Casa Fiesta

I LOVE mexican food, and I can usually get past bad service, but this is the worst place I have ever been. I have been here a few times (for some reason I think it will get better based on the reviews I’ve read), but I have not seen the service/​food/​experience others describe. The best service I’ve received has been at the bar. The first time my husband and I came here we ordered two draft beers, and the waiter came back with two soda glasses and asked if we wanted ice before he poured the beers. The last time we came here (a week ago), we sat for 10 minutes before we were acknowledged by a waiter. When we went to pay for our meal, the credit card machine wasn’t working, and they had a mess of credit cards and receipts on the hostess stand. We had to keep our eye on our card when the host sat it down in the mix of everything. To top it off, the women’s bathroom is disgusting. After trying to give this place the benefit of our doubts time and time again, we will definitely not be back.

OMG!!! Really great food. A family of 7 visiting from Texas and the food is on point. Fed my husband and I, 2 teenage sons, a teenage daughter, and twin 6 year old sons ate for less than $ 65 including drinks and before discount. They atmosphere is super kid friendly and they really catered to the kids… also gave me 5% military discount. AWESOME clean and tasty place!

The only place I’ve found in findlay with horchata, and it’s the perfect balance of creamy cinnamon sweetness. Plenty of options on the menu, with some authentic dishes that can be harder to find. My food has always been hot, delicious, with fast service. Would definitely chalk this up as my favorite place for Mexican in town.

It was our visit. We heard it was good so we gave it a try. Our service was great. The margaritas were good (maybe not the best ever but good). The highlight was the food. The portions are huge. There was four of us and each ordered something different. The star was #75 a seafood dish that could have served 3 (leftovers were just as good). We will be back.

The food is amazing! The staff are very friendly and welcoming! Absolutely love this place!

Casa Fiesta is a 5 star Mexican restaurant, and about as good as it gets. The service is excellent and they are very friendly, enjoyable, and accommodating for their customers. Right away we got chips and salsa and they will bring out queso as well if you like. They also have a couple other homemade salsas to try if you ask for them.
The main meal came very promptly with a short wait from the time we ordered. Everything came out hot and exactly as it was shown/​described on the menu. The steak inside the burritos is very tasty and grilled to perfection. The burrito grande is always my go to dish here but other entrees look excellent as well.
Long story short, if you are a lover of good Mexican food then Casa Fiesta is your place to go. The friendly and prompt service also makes it a very enjoyable restaurant.

It seems lately I’ve been leaving more bad reviews than good but welcome to west central Ohio, the arm pit of America. This place is absolutely horrible in every way possible! Their margaritas taste like straight Daileys daiquiri mix, and their fried pork isn’t fried at all. I hate to say it but if you have the slightest of a craving for Mexican food drive another two blocks and hit the chipotle.

I left another longer review, but a nutshell version of my most recent visit is below:
Great food, nice atmosphere with the colors and music, I had smiling and friendly hosts, lunch prices are especially a great deal, complimentary chips and salsa were tasty, when I left a guy shouted «Have a wonderful rest of your weekend guys!» with a smile and a wave. I am definitely coming back and will be recommending to friends and family.

We have been here a few times and every time the staff is friendly. The food is amazing, fresh, and fast. Thanks for the family friendly atmosphere.

This was a 2 – 3 star place for me. Service was good, most food was passable. I had a taco, chile relleno, and chimichanga. The taco was a Taco Bell /​El Paso (store) type. The pepper was breaded in an extremely soggy coating or maybe just an unusual egg? It was very unusual and stuffed only with cheese, no sausage or spices. Rice and beans were overcooked. Flavors overall were okay. The biggest offense for me was their guacamole is just… not guacamole. It seemed to be blended and made with high onion content? It had more in common with a vegetable smoothie than real guac; it was a bit sweet. Actually, now that I’m describing it, I wonder if it was prepared with green peppers added; that seems likely.
I do want to highlight four menu selections that went over well with my family. The drinks were reportedly good (little light on the pours, but tasty). Items 57 and 75 were well-​received. I tasted the milanesa and it was tasty; definitely the best thing on the table imo. #75 was a mountain of food and I’m told it was good. The tamale looked pretty good/​authentic and I’m told it was.
This is a decent «American Mexican» place, but if you’re looking for something authentic and tasty, this isn’t your top choice.

Really enjoyed this place. The only reason I didn’t give 5 stars is that I’m not a big mexican food fan. However, this was probably the best I’ve had. I got the #75, which was a HUGE seafood dish. My wife & I split & we were absolutely stuffed. It was easily BIG enough for 3 people & they sure didn’t skimp on the seafood! Be sure & ask for the green salsa. It was OUTSTANDING & the guacamole was GREAT as well! Service was very good & attentive. Would definitely recommend! :-)

Findlay is fortunate to have this place. Homemade real Mexican favorites like orchata, mole, and great seafood (the chef is from Veracruz). Ask for the freshwater tilapia. Staff is wonderful. Owner loves his job. And they have real hot sauce and peppers for those who like it spicy. I hope this place catches on it would be a shame to lose them!

Delicious Mexican food in a beautifully decorated space with a friendly, helpful staff and a widely varied menu. We like the Pollo la Crema, enchiladas and, especially, the Molcajete, a meat, shrimp and peppers-​filled, stone bowl that’s served piping hot. Think fajitas but even better. The chips are delicious and are usually served still warm. The red salsa is excellent but ask for the creamy, green, jalapeño salsa. Yeah, it’s hot, but not so crazy hot that you can’t enjoy a lot of it. The owners, brothers Victor and Omar, also have a restaurant in Fremont of the same name but are excited about this new venture here in Findlay, which I believe now features, far and away, the best Mexican food in town. Oh, by the way, the Dos Equis on tap (I prefer the jumbo size) and the margaritas are fantastic. Andale, amigos!