting kindava bar, almost vampiric!

Great decorations. Awesome events. Amazing owners and staff. Love this place. Brings something different to Old Town!

The BEST place to get a beer in Humboldt! The atmosphere is amazing, the décor is dashing and the service is superb. But don’t take my word for it, go see a show there. Virtually every night they have something fun. And most of the time they don’t even charge a cover!

Sweet people and great coffee! Love the selections, lots of local and organic options. Fun décor

It’s a good place to try new drinks, but the selection can be hit-​and-​miss. Two things I really liked: the banana bread beer and the selection of lambics. I ended up with one really strange «smoked porter» that smelled and tasted like ashes from a campfire. Another time, a wheat beer that tasted like nothing. So, if I were going to go try new things, I’d probably look them up on a review site first.
The acoustics could stand to be improved. During a live show, the three-​piece band with small speakers dominated the cavernous room and made conversation difficult at the far end.
The décor is lovely, the staff are helpful, and the regulars seem really nice. I will probably continue to go back, but not as a regular thing.

First off the décor is AMAZING! I go to a lot of Savage Henry’s comedy shows and this is my favorite venue. It’s so comfortable and clean. The artwork is FANTASTIC! They support local art and usually have some pretty amazing pieces up for sale. The owners seriously have an eye for detail because even their plants are super cool (they’re carnivorous!)
Also, for a bar, this place smells sooo much better then other bars. Might be that they only serve beer and cider but still! The surfaces are never sticky.
They also serve cool soups and espresso drinks.
They also have the fanciest beers and ciders. I see something new every time I come in, so if you’re into trying new things in a really nice atmosphere, this is your destination!

I love that they have live music here often. The décor is amazing and they have a great selection of drinks.
The room setup is cramped and the tables take up a lot of space. If you go with a a big group, 5 of more people, you’re going to find this place very difficult to socialize.

Nothing but positive experiences! Great beer list, fancy soda selection & great espresso. Accessible all ages venue. Beautiful place. Everyone is consistently kind here.
The owners have made it very easy for me to plan local events here. I recommend this place for gathering with coworkers often.

Hallelujah — Humboldt finally has a great craft beer bar and bottle shop! PLUS, ciders (of the alcoholic variety), espresso, and good food (from what I hear). It’s a nice departure from the (great) breweries that have dominated this region thus far. I am getting computer work done here at 7:30 on a Saturday evening (blah), and their latte is good, wifi fast, and atmosphere cozy and friendly. Everyone else is understandably drinking beer, and their selection is excellent — several varieties on tap and more bottles than I’ve seen in this neck of the woods before.
I’d definitely recommend coming in for a visit — it’s a sweet little place. Tall ceilings, exposed brick, couches, a nice bar, and plenty of decent sized tables. I’m hoping to get done early enough to enjoy an adult beverage … I’d definitely meet folks here for drinks in the future. Hopefully locals embrace it as the opportunity it is!

We totally took a chance in Eureka to go out to Old Town on a weeknight! I thought that surely everything would be closed. Much to my surprise, there were a few places open for hanging out and having a drink.
I ended up at the Siren’s Song Tavern for Poetry Night. It was amazing – so inspiring and fun, full of locals with lots to express! The ambiance was perfect, chill and uplifting – full of genuinely nice people.
My only complaint would be that they only serve beer and cider for drinks. I had water and took in all the poetry. It was great!