The Bagelry

Whenever I am in Evergreen I make sure I stop by this place. I always get the berthaud pass bagel and it never disappoints. The staff working there are super nice and friendly and get out the bagel nice and quick. The bagels are delicious and they’re creative ideas are amazing. This place will not disappoint you.

The Bagelry had been a normal stop for me for 5 years now and i do like some of their bagels quite a bit (although Costco carries Einstein bagels now, so I go there), but i go less and less as my negative experiences tally up.
Too consistently does it seem that they hire rude highschool girls, attractive ones (I’m betting the owner is a male), but usually rude. Today I went and, although the first girl wasn’t overtly rude, when I told her I bought a sandwich that was supposed to come with salsa and i didn’t receive it she told me that, «people don’t usually want it so I don’t give it out.» Yeah, but it’s on the menu, I guess I should do my due diligence before I get home/​work, but usually one is looking for accidentally forgotten things, not intentionally withheld items. Next time, I forgot to ask for salsa again, or look for it, and it wasn’t there. When I called to ask again about it, a young man told me that I wasn’t supposed to get it and should have asked. «Is it on the menu?» I asked, «uh, I guess so but that’s not how we do things here, our regulars know that.» He flatly put. Ok, thanks. I prefer businesses that give you what ya pay for and don’t deal out snide remarks.
The coffee is Daz Bog. Not my favorite, but my partner likes it so we buy it. Today at 8:30 am the coffee was burnt, smelled like a matchstick.
Update: they’ve taken the salsa off the menu, yet have not responded to any of my emails. Bad business if you ask me

I have been to The Bagelry more times than I can count for 20 years. It’s consistent, delicious, and the prices are beyond reasonable. Where else can you get a fresh, delicious meal for $ 2 and change (besides fast food)? There are options on the menu for just about anyone, and their Mountain Power bagel is so hearty, filling and satisfying. I also love that they offer low fat cream cheese AND low fat veggie cream cheese.

I have been going to the Bagelry for my whole life. For as long as I can remember, the Bagelry has been delivering amazing coffee, bagels, and breakfast sandwiches. Memories of childhood breakfasts are filled with the smells of freshly baked cinnamon raisin, blueberry, rocky mountain power, or everything bagels that my mom just picked up from the Bagelry. Even through the inflation of nostalgia, the Bagelry still lives up to my old memories.
The Bagelry is the best, you don’t need me to wax poetic about my childhood to tell you that. Just go try it and enjoy the best bagel shop ever.

Service was great, but the bagels were not very good at all. Slight caveat is that I’m a New Yorker and used to good bagels — but even holding back my true bagel snobbery, I wouldn’t rate these too highly. Toasted with toppings they are fine enough, but on their own as bagels I wouldn’t recommend. But the prices were very affordable, the place is cool and the staff was very helpful.

Bagel was amazingly fresh, sandwiches are tasty. Prices are more than fair. Lots of options and good portion, not a gut bomb like some places. Only critique is the salt bagel was a bit too salty.

This place is hip and cranks out great bagels! We opted for the salt bagel with Nutella and cream cheese. Grandma got salt bagel with chive cream cheese. Both are fabulous! Will be back!

Just went in to buy a dozen bagels and asked the young woman if she could cut the bagels for me. She rolled her eyes at me but still did it. Very unfriendly. I love their bagels but may not go back.

I’ve been going here for over ten years. Still great, try the Bagelry supreme. They hire a lot of high school kids which I think is awesome.

OMG… Get the 14er — Jalepeno Chedder Bagel with Pepper Jack Cheese and everything else…
You will Love it!!!

Bagels are the bomb and the people working are really nice. There is only one bagel place in all of Colorado where I have had a better bagel and it is nowhere near here. Oh, and Dazbog coffee? YES PLEASE. Go to order: Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel, Jalapeño cream cheese and tomato slices with a big cup of coffee.

I’m a regular here because I love the bagels so much but literally the past 10 times I have been there my order has been wrong. One day they got it wrong 3 times! And never apologized but made it seem like it’s was my fault. I love local places and will continue going here but the service Needs to improve. Stop talking to one another and listen to the order!

The Bagelry continues to be the best place in north Evergreen to meet clients (for me) or as a hub for the many great hiking or cycling loops accessed from here– or the perfect place to get a breakfast to-​go before a big day of skiing.

Bagels are great, staff needs some help. On three occasions now, some coworkers and I have ordered and send someone to pick up the bagels. Every time the wrong bagels were on the wrong sandwiches. Order no chives, sandwich is loaded with chives. Hard for me to give two stars because I love this place, but the staff needs help

Usually eat here once a week, but today was pitiful service. Girl in the black t-​shirt took my order, forgot my order, was busy counting her tips, when I asked for my order, she took her time, never apologized.
Hopefully just an aberration, I won’t give up yet in this place.

Wow Sunday morn is crazy here! I didn’t feel like I had enuf time to really get a feel for this place. The bagels were great! I like chewyer bagels. One bummer tho was when my sandwich was handed to me it had 1000 island dressing on it. The other sandwich foil had opened up on the drive home. Those r just being picky tho. Food was great. They use Dazbog coffee as well so if u like Dazbog this is the place for u. One tip: chk the menu online before u go. It’s hard to see the menu if u r in line. They do have laminated menus on the counter so grab one. I didn’t know that until I was asked for my order.

We like it.
Eat it here and take some home for later.

My kids were Einstein fans for years and it was difficult to convert them to fresh, authentic bagels — the kind I had in Detroit when I was visiting my grandparents. This isn’t a fast food bagel place — it’s a bakery. The bagels are authentic, home made and delicious. No, they aren’t soft and squishy like play dough, they’re real bagels made with love.
This is a weekend favorite. We love the egg sandwiches and the cranberry walnut bagels.

As I’ve said in some of my other reviews I’m from NJ/​NY area and we tend to pride ourselves in certain things. Subs, Pizza/​Italian, and Bagels are a few of them. (I probably judge the 3 categories the harshest) Are these good bagels? Yes and no. They’re definitely the best I’ve had since moving to Colorado. So they probably are 5 star bagels for Colorado. But are they 5 star bagels in general? Nope.
They have a good variety of toppings and I normally get the Lox and hummus on an everything bagel. The lox is piled sky high. They make breakfast wraps and also sell cream cheese in tiny containers (4oz). They sell prepacked cookies and some (I’m not sure if all) of the cookies are vegan. I got a chocolate peanut butter one that was delicious but these are baked off site.
The staff has never been overly friendly nor have they been down right crabby or rude to me. They’re just in «work» mode.
So bottom line is I may be judging harshly but I guess that’s what happens when you’re an East Coast transplant. It’s ok you can go the East Coast and tell us how much our microbrews suck. But overall they’re the best bagel I’ve had since being in Colorado. Better than pre-​packaged crap Thomas bagels, or better than bagels that Safeway sell in their bakery section which are a joke.

What a joyful spot to grab a hearty bagel sandwich for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. If you’re a lox and bagel girl like myself — I recommend that number here. To say they load up on the ingredients is an understatement. They don’t skimp — that’s for sure. The smoked salmon was so densely packed in the bagel sandwich almost to the point I had to remove some.
They have tons if options and such a nice serving staff that is so patient with you as you aimlessly stare at their blackboard menu chalk full of options. If you find yourself in Evergreen, stop by!