Lexy’s Pizza

pizza tastes great but my coworkers and I get heartburn from hell anytime we eat their fare. the taste aint worth the gut bomb you get and it is NOT cheap. Dont like the cook handling money and then your food YUKY thx Gary E

Another pizza favorite in this house, actually this is THE FAVORITE. We are always prepared to wait when we order from here but it is so worth the wait.
I have had Lexy’s pizza my whole life. We order Sausage and mushroom pizza when we order from Lexy’s and have not once been disappointed. We even recently found out that they deliver to our home.
The pizza is good, worth the price and the staff is friendly. What more can ya’ ask for?

What can I say? This place is simply AMAZING!

Fore most of my life i have loved this place. I love the feeling of a small locally owned business and this def had that feel.
The number one thong i love to get are their hot subs. So so so delicious. Theow pizza is also do good but not my nunnery one choice due to price. I’ve had better. But bevause i was radioed to like this is hard top knock somwthing you live.
The building had little to no seatimg and id alittle tun dian but the people who wprk their doop s great job making you feel at home.

Best sausage roll in town, hands down. Their grinders are also delicious. Surprisingly enough, I haven’t tried the pizza yet, but when you can never go wrong with the sausage roll, it’s hard to justify a change. The sausage roll will feed 2 – 3 people, but we typically get a grinder, too, so this feeds 4 well.

Me and my family have been eating here for as long as I can remember. They have sausage rolls that are off the charts and amazing grinders. Their pizza has a homemade taste and is off the fucking chain! Love it and highly recommend it!

The grinder and the veggie rolls from here were both very good. Lexy’s has one of two choices for dinning, Pick-​up or delivery. There is no dinning in option, which is ok. The food is good, I have yet to try there pizza but I have heard good things so I’ll be trying that next time I go to pick up some food. Only draw back. Was my 2 item dinner was $ 18. This little mom and pop pizza shop is not cheap by any means, hence the 4 stars and not 5. The prices listed on the Unilocal page are incorrect. When calling ask about prices. My bill after tax should have been $ 14.98 according to the prices listed on Unilocal.I was charged $ 18.40 something.

Didn’t try the pizza but my husband remembered the sausage rolls from when he was growing up and they were great. Tried the Hindenburg and veggie roll as well. The Hindenburg was good and had sausage, pepperoni, some veggies. I would not recommend the veggie one, not much flavor. Good dough and was steaming hot when it was picked up. We split those 3 between 4 people and it was plenty of food but was a little pricey.

So, this place is a mixed bag. My first experience with them was actually pretty good. The pizza, anyways. I agree with other reviews I’ve read about them, they have THE RUDEST EMPLOYEES I have ever encountered in my life. From being asked the most basic questions they just snarl at you and act indignant at being asked to do their job! Thankfully I had read about the less than stellar customer service prior to ordering or I would probably have gone off on the surly staff. Thankfully I stuck it out and was rewarded with a good thick crust pizza. YES, it is VERY EXPENSIVE compared to what you pay at other pizza places, but you do get what you pay for. You can tell you’re getting quality, fresh, handmade stuff here. Not frozen, bulk, overly processed stuff like the big chain places. I appreciate that fresh, homemade touch, so I was willing to deal with the price-​especially when it comes to crust, and their thick crust is killer!
So after several rides in the thick crust saddle I took a chance recently and went all out for the deep dish. This was risky for several reasons. One being that the price of one large deep dish is about what it’d cost you for two large deep dish pizzas at Pizza Hut. Secondly, in order to get a deep dish you HAVE to order a large. Living all by my lonesome, that’s an awful lot of pizza for little olé me! So I forked over the $ 23.60 for my large pizza and boy was I disappointed! Even though I’d requested they go easy on the pizza sauce this thing was practically soup. It was so goopy and sloppy that the crust was mush and totally inedible! The part of it that was safe to eat was what was about an inch to an inch and a half (max) from the crust. And that’s being generous! I was livid! For what I paid, to only be able to eat a few inches of pizza was unacceptable. The pizza was also not just overly saucy, it was super greasy, there was so much grease it had soaked through the cardboard circle and through the paper bag it came in (that’s right, it didn’t come in a box, it came in a paper bag). Honestly, if I had been part of a blind pizza eating contest, I’d never have guessed this pizza came from the same restaurant as all those awesome thick crust pizzas.
So, That’s my story of my mixed experiences with Lexy’s. To recap. Crappy, down right unfriendly service and staff. AWESOME thick crust pizza. Over priced, disgusting, inedible deep dish pizza.

Really good pizza. A little pricey but definitely worth it.
They were not polite on the phone and added toppings that I didn’t order, but I sure loved what they made me. I’ll just speak clearly on the phone next time.

Ordered pizza. It was busy, but still kind of slow. I’ve worked in pizza parlors before. This was slow. Pizza looked ok and had a mediocre taste – not bad, but not great. It was vaguely sweet. My kids make better tasting pizza. It is hard to mess up pizza, but this came close.
I’ll try it again some time. This might have been an off night.

Fantastic pizza — a little pricey when compared to the mediocre chain pizza joints, and worth every extra penny!
My only complaint is a lack of consistencey — sometimes the pizza is good, and sometimes it is fantastic! Even a bad day @ Lexy’s is better than Hungrie Howies at their best.
Don’t be surprised by the staff — they know how to make pizza, but not much for small talk.

I’m a pizza addict. Pizza is always a good idea. And Lexy’s Pizza is one of the reasons I’m happy about being back in Fort Wayne.
All their pizzas are delicious, but their Everything is out of this world. Great thin crust combined with a tower of toppings held in place with cheese.
I normally hate sausage on pizza, but I happily eat it on this pizza. My husband is normally anti-​green pepper, but was scarfing down the pizza like he wasn’t going to have another chance, green peppers still in place.
Person on the phone was friendly, as was the delivery driver. Delivery took about an hour.
It WILL cost more than a pizza from Pizza Hut, but it is a different class of pizza and is worth the extra couple of bucks. (Toppings, toppings, toppings!)
Do an internet search and you should find a $ 5.00 off coupon.