Paradise Pizza

Sadly, this must get a very low rating. Told me it would take 30 to 40 minutes to get here and it took over an hour. And this is how it showed up. Unilocal was very misleading on this one as the pictures and reviews told one story and I got a totally different story.
Visiting from out of town and cannot recommend this to anyone who searches Unilocal the same way that I did.

Always excellent food. We order weekly usually on Sunday. I am a true fan!!! Stuffed pizza excellent salads to die for… What can I say more than try it you will be impressed!!!

This little pizza parlor is the real deal. Fresh ingredients, friendly staff and reasonable prices. Having met one of the owners who was actually baking the pies, we were given some history on the restaurant. Only thing missing were potato chips!

Came here on a Sunday night at 9:15 not knowing that’s they close at 9. The owner was so kind telling us to stay. He made some of the best pizza that we have ever had and showed us some of the best customer service! Definitely coming back son!

Friendly service. Very good thin crispy crust. Had veggie pizza, all fresh ingredients, lots of toppings.

Tried Paradise Pizza for the first time today! I have to say it was better than I expected. The pizza came in a timely manner and was warm, cheesy, and delicious. The crust was cooked to perfection, with some crispy pepperoni that created a nice bite to the pizza. I will definitely be coming back for some more!

I just had a pizza delivered and it was ice cold and the crust was hard as rock. Extremely disappointed!

We are from Chicago and love our Authentic Italian food, especially salads and pizza!
You can taste the quality of the fresh ingredients, our antipasto salad was crispy and layered with delicious Italian deli meats and giardinara!!!
We will be back to our new favorite place !
Pizza was great!

Delivery only took 25 minutes from order time to my door!!! Food was very good too!!!

First time in and waited a few minutes to get the attention of the girl at the counter. With only 1 older couple eating in, the place was rather busy with phone orders. Although, I do not know why there were a couple men standing in back discussing things — they could have easily helped at the counter. But that’s not a deterrent for the over all appeal.
The couple were attempting to pay for their meal, as they had eaten in the restaurant. They had enough pizza left over, that they were able to take home a small box. The woman said to me that they travel all over the country and always end up back at Paradise Pizza because the pies are that good. No wonder the Cape Coral outfit came over to Fort Myers… if people are going to both locations now, and this one takes so many phone orders!
Due to the business of the place, one of the lads who makes the pizzas came over to help at the counter. Having taken my order of a small (12″) White Pizza, I was able to pay the girl, as she had just gotten off the phone. For $ 11.60 after tax, I got a meal that was ample enough for two days.
What’s so interesting about this place? It’s small enough that you can comfortably sit a few tables around and eat there. Outside has two tables that would sit a pair of customers and their order. There are daily specials on the chalkboard that looked reasonably priced and delicious. I noticed when they were making my pizza, that the dough goes on a sort of heated metal press. Looks like a machine you’d make waffles in, but it’s flat on either side. Dough gets sprayed so it doesn’t stick, gets formed on this press, and they take it out to finish stretching it and make whatever pie you want.
How was the pizza? Considering it was regular crust (not thin like I’ve been getting at places), it was cooked perfectly. Not doughy at all or soggy in places. The whole pizza was cooked through out and the cheese was a melty goodness. It being a small, was cut evenly and 6 pieces were enough for two meals (I wasn’t sharing with anyone for dinner). If I had upgraded to the next size, I’m sure there would have been TOO much leftovers. This served its purpose.
Will I go again? More than likely, as I was really contemplating the Buffalo Chicken pizza. Apps looked good too.

Great pizza! The staff is very friendly and quick! We will be ordering again next week! The deserts were also very good!