Pasquale’s Slice of Italy

I feel the pizza has improved. It is nothing great but still probably the best pizza you can get in this area. It is located in a small plaza with good parking.

We ordered 2 calzones and 2 extra sauce… I called to tell them to say we got no extra sauces and one of the calzones is made wrong. They told me I had to come pickup the correct order, even though we originally paid for delivery. I told the girl to just forget it, wtf, and hung up on her. We won’t be going back. I suggest that you don’t use them. They don’t want to make their errors good.

Ordered the Meatball Parm and a Turkey Club to go on a busy Friday evening. Great flavor, nice roll and a better taste and appearance than I expected. I will be back to try other dishes and sit in at a table next time.

Save your time and go somewhere else. This place is beyond pitiful. First if your staff is going to catch an attitude answering questions, then post a bloody menu on line its 2015 for F… Sake ! I have lived all over the world and eaten everything under the sun. This evening I called and wanted to order a Chicken Parmesan Dinner. For some reason this slice of Italy had no clue what I was talking about. This is when the alarm bells started to ring. Then I asked about a Chicken Parmesan Hero. I also wanted to order a side of saluted broccoli, (broccoli /​Italian food goes together like peas and carrots) Did not have it so I order a side salad. I was asked what kind well reverting back to no web site I had to ask. This is where I heard the same kind of sigh that my boxer gives me. Yes I am aware that in different parts of the country there are other names synonymous. Mind you I born and raised in NY State, and yes it was down state, but I also attended Cornell so I was familiar with the jargon, however this girl who answered was baffled with that I asked for.
Now to move on to the order of Chicken Wings that were ordered. How about a lid so they stay hot and 1:9 butter/​hot sauce doesn’t end up all over the place. What a mess …
We asked how long it would take we were told 45 minutes fair enough its Friday night and raining, I did not expect anything different. Within 25 minutes of the place d order the doorbell ring we very happy as it was the first time that either of us ate anything. The food came in two parts, a brown bag and a pizza box. The bag contained the salad which was iceberg lettuce a handful of sliced black olives that came out of a #10 can some kind of grated cheese and a plastic solo cup of dressing. You could have thrown in some tomato, diced, sliced, rough chop. Something to give it some color. The chicken parmesan sandwich the reason for the call, was missing. I don’t mean they forgot it the sandwich, they forgot to put the chicken on the bread. It was all of the tendon that comes from the chicken breast and ½ of the other. I was in shock. As mentioned before I have eaten all over the world. The Italian restaurant I went to while living in Bangkok was 1000 times better than this place.
I am trying to figure out how to upload a picture of what I paid for. For your own benefit when the picture does arrive, you might want to get a magnifying glass or even a jewelers loop, because when seen by the naked eye you ask where is the chicken.
I will never spend another penny in this place ever again. I would rather chew off my arm.
Should have no stars in fact they owe me stars !!!

I’ve ordered here a few times and even stopped in for a slice of pizza and fries. When I asked for hot sauce and got into a discussion with the owner about liking really spicy sauce, he went back and made me even spicier sauce than what was up front and it was delicious (though still not MY spicy, so I’ll have to have them try again). The pizza is very good and the wings, fries and breadsticks are always a nice addition.

One of my families favorites although the pizza is sometimes AWESOME and sometimes just 3 stars. But 3 stars are good either way.
Huge selection of grilled and regular sandwiches.
My only knock, is that they ZERO online presence. No current menu could be found anywhere online. As a business owner myself, that’s a gamble imo.
They’re always busy so maybe the owner doesn’t find it necessary

We stopped on a rainy Sunday night and they were super busy with takeouts and deliveries. We got one large cheese, one large pepperoni and a family size salad. Everything was delicious and perfectly prepared. Can’t wait to stop there again!

Love this place. Never had a bad order.
I always get the Formaggio. It’s better than New York City pizza in my opinion!

Ordered a buffalo chicken sub. Not buffalo, had to add my own hot sauce. Asked for mozzarella cheese, there was none. Lettuce was all brown. My wife called to tell them what happened & guy argued with her and didn’t apologize or offer to fix the problem. He argued so much that my wife hung up on hm! We will NOT be back! Better pizza and food at Mario & Salvo’s anyway! Worth the extra 15 minute drive! Lesson learned!

Order from here all the time. Only place in the Manlius/​Fayetteville/​Dewitt that I will get pizza. Pizza is always delicious and so are the chicken wings. The staff is always friendly, and the warm atmosphere is always welcome. With a great dining area I will continue to always do my business here.

We were spending the week at Green Lakes State Park and we always order pizza one of the nights when we stay at cabins on the week of the 4^th. Independent pizza shops can be tricky since you never know what you’re gonna get but we didn’t see any local Dominos so we went with this one. We were hoping for an online menu but no such luck. We just crossed our fingers we’d do okay ordering the old fashioned way haha. And not get scalped on price being a mile from the park.
So first — we ended up ordering 2 of what they called XL pizzas since they said they didn’t carry sheets. FYI what we got is the size we call sheets back home. The price was also really reasonable for 2 «sheets» — little over $ 40 and each had 1 – 2 toppings.
Next: taste etc. we didn’t specify thin or thick and got a very thick Sicilian crust. We all liked it but it would be an unpleasant surprise for someone not fond of crust. The rest of it was good. The sausage was big slices and the meat eaters reported it was great. The cheese tasted like the quality cheese you get at good pizzerias. The sauce was okay. Overall, our family of 10 was happy we chose this pizza place while at GLSP! :)

Best pizza that I’ve tried in the area. The size and thickness of the slices are similar to OIP, but better ingredients. Real tomato sauce, yeasty thin crust, fresh toppings. Lots of cheese, but that’s how I like my pizza. We are lucky enough to live in their delivery area and they’re always very fast.

Dough was greasy. Staff could do with do with some customer service training. Will not be going back real soon.

Easily the worst mushroom pie I’ve ever had. It was painfully obvious they just dumped a can of (likely expired) mushrooms on the pie. This allowed the can’s juice to soak over the pie, resulting in a disgusting and soggy pie. The pie was wet with SOMETHING. It was actually slimy. It’s not surprising that it didn’t digest well, either.
We called and left a complaint, along with our number, and they have yet to even reply and apologize. It seems these reviewers aren’t aware of what actual NYC style pizza tastes like — it’s quite the opposite of this soggy mess.

I’ve recently been enjoying the good life of Bleecker ST Pizza in Manhattan.
What a shock to come home and eat the antithesis of NYC style pizza: Pasquale’s.
Soggy pizza, slimey canned ingredients, and clearly not left in the oven long enough to be edible.
A waste of money.

I am new to Pasquele’s and I cannot believe I didn’t discover it years ago. The NYC style pizza is delicious. Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had in Syracuse. They also have yummy garlic knots. I went on Friday and had the Fish and Fries, it was absolutely delicious and only $ 5.50. My mom had the New England Clam Chowder and she said it was really good. The prices here are cheap and they have a big selection of hot sandwiches including chicken parm and philly cheese steak. I can’t wait to try more of their menu!

Pasquale’s Slice of Italy serves some very good NY Style pizza with excellent prices. I’m not sure it’s as good as the other reviews would lead you to believe, but it is very good.
I paid $ 9 for a small cheese pizza (12″) and 16oz bottled soda. The crust is just slightly too thick for my taste but with a great yeasty flavor. The sauce was very flavorful and plenty of cheese. A little over cheesed for me, but still not too bad.
Pasquale’s is small and very casual, seating limited with only 5 tables, plus 2 tables outside. Very friendly service is also a plus. Would be great for kids.

Pizza and wings are both great. Haven’t tried anything else yet.

This is the best for your money. Fast service, excellent food, great people and they even deliver. I use to go to Panera but this food is just as good if not better and the prices are way better also.

Not quite sure why this place hasn’t been reviewed yet, maybe and indication of the lack of people in Syracuse using Unilocal???
The pizza and wings from Pasquale’s are fantastic and I think you’d be challenged to find better pizza in the area. People will say Pavone’s over in Manlius is excellent but I believe its a league below Pasquale’s.
The different variety of sandwiches that they offer are also a safe bet and you probably wouldn’t leave disappointed if you were to order one of them.
The prices are way more than reasonable and for what you pay for this place is definitely worth every dollar that you will spend.