Pizza Shop

I like the idea but it’s strange pizza. Place is super clean, everything seems fresh and thoughtfully prepared but somethings up with the crust, sorry.

Have had pizza here a few times and it is top notch. Whether it’s by the slice or a whole pie you will be satisfied (especially with the Meatster!)

Issue resolved. Manage reached out to me. Much appreciated. Turns out the family runs s few other restaurants nearby. Different names. I have returned for slices and they are good. Haven’t tried the meatball subs again though. Will update when I do

Here in Fishkill NY on Business.
Purchased: 3 slices of pizza (buffalo ranch chicken, white pizza, and mozzarella). Cheese cake. Pepsi. Total price $ 17.
The good: pizza is fresh, delicious, and made with premium ingredients.
The bad: prices are a little high.
Overall thought: ⁴⁄₅ would eat here again. Some great pizza. Took a star off because of prices.

Just had a delicious white Sicilian with basil and tomato. I loved the crunchy crust and the fresh toppings.

Came up to the area from NYC for the day for work. Typically skeptical New Yorker, I’m glad I didn’t read the reviews before I stopped in. Order a slice and a chicken
parmigiana hero. Slice was good, hero was outstanding! Originally stopped in because the place was new and clean, but I really liked the food, plus the staff was nice. Definitely stop back again next time I’m in the area.

Love this spot. Pizza is crispy. Sauce is on point. Nice staff and location makes it an easy spot to meet friends across the river. They also have really good cappuccino which we never miss!

Came here for lunch with co-​workers, the place is very small setup, nicely designed, but small, with about 5 or 6 tables that are also a tight fit for 4 people and a big pizza (hint:i they might do well to invest in some platform pedestals to get the pizzas up off the table for more room on the tabe.
We had a pepperoni pizza, beware it’s the curly and extremely greasy variety, so a little goes a long way. But have to say, the pizza was delicious,…the crust was outstanding, nice golden brown, crispy on the bottom and chewy inside. nWill definitely come back… good variety of calzones, Stromboli’s, typical soda and tea selections so nothing out of the ordinary there.
We’ll be back for more pizza that’s for sure… and the. Counter folks were very nice to us… we were a little unsure what to expect after seeing some of the reviews, but we were pleasantly surprised, they were very nice and answered all our questions on the menu. I’m not a big fan of rustic pizzas with tomato slices, so we kept it pretty basic and it was great.

My husband and I ordered food from this place last night. We ordered a gluten free pizza and it’s probably one of the better gluten free pizzas around (we’ve tried a number of them). We also ordered a Roast Beef sandwich off of the menu and it was horrible, absolutely no attention to detail. It was the type of thing you’d expect to see if McDonalds starting offering a Roast Beef sandwich. It was literally served on a burger bun with a side of greasy, soft chips. Who does that? The whole sandwich was poorly constructed and falling apart. It was a major disappointed for $ 9. I’m sure we’ll be back at some point for the gluten free pizza but that’s likely the only thing we’ll order.

I am surprised by the bad reviews… I tried this place for slices only the other night and the slices were really good… I especially loved the rustica pizza… very fresh tasting! I will go back!

Went there for take-​out. Very disappointed! Food looks delicious when you walk-​in but the taste is very disappointing; the sauce does not have a good flavor at all! I ordered spaghetti and mini meatballs and eggplant parmigiana. Food was mediocre at best. I was very disappointed given this is a Cosimo’s company. Manager also gave me a hard time about using gift certificates. I will not go back.

I ordered a salad for takeout and it was the worst I ever tried to eat because it was inedible. The salad was loaded down with hot peppers and the lettuce, tomatoes, and what was supposed to be ham was not the least bit fresh. The dressing served on the side tasted like plain mayonnaise. I ended up throwing the $ 8.95 salad into the trash. Stay away from this place.

Very picky about my pizza being from NYC. Tired of eating frozen crap from the other places in the area. Pizza Shop serves delicious food. A must is to try the Meatball Sliders… a garlic knot with a meatball slice of mozzerella making the slider. Been there about a dozen times since they opened. Keep up the good work !!!

I have to agree with Kim. The pizza sauce was just tomatoes put on dough. NOT authentic pizza at all. If youre going to spend money on pizza, go somewhere — anywhere — else.

A newly opened pizza place in Fishkill, in the same plaza as Five Guys and Frozenberry. The tomato sauce on the pizza didn’t taste authentic. It tasted like it was out of a jar. I was not impressed by my slices (one with pepperoni and bell peppers, and one a grandma-​type slice). I’ll try it again someday, but right now I feel it can’t compare with any of the other places that I’ve tried in southern Dutchess. Maybe their sandwiches or pasta are better.