Tony’s Pizzeria

Went here for the first time today. The lady working the front was so sweet. She wouldn’t let us pay until we got our food because she wanted to make sure it was satisfactory. My husband and I got two appetizers and a large pizza. All of which exceeded our expectations. It’s hard to come by good food accompanied by good service anymore but this place has it. I definitely recommend it! We will be back.

Pretty much the crispest, tastiest wings delivered ever! The sauce is on the side which keeps them crispy! They are delicious even without the sauce. Also delivery was super fast!

Tony’s is the best pizza in haddonfield. Crust is thin and crisp on the outside chewy inside. Sauce is not too sweet. Never greasy. I try other pizza from time to time but my kids always demand going back to Tony’s. Delivery service is consistently good. Rest of the menu is good, neighborhood pizza joint fare.

I’ve been going to Tony’s Pizza for 15 years. It’s my go-​to place for pizza. Not the best ever but pretty darn good. My husband requests long hots on the pizza and they are happy to oblige. The owners are an Italian couple named Jerry and Connie and are very nice. They are funny to watch interact especially when they get in an argument. My mother-​in-​law from Pittsburgh says she craves Tony’s Pizza when she’s in for a visit so we always order it when she’s in town. They also have a loyalty card and you get a free pizza after 10. They also offer an awesome special on Mondays: $ 7.99 for a large pie.

Very mediocre pizza. Ordered wings and unfortunately they were breaded wings. Yuck. Come on south jersey!
Much better pizza places. Nothing negative to say about the place but the food was just very, very average.

This is a little mom and pop shop and a great place to go for a slice of pizza. The prices are reasonable and the quality is always consistent.

Love Tony’s pizzas. Sauce is the best: Fresh, tomatoey. Not the thick over spicey stuff commonly found. Cheese is delicious and toppings generous. The other stuff is very good too. Delivery is prompt. (one time the pie had the toppings slide to one side and they offered to replace it.)

Tonys margarita pizza and wings are the best in town (as for hot). You can tell everything is made fresh in house. This is a gem of a place for authentic italian food!

A solid neighborhood restaurant. Reliable, inexpensive, pleasant, accommodating … Not high cuisine. Nothing gourmet, but good … what I’d call soul food, the food of my childhood growing up in an Italian neighborhood, that I could eat dinner after dinner if I had to, and never tire of.

The food is ok. .Had better pizza.
But the most important is they have mice infestation in the building.

Margarita pizza heaven! If you like lots of fab tomato sauce in comparison to just enough cheese to make it seem not completely unhealthy, you’ll love this pizza. The crust is the right kind of thin and crispy, and not crunchy like a cracker.

Haddonfield, you’re fortunate to have Tony’s in your neighborhood!
Every year I call from 1100 miles away in Tampa Bay to order one of Tony’s best hoagies for my cousin’s birthday in August. Their food is consistently good and delivery service is always right on time! My cousin would rather have one of their hoagies than any other birthday gift. I think that speaks for itself.
Since the owners speak Italian it gives me a chance to parli Italiano
as I did back in the day when I studied at Temple University’s campus in Rome.
I miss living in South Jersey but when I order from Tony’s Pizzeria all the good aroma’s flavors and memories return.
Gratzie per tutti!
Michael M.

Every once in a while when I visit my grandparents in Haddonfield, we order from Tony’s. It is a really great family owned restaurant. The owners are very personable and make you feel very welcome. You receive a lot of food for the money you spend. I particularly like their panini sandwiches :) The food is usually made within 20 minutes, our a little longer if they are super busy (which is understandable). But overall I think this restaurant is great!

Tony’s is a solid pizzeria for take out or delivery. The crust is nice and thin, cooked perfectly, with the right amount of cheese and sauce. They charge $ 1 for delivery and their overall prices are good. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice (or two) or ordering a whole pie for a night in, Tony’s is a solid and dependable choice. I recommend it.

If you are visiting Haddonfield, as I was, you’ll immediately notice how dang cute this town is. Everything in the downtown area is adorable — restaurants, shops, houses, business… everything. So when we walked into Tony’s after reading some good reviews, we were like, «meh.» Not the cute restaurant one would come to expect after driving through the quaint little streets of Haddonfield. We were skeptical. But then we ordered food from the very nice Italian woman behind the counter, and when it was brought out on actual dinner plates (not paper or styrofoam), I was very impressed. You wouldn’t expect a hole-​in-​the-​wall place like this to use real plates and silverware. We ordered some caesar salad, gluten-​free cheese pizza, and one medium pizza that was half margherita, half bruschetta. The caesar salads were pretty good. The dressing was thick and creamy, and they served it on the side, which I appreciate. It also hard hardboiled egg slices, which I liked. My friend who is gluten-​free said that the gluten-​free pizza crust was pretty good, and she really appreciated that they gave her her own individually-​wrapped pizza cutter so there was no cross-​contamination. My other friend and I shared the bruschetta and margherita pizza. The margherita was really good but I wish we had gotten a whole bruschetta, because it was possibly the best pizza I’ve ever had. Oh my goodness, SO good. Ridiculously fresh mozzarella, delicious tomato, basil, garlic, and spring mix. Perfectly flavored. Mmmmmmm, you must try it. I’m going to be dreaming about this pizza for a long time.
Anyway, do not be fooled by the un-​cute exterior of the place. The people are great, service was great, and food that we tried was incredibly delicious.

We’ve been regulars for the 6 yeas we’ve lived in Haddonfield and of course that means we think it’s the best pizza in town. The owners are great and know their customers. They often bring garlic knots for the kids and always fawn over the little ones. Pizza ranges from solid/​good to occasionally great.
It’s a friendly cool scene and I have to admit the soccer on the TV (in Italian) and kitchen chatter (Italian) influences my judgement — but what can I say — there is nothing phony about this place and they put out a pretty good pie.

I remember when good friend of mine owned a consignment shop 3 stores down, she would go grab a margherita pizza & water. I would go visit, & I was hooked. OMG! I would safely assume the other ones great too. I stopped here today, after running errands, got couple slices. The slices had home-​made sauce, tons garlic & Basil, simply heaven! It runned by cutest Italian couple, just adorable! Love this little place! If not anything else, go get Margherita Pizza! Pizza-​pizza!!!

After reading Marcello D.‘s very solid review of Tony’s, I swung by one day last week while running errands on my lunch break.
The door was held open for me by a friendly gentleman on his way out, and I entered to hear the husband and wife duo behind the counter speaking to each other in Italian. Swoon!
I ordered two slices to go, one plain and one veggie. Fifteen minutes later I was back at my desk, inhaling the pizza as fast as humanly possible. The slices were nicely sized and with a thin crust. The toppings on the veggie pizza made me feel downright healthy about my lunch choice. I felt like I gave into my pizza craving without going way overboard in the calorie department. Whether or not that was true… is irrelevant at this point.
I have had better pizza, but for a quick takeout slice, Tony’s wasn’t a bad option. I’ll check them out again sometime soon.

Good service can enhance the way you perceive any business. Tony’s, a mom and pop pizza shop, works this angle very well.
It’s always a pleasure to walk in here and be greeted with a «Ciao, Marcello,» no matter how long it has been since my last visit. The owners seem happy to see me and genuinely interested in hearing about my children. They respond by telling me stories about their family. It’s a small detail that makes a big impact.
Their delivery service is also very good. They come quickly and the food is reasonably priced. It’s also a great spot to run in and grab a quick cannolo, if you’re sweet tooth is aching.

Best pizza in the area. Cheap pizza nights on Monday and Tuesday. Can’t beat the price!
Delivery guy rocks, got to my place in 15 minutes during a snow storm!