Carly’s Pizza

We ordered pizza to go from here since the reviews were so good. They were reasonably priced, but there were a few things we were disappointed with. Their menu says that the pepperoni pizza has 2 types of pepperoni, but ours only had one kind. Also, on the combo pizza, the tomatoes were thrown on at the end instead of cooked on the pizza, so we ended up having to just take them off instead of eating them. Lastly, you should know that their Jumbo pizza is the same size as almost every other pizza place’s Large. We may try them again at some point in the future.

Used to love this place. It’s been a few months so we decided to get a pepperoni pizza tonight. Its so different. Different pepperoni and the crust is dense and not fluffy. Like dough that didn’t properly rise. I guess is back to searching for good pizza. Carly’s used to be so good.

The pizza here is amazing!
I believe they recently went through a change in management which is exactly the same time I noticed a big improvement in the crust, sauce and toppings — they all seemed much fresher now like they are made in house now vs the frozen crust and canned sauce they used to have. I had a good ol’ cheese and pepperoni — the sauce is rich with a nice garlicky flavor and some of the pepperonis got crispy on the edges, just how I like it. They also have some great beers on tap that were a tasty compliment to my meal.
I noticed a few negative reviews, but most seemed concerned about the fact that the new owners wouldn’t honor old coupons from the previous owners vs concerns with the food — it’s ridiculous to take the time to write a review just to ding a restaurant over non food topics when they are obviously changing over to new business policies.
If what you care about is getting a great tasting pizza, then look no further than Carly’s, it’s one of the best in town and I plan to eat there often. Quit reading and just go!

We always get our pizzas from Carly’s. Recently, we went in and they would not honor a Unilocal coupon that we tried to use. They stated they no longer accept this coupon because the owners have changed. It is definitely reflected in the pizza as well, which is no longer tastey. :-(Unfortunately we will not be ordering from Carly’s anymore because it is no longer yummy pizza.

Didn’t honor their Unilocal coupon! Says it’s not supposed to be there. Too bad. Pizza is good though.

VERY DISAPPOINTED!!! It «was» one of our favorites pizza places. Not even edible. Pizza was so greasy it was soggy to where you were unable to pick it up!!! New owners? Not sure but won’t be returning. Hope this review helps others save their money and take their business elsewhere.

I was a little on the fence about trying this place because of the location but boy am I glad I did. The lady who took my order was nice. The restaurant was a cute little place, not very big, but just right. The pizza, the pizza was amazing! It was so flavorful and tasted so good! I will definitely be ordering from here more often!

WARNING: they have changed their menu! They will no longer make your favorite pizzas and sides you are used to. The place has a new modern look that I like but for the first timeS in nearly 20 years the customer service was horrible and inexperienced and the food was not what I was hoping for. I should’ve just got pizza h@? If that says anything. At least I wouldn’t have to leave my house for a cramped parking lot. I’m sorry Carly’s but we had a good run I guess all the good things must come to an end. I’m sorry to see you go I wish we could’ve had just one more fling…

I was dog sitting for a friend down the street and wanted to get a pizza to go. Staff was very friendly and service was quick. Pizza I got was margarita and added artichoke hearts. Delicious! Just the right amount of sauce and the crust remained crisp and seasoned well. Will come back.

Got the 16″ meat lovers… with $ 3 off discount from Unilocal… quick, friendly service… sauce was excellent, not over powering… dough was garlicky and herby… both compliments the toppings very well, which were piled on…

One of the best pizza places around! Family-​owned and you are treated like family. They just re-​decorated the inside with beautiful handmade wooden picnic style tables. Friendly staff and they usually have a special where if you talk like someone famous, you get a discount! (The name of the celeb or well-​known person will be posted at the counter). If you order extra cheese at Carly’s, you actually get it! Clean and prompt. Did I say excellent pizza? ;) YUM!!!

I ordered a combination pizza and jojo’s, wow was it good! I have a cheese allergy, so they made it without cheese and it tasted amazing! It wasn’t dry without cheese like many other pizza places I have been to. The jojo’s were excellent and came with a side of ranch. They put a wonderful seasoning on the crust, which is my favorite. My new go to pizza place! They are locally owned, and the owners are very friendly. I would recommend if you want amazing pizza and a great customer service experience!

Pickup the Hawaiian pizza. Not bad, not great. Better when adding jalapeños. Would need to try other pies to get a real idea. But people were nice.

Amazing pizza and great customer service. Calzones are a little expensive, but much worth it.

Small place but I like the picnic tables… about four of them. Pizza was pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom. Very good. Next time I’ll have them cook it a little longer though. I could only eat a piece and a half the rest is in the fridge.

We were in town for a water polo camp nearby and stumbled upon Carly’s on the drive back to our hotel. We decided to give it a try. We opted for an extra large cheese pie (16″ for $ 11.99). The crust was both chewy and crunchy — which is precisely how we prefer it. The best part about it was the seasoning on the crust itself! The sauce was tasty and balanced the overall flavor of the pizza well. Service was super friendly and quick. My husband and I opted to get a beer while we waited on the pizza; we barely finished our pints before the pizza was ready to go! We would definitely return if we find ourselves in Gresham again!

I really do like this pizza. The taste is like no other and the atmosphere is great too. I haven’t had a pie I didn’t like in the last year.

I was told 25 minutes to pick up. I showed up at the 20 minute mark and was not acknowledged upon entering. After about 2 minutes someone helped me. When we got home a 3 minute drive we opened our box expecting a delicious cheesy pizza. What we found was a cold pizza. A little undercooked. I would not go back. That’s what we get for trying something new.

Wow! This is good pizza!
It seems hard to find a place that makes a good pizza and that doesn’t skimp on toppings. I’m happy that I ventured into Carly’s because the pizza is down right amazing.
Don’t make the same mistake I’ve made in the past and eat terrible pizza when Carly’s is available!

It makes me sad that this is the first review that Carly’s gets. It’s been here for years, and they’ve always used delicious ingredients– I know this, because I briefly worked for them ten years ago as a secondary, temporary income.
The other day, our Scion was in the shop at Toyota, and I told my partner (who, ironically was the reason I had worked at Carly’s many years ago, to buy her a ticket to move across the continent to live with me) that we ought to go into Carly’s. I hadn’t been in there since I’d worked there, so I had no idea whether or not the pizza or service would be any good at all, but I wanted to try it out because back then, it was actually really wonderful!
We came in and the service was incredibly friendly (this place very obviously thrives off of a regular clientele that live in the Gresham area). We ordered a personal Hawaiian pizza, a beer and some wine. We sat down in the dining area, and were served at our table with all of the condiments you could want for pizza. Then, the moment of truth; we bit into the pizza, and it was even more delicious than I remember it. A crispy outer crust, a soft warm inner crust, and a delicious sauce with bubbling natural cheese topping off a notably good quality ham and pineapple.
This place was spotless. The game room (lottery) was clean and laid back. they have LCD TV’s for sportsfans who are enjoying their meal or waiting for a pizza to go, or just hanging out and playing slots for a bit. I remember the owner (Dan) being a stickler for cleanliness. If customers weren’t in the store, we were taking the lights down and dusting them on the inside so it didn’t start looking dingy. A lot of love went into this little place, and we’re happy to switch from a chain to a place that offers such fantastic goods and services on a naughty, lazy night where we’re craving a good pizza.
The only sad part of our trip in was that I put a 5 dollar bill in the «Wolf Run» machine, an doubled it, and didn’t listen to my partner when she told me to cash out. Big spender ;)