Brooklyn Pizza

Simply the best pizza in not only Fulton, but in Mid-​Missouri! I have eaten here alone, with my family and may parents many times and we have never had a bad menu item. The desserts are to die for. There is a reason why Rural Missouri voted them the best pizza. It’s because they are.

Have given this place a chance… eaten here 3 times. 1^st time, family ordered a supreme style pizza. apparently they forgot to put the mushrooms on when they cooked the pizza so added cold ones on top. Not so good. 2^nd time, don’t remember much, so not impressed. 3^rd time, just ordered a piece of cheese pizza as a lunch special. Not worth eating. Bad. Live locally and won’t be back.

On the way back from the lake. Everyone should stop here. NY style at its best. So good. Don’t forget the meatballs.

Excellent pizza! I get so overwhelmed sometimes choosing crusts, toppings, etc but Brooklyn’s makes it simple. They only have one kind of pizza size and crust. You just add one what you want. They also chill the salad plates, which makes the greens much crispier. Not a lot of places do that. Their lunch deal is great too — just get there before it’s gone!

I love small businesses and try to support them. I really wanted to love this place and I had heard good things from the people who work at the Churchill Museum. We were craving Arris’ Pizza but since it was 30 miles away, we opted for this place.
The service was friendly enough and the atmosphere was fine, but I found myself really wishing we could sit outside or on the patio (which was like one huge table).
Their menu is very limited, and I didn’t find much original. We were there on Mother’s Day and there was no «Happy Mother’s Day» or any real observance of it.
The pizza was fine but nothing special in my book, even though I really wanted it to be because I am all about the small, independent entrepreneur. They did offer a gluten free crust. We should have gone ahead and opted for it because the regular crust didn’t leave me breathless.
They serve beer and wine, so I loved that about it. Many small places don’t bother to apply for the liquor license so that was a pleasant surprise. They had a tannin free wine too so that is awesome.
Their salad was fine but I guess I was hoping for a little originality– like a creamy italian dressing with provel or something. It was lettuce, italian dressing, and mozzerella. Just nothing to hook me.
The pizza was okay but not my favorite.
I would try it again but I would love it if they offered some cheese options or a Chicago style pizza, or just something to make me choose them over a chain.

This is a cozy atmosphere with food that taste like it has been made from scratch. We had a pizza (half cheese and half meatball) a nd some garlic cheesy bread and could not stop eating it was so yummy. Service is friendly and very good. Nice to see a non franchise restaurant in the area that knows how to make some great food.

Good pizza for a good price. Crust is something you can’t get at Pizza Hut or a franchise restaurant. Pizza was fresh, hot also with fresh ingredients.

pizza wasn’t that great, I don’t mind greasy pizza but this was nothing but greasy. Lumpy cheese with a barely crisp crust.
I’ve had better pizza from gas stations.
the calzone was a giant bread ball of grossness.
don’t let the other reviews fool you this pizza isn’t great.

Listen, this is the best pizza in the Central Time Zone, okay? I ain’t kiddin’. I been ta Brooklyn, alright, and this is REAL Brooklyn pizza. Fantastic Brooklyn-​style pizza. I’m from Columbia, home of Shakespeares — renowned pizza and absolutely worth the praise. But you know what? This pizza is better. The BEST pizza in the central time zone, and right smack dab in the middle of Fulton, in the Kingdom of Callaway. Who knew? So when you come to Fulton to see the Berlin Wall, you come to Brooklyn Pizza and taste pizza that’s better than its own namesake. Or you just come to Fulton to eat at this place: I have. Because it’s that good. (Great salad dressing too; garlic cheese bread — all the trappings.)

Absolutely loved the dining experience! Great staff, great food, great atmosphere, and the price was just right. We will be going back! Owner was going around and talking to each table — that seems to be a thing of yesteryear, and it was so nice to see this! He even brought his granddaughter around. Great family place. The pizza was excellent (as was the gluten free pizza, which someone in our party ordered.).

Ok, read the reviews and thought, hmmm really with the five stars? I’m trying it, walked in, greeted by the staff and ordered one of the most A-​MAZING pizzas ever., fresh mushrooms, fresh Italian sausage, pepperoni, onions and a chewy crust… listened to a little Sinatra, ate my Brooklyn style, visited with the owner, and fell in love… if I could, I’d throw down 10 stars on this place… try it, it really is awesome!

Sbarro — like New York style pizza but SO MUCH tastier! Crispy chewy crust. Environment was relaxing and casual. The inside is much bigger than it looks from the outside. Wait staff were supper busy but still managed to be attentive, friendly, and timely. Quite the find in little Fulton.

It’s easy to see why this genuine NYC-​style pizzeria in small-​town Amercia is voted the Best Pizza in Rural Missouri; they deserve it. Personally, I think the secret is their homemade pizza sauce; it’s hearty, rich and full of flavor. I met the owner, Brian, as we were both leaving. You know how you can tell when someone is passionate about their work? Well, Brian – and his team – are all very proud of their pizza. And they should be.

The quality of the food and attentive customer service make this one of my favorite places! They offer a great lunch special and have a daily special — both are well worth the experience — I have never been disappointed!

I never wrote a review before but I felt compelled to do so for this restaurant because the food was that good. The staff was friendly and the food was great.
I’m from the Bronx in NYC and I felt like I was eating at a local restaurant on Arthur Ave or little Italy in NYC.
If you are looking for some authentic Italian food, this is the place to eat!

The lasagna was delicious and it felt like I was having lunch at their home. It was obvious they desire everyone to have a great dining experience by providing quality food and service.

Great customer service. Owner is very passionate about the quality of the pizza!