Yummy Pizza

Extremely great pie! A little on the expensive side, but worth it. Came here the first time because Sacco’s was packed. Got the meat lovers pizza and it was amazing! Garlic breadsticks seriously rock! Gonna be back there a lot! Try it tonight!!!

Eh. I mean it’s fine. I can certainly take it or leave it. The man working there (I assume the owner) was very nice and very cool. So I hope great things for his business. But as far as pizza goes, I have had better pizza lots of places (although nothing much better in the michiana area.)

Very friendly staff, unfortunately the pizza is below average, would be better off going with a mid grade frozen pizza.

Great NY style pizza. And the owners are personable as well. Our family will definitely come back!

We are new to the area and wanted some yummy pizza on a Friday night. And it was yummy!!! Fantastic New York style pizza. The customer service was fantastic. Delivery was about 30 minutes. Love the local owners. Highly recommend.

Best NY style pizza in town!

This pizza is awesome! New York style right in Granger, IN. Plus the staff are amazingly nice and recognized us right away. Must try!

Pizza was very greasy, we were not impressed. We thought Pizza Hut and dominos were better. It’s not worth the extra money

Tried this place for the first time tonight. We ordered breadsticks and a pizza with bacon and meatballs.
The breadsticks were long and thin and came with a side of garlic butter. Delicious! They were so hot and fresh out of the oven that we burned our fingers a bit on the first one. Although they may not look like exceptionally hearty breadsticks, I started to fill up after the first one.
The pizza arrived shortly thereafter and was cooked to a medium degree of doneness — cheese was thoroughly melted without any crispy bits and the crust was golden brown. The sauce was neither too sweet nor too tomato-​y, which is a plus for me. The crust wasn’t quite New York thin, but it was a thinner crust. There were generous amounts of bacon and «meatballs» on the pizza. I say «meatballs» because they were more like little dabs of meat instead of small meatballs, but I believe that actual meatballs would’ve been a bit too much.
They do not appear to offer alternatives to tomato sauces, which is the only reason I gave them a 4-​star rating. I prefer a white or an oil-​based sauce on thin crust pizzas. In fairness, I don’t usually love tomato-​based sauces and tend to avoid pizza altogether unless there is a non-​tomato sauce option, but this one was good enough that I’d eat it again, tomato sauce and all!
The service was attentive without being intrusive and the two staff members were friendly and accommodating. I’d recommend this place to anyone looking for some thin-​crust pizza!

Not bad pizza, not our fav style. Great atmosphere for families! Prices are pretty reasonable as well. Service has been good as well.

Great crust! I guess it’s making me add more words sooo. We also had the pepperoni bread sticks too which were great.

Pizza is AMAZING!!! 5 stars!!! The price on the other hand is a little bit high, 20 bucks for a 16 two topping new york style pizza is a couple bucks more than I think it should be. But the staff are extremely friendly and professional. They call you by name and refill your drinks promptly. Quiet atmosphere, nice and bright, very homey. Billiards is a big plus. So all in all I would say the TOTAL experience is worth 20 bucks, just not the pizza alone.

Great tasting pizza. The breadsticks are like mini baseball bats and i love to dip them in garlic butter. They stuff the bread sticks with pepperoni on request.

First they tried my patiences but in the end it was worth it! To start with we got bacon dip for appetizer which was outstanding! For main entrée I choice the steak sandwich which was fantastic — guys got the steak which was very good too! Recommend highly but be patient.

Great pizza — we moved here from NY and this is a great NY style pizza — it came hot and delicious!

This is the best pizza in area for takeout. It stands up to a drive home and a quick warm up. AND they deliver! If you have kids, the place has games and is funfor small and large groups.

This is a solid pizza place. I go through periods when I get pizza here every week or so, so I’ve tried it often. While it is NY style, it bears saying that (for better or worse), the pizza is not as greasy. They must use a lowfat mozzarella here, because there’s no occasion to sop up fats from the top. I actually would prefer the greasier style, but this place is, all the same, a great addition to the area.
Also, while I normally carry out, it’s important to note that dining is great with kids and whoever else likes electronic skill and video games, a pool table, etc. This is a GREAT place to go where adults can sit around and chat and have worthy food while the kids can go off and have fun without getting out of sight.

I thought the name was weird until I saw the Asian woman behind the counter. However, the pizza was really good thin crust. The dining room was clean and large. There were also several old school arcade games, a pool table and air hockey. I will definitely be going back.

We recently tried Yummy Pizza after driving by it for the past few years. I was AWESOME. Some of the best pizza in the area. The pizza is NY style with a semi thin crust, simple but excellent sauce and really good cheese. Their homemade breadsticks are great as well. They are about 12″ long and come with either garlic butter or marinara sauce for dipping.
The actual restaurant itself, isn’t anything special. There are about 20 or so small tables and a few arcade games for kids.
All in all I would highly recommend Yummy Pizza to friends!

Great NY style pizza. Thin-​ish crust, light sweet sauce, good cheese. Pitcher of Killians is very reasonable (under 6 bucks). This remind me of Boston’s North End Pizza Bakery in Honolulu… if you are fortunate enough to have experienced that pizza joint…