Rays Pizza

Excellent NY-​style pizza. Sauce is tasty, cheese doesn’t slide all around, & the garlic rolls & chicken wings were fresh! The delivery guy offered to drop the food off into our room/​kitchen which was a very nice gesture and we did not reject! Ordered a 16″ Four Cheese, 16″ Pepperoni, 6 Garlic Rolls, & 6 on-​the-​side Buffalo Chicken Wings for 6 adults & ended up with the perfect amount of food with just enough room for Kilwin’s waffle cone ice cream later! Crust was medium to well done too, which we love. Don’t hesitate to order; you won’t be disappointed! Great job Ray’s Pizza!

I ordered from there on a Monday and got the pizza, garlic rolls and wings special. The pizza and garlic rolls were good. But the chicken wings were just average.

This place was quick with the delivery and the food was excellent. We got a large cheese pizza and the bbq wings. Both were delicious and hot. It is good to see good pizza in a touristy town. Keep it up!

This pizza is ridiculous! Literally top 5 best pizzas ever! We ordered Rays special and Grandmas pizza! Rays special had pepperoni, olives, onions, sausage, peppers. Amazing! So fresh! Grandmas was my favorite. Focaccia bread, but still thin crust, fresh tomatoes, basil, mozzarella, loads of garlic… Perfection! Being from Chicago I am a tough pizza critic but Rays hit it out of the park! The buffalo wings were even great. Lightly breaded and lots of meat! About a 40 min wait. Not bad at all. Go get some!

We stopped in and the pizza was fantastic. Ray’s take on buffalo chicken Pizza is the best I’ve had. A NY pizzeria in FT Myers, what treat! Ray and his wife were excellent hosts and go the extra mile to make their guests feel like they’re part of the family!

We stopped in here for dinner one night after a long day at the beach with the family. The pizza was very good and the staff was extremely pleasant and accomodating. We ordered 2 mediums and could not finish them between 5 of us. Toppings were good and plentiful. Thin crust, New York style pizza. They only serve bottled beverages, but that is kinda a good thing since they are not limited by brand that way. They do not serve any alcohol. There is limited seating inside the actual restaurant, you might squeeze 20 – 24 people in there, but it would be REALLY tight at that point. I get the impression most of their business is take out or delivery, which makes sense since they are nearly adjacent to Ft. Myers Beach. Prices are reasonable and we would recommend/​go again.

We loved this «Ray’s» ! Really great New York style pizza! We actually got it to go 3 times in 5 days!

Great pizza/​sauce like our place back home.
Fresh mushrooms– not canned.
Fresh produce in the salad.
Delivery –arrived piping hot!

Here on vacation from northeast … BEST PIZZA EVER! Wish Rays Pizza was closer to home !! if you are a pizza snob like me … Eat Rays pizza!

We ordered the garlic rolls, medium sausage pepperoni pizza and the Italian hoagie. Everything was delish! Loved the rolls I hear they have cannolis, may have to stop by before we head back home!
Service was also great! Thanks Paula!

Fantastic food: there’s is no one as talented to the famous ray. Him and his wife have a beautiful restaurant and great food

Very solid Za! I have to say one of the biggest perks is the fact they have free delivery on the island. One night during our trip we didn’t feel like going anywhere for dinner. And the fact we didn’t have to pay or pick up the pizza is a great deal.
Pizza priced well too! Ended up being around $ 25 for a large pizza with a couple toppings and an order of their garlic rolls. The GARLIC ROLLS. Wow. So buttery, so delicious. Healthy? Of course not. Delicious? Why YES! Pizza pretty good too. Crust was cooked perfectly, not too dry, not doughy. My only wish is that it had been browned a bit more. Adequate sauce and we ended up getting some on the side as well (with the garlic rolls).
Locals on the island recommended Ray’s as we headed into town and I’d say it’s worth a try! Especially if you’ve got a rainy day and don’t feel like walking/​cabbing to get dinner.
Thank you for the great pizza!

Overall pretty good experience. Excellent pizza and some pretty good service. I highly recommend this place if you’re looks for pizza on the island. I got their jalapeño popper as an app, they were great.

Pizza was really good. Canolli was great. Service was awesome. What else can you ask for! Oh ya, reasonably priced too. Perfect.

We ordered pizza from Ray’s tonight and were very pleased! I could tell as soon as I opened the pizza box that the pizza was going to be good. And it was! It’s a very nice thin crust New York style pizza — not paper thin like a Monical’s chain, but just right! It was very good!
We also ordered a small order of garlic rolls and they were excellent! May I suggest to the owner Ray that they sell these in even-​numbered increments; it may save a life! For instance, if both spouses have had 1 garlic roll each and there’s only 1 left (because it comes in increments of 3) and the spouses have to fight over it, things could get ugly real quick! ;)
Also, the customer service was good. The guy who answered the phone was patient with me and fully explained everything, and the delivery guy was earlier than promised.
Overall, we were very pleased and will definitely return! Good job, Ray’s!

Pretty good pizza. I like the crust, but I wish the mozzarella was a bit more gooey and soft. We got meat lovers which had a perfect amount of meat… not too much, not too little.

Great New York style pizza. They are the best on the beach. Generous portions and wonderful customer service.

Just picked up a Hawaiian pizza and it is like someone dumped sauce over uncooked dough… not pleased.

Ray’s pizza will scratch your pizza itch!
Some perspective: I grew up in Chicago and the Chicago area, and «back in the day», Chicago pizza was mostly thin crust pizza. In the late 60’s and early 70’s the deep dish pizza came into prominence, although it had been around since the 50’s. Great marketing by Unos and Lou Malnati probably had a lot to do with that. Bottom line: I’ve had a lot of pizza, and pizza can be a great bar topic of discussion; you don’t need to grab your phone and consult Google at every turn, because pizza likes and dislikes are ultra-​personal. I like Ray’s, and will try a couple of different combos over time until I fine tune «my» pizza.
Ray’s is very good east coast style pizza. The crust is hand tossed and formed (based on the slightly «obround» shape), lightly topped and tasty. A touch on the salty side, but wash it down with your favorite beer and have another bite.
A note to my Chicago and Rockford friends: Skip the sausage, Ray uses very thin slices of mild sausage that crisp and curl on the top. Go with the pepperoni for sure. I can’t speak to any of the other toppings. If you are a cheesehead, add some extra cheese.
A note to everybody: Try some garlic rolls and sauce! Probably pizza dough or a slight variation, but who cares.
Delivery was about 30 minutes, Pizza was hot and ready to eat. When I ordered, Ray told me «within the hour.» Darrin, aka Derwood (from Bewitched) was our delivery guy. Darrin is a great representative of Ray’s business. This was the first time my pizza was delivered on a motor scooter. If you are sitting in FMB right now, you know how crazy Estero Boulevard can be, so a scooter is the perfect delivery vehicle.
4.5 stars. I’m now looking for my 5 star Ray’s pizza with my next order.

Ordered two medium pizzas and a cannoli for delivery. First pizza was a spinach broccoli and came as ordered while the second was sausage, green pepper and mushrooms. Unfortunately the second pizza had onions instead of green peppers (more trouble than it’s worth to call back). Both pizzas were a little salty, not sure if it was the cheese, sauce or both. The toppings were of good quality and quantity (although a little more mushroom would have been nice). The cannoli was fresh and had a firm shell.
Delivery was prompt, pizzas were nice and hot and the driver was friendly.
Overall it was better than a chain but nothing to write home about (maybe just a boring review).