McMillan’s Bakery

Cute mom and pop kinda shop. The cream donuts are fantastic and not overly sweet. I will be back again!

Stopped in today for donuts after reading the reviews on Unilocal.The donuts were delicious. I had a powdered cream and it was amazing. Finally a cream filled donut with more than a bite of cream! My wife had a boston cream donut and loved it. It was a little pricey but the quality was there. I’m glad we stopped in!

I have been a 50+ year fan of McMillians Bakery and would give 5 stars for your product. I know how hard you work and are diligent with your product line that is exceptional. However, On 5÷26÷16 @ Aprox 3:00 pm I witnessed the most horrendous customer service sever seen. The 2 mature sales ladies were in deep negative discussions about Gary and Arlene (Biemillers) in front of my wife and I. I was absolutely in shock with there lack of attention and made me feel embarrassed for the organization. I think original Mac and Gary Sr, are rolling in their grave! Biemiller family… better not trust your business to these type of sales people or there may not be a 76^th anniversary. Totally disgusted! (Real time cameras with audio /​video recording are needed)

What we ordered:
2 French crullers
2 jelly
2 apple fritters
2 chocolate frosted
4 cream filled — 2 w powder, 2 w/​o
What we received:
4 French crullers
2 plain w sugar
2 chocolate frosted
5 cream filled — all powdered
For $ 18 for a dozen donuts I expect my order to be filled EXACTLY with what I asked. It’s a shame this was my first experience because I won’t be going again. Half of my order was wrong.

If I were offered a last meal on earth it would hands down involve McMillan’s cream donuts. They are AMAZING. One of the wonders of the world, for sure. They are fluffy, messy, sweet, light, and satisfying all at once. And while they look like pure sugar, they do not possess that cloyingly sweet sickening aftertaste. By no means am I underestimating the calorie bomb that these provide, but their lightness and perfect balance of doughy and sweet filling make you blissfully forget.

Best cupcakes! I go out of my way just to get them. Very unique icing and taste. Can’t beat them.

Came here strictly for the cream donuts. I have been wanting to try them for a while. We walked in and was greeted right away. The service we received was excellent and they were very friendly. I didn’t see any cream donuts and I started to panic, however, they reassured me they had plenty, in the back. I ended up ordering a half dozen at close to $ 9.00.
The donuts were so pretty and looked exactly like all the photos on Unilocal.The only problem is there was just to much cream, for me. The donut itself, was so soft and melted in my mouth but I had to remove most of the cream filling. It was just to sweet for my liking. If I was someone that enjoyed an overstuffed donut, then I would have definitely fallen in love with this place. However, I didn’t enjoy removing most of the filling and it really made a mess for my eating experience. I may return to try something else, but I will definitely have to pass on the cream donuts.
Didn’t help that Krispy Kreme donuts was right across the street with the hot and fresh sign on. As I left the parking lot, I found myself heading across the street to spend more money. I hate a sweet tooth when your on a diet!

For a bakery that makes goodies since 1939, it’s just okay and the service is even more appalling, no hello, no smile and no goodbye — except from us who would prefer to drive 30miles away in Swedesboro for their strawberry shortcake which taste better with friendlier staff.
When you take the time to make your cream puff with chocolate topping on a nice wax paper cup but your terrible staff just mash it with their grubby hands partially destroying the puff pastry and glop it into a paper bag smearing down the sides, that’s exactly the kind of appreciation I felt while in the shop! Why make your desserts look nice when you serve it in that fashion!!! Happy Easter to you and goodbye to our patronage!

That’s 4 stars for the baked goods which are a bit high-​priced, but there’s one miserable woman who is always there who looks and acts like she hates waiting on you. The others are pleasant and helpful. Friday am before Easter called to see if they had a certain item. She said they did. I tried to reserve it and she sad «no.» Five minutes later I walked in the store to get it and she said they must have sold out. Very disappointing as it is one thing I get my dad once a year who lives 150 miles away. Asked if they could make me one for pickup the next morning. She said «no» again. You’re not selling priceless heirlooms. Try to be a little more helpful and appreciative of your loyal customers.

Yes. All the donuts. Eat them. Eat them now. Don’t share them. Put them in your mouth.
At $ 1.40 a donut, they’re not the cheapest game in town, but I love these so much more than anything I could get at one of the nearby chain shops.
I’ve never been in there during peak/​busy hours, but the staff has always been averagely polite to over the top wonderful. I can’t wait to eat my way through the rest of their offerings, but honestly, I don’t know how I’ll ever make it past the donuts.
(They also get the roller derby Team Donut stamp of approval. I brought them to a team meeting the other day, and they fell in love. More than one person mayyyyyyy have declared them better than Federal’s.)

Some of the best crème filled donuts in the area. A dozen gets you a Baker’s 13-​and there’s a true old school vibe-​they even wrap the box with the old string machine! (what do you get at Dunkin? Tape-​maybe!) If you are looking for a real bakery donut (not some processed Dunkin or even Krispy Kreme across the street) check this place out.
Pretty fair hours for a locally run place too. Most days they are open 7 – 7 meaning even us poor working folk can make it in on a weekday!
4 stars for sometimes cranky counter service (employees often bark at one another and are short with customers! Got scolded for asking about an apple cider donut today!), $ 10 credit card limit, and the fact that their iconic neon sign was removed a few years back meaning the building has lost a lot of its vintage charm! Despite all this, that doesn’t make the donuts taste any less amazing, so I guess I’ll keep going here even if I do get yelled at by the bakers.
UPDATE: A manager reached out about the employee’s rudeness and apologized. (I appreciate that!-and don’t worry, we’ll be back. I feel like someone could punch me in the face and as long as they handed me one of those donuts afterwards, I’d still be a loyal customer! haha)
She also noted that the sign was not able to remain up after roofing problems, the town didn’t allow them to put the letters back up) That’s so sad, Collingswood!

I’ve been going to this place since I was a kid. Their service and goods are amazing. Recently I went back after years of living out of state and the pies exceeded my expectations. Whether you’re looking for some crumb cake to bring to work, a single cupcake, or some pies for a holiday party– this is the place to go!

Bakery products like they should be. You’ll never go back to Dunkin’s.

I will never look at a doughnut the same this was a delicacy! I’ve never physically been in the bakery but a customer of mine drives from philly to jersey for your pastries and they are bangin!

I wanted to be amazed with fresh made donuts at this quaint little shop, but they were just ok. Maybe I would like a different flavor better? I didn’t care for the cream stuffed donuts with a sugary frosting-​like filling. Better than the chain donuts in the area but not the best place to get a donut. I will drive great distances to satisfy my sweet tooth!

McMillan’s has one the finest donuts in the area. It always is a hit with whoever you’re lucky to bring one to or just for yourself. It’s crème filled but not the way a jelly or pudding style donut would be. This donut is classier, baby. This donut is like an open faced crème cannoli with just the right amount of ingredients and topped with powdered sugar. Mmmmmmm yes! I did a 12 assortment for the office. Each one of the donuts were a hit but the mammoth sized ‘WHITE DONUT’ was talked about 48 hours later. Legendary? A firm yes at my office and definitely the route to go if your looking to bribe your way into a raise or maybe just bring in at a meeting. Even some of my gym addict co-​workers were saying thank you.
Across the street is Krispy Kreme but nothing can compete with the famous white donut from McMillans. Believe it, this is a repeat visit.

I rarely give 5 stars but this bakery deserves it. The best powdered jelly donuts ever!
It is a cute old school bakery that can have big lines on the weekend because everything is so good.
The rest of their donuts are great too especially the glazed Apple ciders.

We stopped in on Sunday afternoon surprised to fine the cases still full. We got two types of sticky buns, the nutty ones with almonds and some with raisins. We also got several muffins as well. Everything was very fresh. Service was good and prices were reasonable. There are only three parking spaces in the lot and you must back out onto a busy street.
Remember there is a Krispy Kreme almost across the street but this place knocks it down anyway.

I have frequent here before, and yesterday I had to stop by to pick up dessert for dinner with Good friends. They had other cakes, mostly St. Patty themed, and either chocolate or Yellow, so I went with the Strawberry Shortcake, which Had fresh strawberries & whip cream. It was a Hit! Not overly sweet & Yummy!
Too bad cream donuts aren’t my kind, Just Way too much cream for me, & not right consistency either. But there are other assorted pastries to choose from.
Return factor:
Of Course, just not all the time!

Everyone knows McMillan’s for their powdered cream doughnuts. These are so good they could sell themselves. Unfortunately, counter help is an obstacle sometimes, as customer friendliness is not something you can buy here. I went in asking specifically for a carrot cake and found that they had two sizes so I selected the larger one. I was charged only $ 25. I asked the young lady why it was the same price for both sizes, to be sure I was getting the right price for the product to which she said «at this point in the day, I DON’T CARE» (a little less than ½ hr before closing).
The two girls behind the counter also cursed and growled obnoxiously about the phone every time it rang as if they couldn’t be bothered with questions from anyone. I’d like to think it was just somebody having a bad day, but this kind of attitude in front of a manager indicates that it is acceptable practice here all the time.
The quality of the carrot cake was average, not extraordinary. Their choice of an overabundance of ingredients is not my taste as I do prefer simpler carrot cake recipes from elsewhere.
Occasionally, I do also buy bread here, and it has been better than supermarket bakeries, boh in quality and price.
Yes, Credit cards are accepted for orders with minimum of $ 10. All others must pay cash. The parking lot is difficult to maneuver multiple cars in because it is not much wider than a driveway. However, 15 minute parking on the street can be had for free by pressing the short term button on the parking meter.