Meltzer’s

The end to an era. There will never be another like this. Many many years, I would rely on these guys to tell me what my dad was eyeing. They knew better than anyone. While I’m happy they have retired successfully on their own, it saddens me to see them close. They knew my dad, knew what he liked, the sports he enjoyed, brands, etc… They are by far superior in delivery of that level of service! A true customer service driven business leads to loyal customers. I learned a valuable life lesson from them… I will forever think of their slogan in my own everyday business. Once you shop Meltzer’s you go nowhere elser. Thanks for the help, the lesson and the memories! Happy Retirement!

I’m truly going to miss this place. I purchased my first fishing rod and baseball glove many years ago from Meltzer’s. Might have not been the most well stocked store, but that is not why you would shop there. I wish all of you the very best.

Super nice guys in the fishing dept. Fixed my kid’s messed up reel and showed him how to prevent it from happening again. Gave us great advice on lure purchases too. Nice selection of fishing gear and reasonable prices. Well worth the half hour drive from South Orange!

Cranky Cranky men! Went to purchase a gun, every single one of them had a puss face. Went to fill out paperwork, one of the guys just kept huffing a puffing and rolling his eyes, no thanks! I’ll take my business to Lucianos… better prices and people. Thanks for nothing guys!

A couple of years ago a fishing buddy of mine told me about Meltzers. So one day I decided to stop by good thing I did. I brought some hooks, sinkers, rigs, line and a net. I had my pole re tipped which I was happy cause it’s my favorite carp pole. Today it’s Spring so need to swing buy get some lures and plastics. You can get a fishing report from them. I only stay in the fishing section due to I don’t hunt nor shoot guns. Staff is friendly and helpful you will like your shopping experience here.
I picked up some sinkers, thundermist t-​turns swivels some carp bait yes they sell boilies the needle and stoppers. Next time I will ask them to show the hair rig I did good only brought what I just mentioned. They have the net I need it’s a very good store better than Walmart.

Went to Meltzer’s to-​day to buy gun supplies, I had the items in my hand to pay, the three guys behind the counter would not acknowledge that I was there. I put everything back and left. I have been coming to Meltzer’s from the 1950’s and never seen it this bad. I guess I’m shopping in Woodland Park at Ottomanelli’s from now on. Mr. Meltzer should get better people working for them.

They have bullets in stock. But their prices are higher than usual. However, they are pretty nice, and has a good atmosphere. They have their own parking lot opposite of the store.

They have a wide variety of guns to choose from. As a first-​timer, the old guys working there were really calm and answered all my questions professionally. The prices are very reasonable and they congratulated me for getting my permit. If you aren’t sure what to buy, this is a good place to start!

They offer competitive prices and a wide selection of sporting goods, especially hunting and fishing. They also sell some work clothes. Their staff are knowledgeable and courteous.

Very nice knowledgable staff decent selection and my family will be life long customers. My fathers uncle got his hunting gear here so does many other family members the prices are average the service makes them better than most in our area!

Was there today to purchase. Waited around 5 min. and 2 guys behind counter never even looked up from their paperwork to say hello. I finally saw what I was interested in and politely asked one of the employees if I could ask him a question and he replied «if it is a quick one». So much for customer service. Like I always say, this is the owners and managements fault for allowing it. Such Idiots. I was at the store in Woodland Park in 15 min and they could not have been more helpful. Made my purchase in and out in 10 minutes. Never go back if they were giving it away. One star is one to many.

I went here with a friend last week. We were not helped for the first 10 – 15 minutes we were there. My friend is black and we were overlooked because of this. We were finally helped, but the help was not sincere. I would not buy anything from this establishment!

I’ve been coming here on and off throughout the years for my fishing needs, and I always found the people there friendly and helpful. Their prices on items are reasonable.

If there is a zombie apocalypse I want be my protectors. The old men that work here are calm and reasonable.
There is an ammo shortage and was still able to purchase .223 cartridges but at a hefty price. The ammo is of better quality but I’ll take it for now. I wouldn’t normally buy it at that price but beggars can’t be picky.
I’d come back here just to support local businesses.

I went here twice. On both occasions, I was met with horrible customer service. Evidently two questions is far too many for these clowns. I will never return. If you want everything Meltzer’s has and more, go to Ramsey Outdoor in Paramus.

I cannot believe that this place only has 1 previous review on Unilocal.I am kinda pissed that it was not me… kudos to you Mike P.
This sporting good store is a local institution, and family owned since the 30’s. By sporting goods I mean, hunting, fishing and firearms. If you are looking for a basketball hoop or a new hockey stick, go to Model’s or Sports Authority. However, if you are looking to buy firearms, ammunition, hunting gear or anything relater to fresh, or saltwater fishing come on down to speak to the professional staff at Meltzer’s.
The knowledgeable, experienced staff are patient and will tactfully answer even the most stupid questions from the novice. I have been shopping here for years and highly recommend Meltzer’s for all of your sporting needs.

This place has a pretty large selection of fishing supplies and guns. They were the two things I remember most; there was an extensive selection of rods and lures, and a lot of different long gun and a fair amount of pistols.
The people were pretty nice. Prices seem average. If you needed something from either of the above categories i think you would probably find what you were looking for, or at least be able to order it.