Nicky-B’s Pizza

I like Nicky B’s. Conveniently located in Haddonfield, and they’re a go-​to of mine for good, reliable pizza and fries. I always go with the pepperoni pizza and fries on the side. You can order to go, or eat in. Plus they have a couple of outside tables for outdoor dining in the summer. Avoid right around 3 – 5 pm, as it tends to be flooded with kids grabbing a slice after school.

While we love the food there they have fallen off, and in turn have lost a 2 year customer. We ordered from them all the time at one point there were weekly orders placed here. But one mistake after another has me giving business to another local place. First issue was when we ordered fries for a friend along with our order and they put cheese on them. Out friend is lactose intolerant so they ruined their dinner. Second issue was instead of giving us the fries we asked for with our wrap we got chips. There were also tomatoes in the wrap and we asked for none. I called and they promised to credit our next order for the cost of the wrap which was $ 8.49. We made another order this time just pizza and our usual wings and asked them to apply the credit to order. We were told it would be. Got our usual order of wings where we always request ranch dipping sauce, not only did they not give us any dipping sauce but they only applied a $ 4.00 credit to our bill. Seriously it’s the principle. They can easily pull up our order history to see that we are regular customers. Not anymore.

Excellent wings and pizza! I always have a great experience when visiting Nicky B’s. Very friendly staff. Love this place!!!

Little pizza joint in downtown Haddonfield. Solid pizza, finger food, sandwiches, etc. Nothing special. Service seems to be very slow, last time I was in I ordered a Stromboli and ended up waiting 25 minutes. Better pizza places in and around Haddonfield.

Have to have another one of those reubens. Awsome sandwich, pretty close to some of the jewish delis I’ve tried. Staff always friendly and pizza is tops.

My husband and I have eaten here a few times now, and we’re always happy. The pizza slices are a decent size, and the crust is nice and crispy. The cheese they use is very good, which I think is important. The mozzarella sticks are another thing we’ve tried, which are thick and crispy. And the service is great. Everyone is so kind and happy.

Solid meh. Close to work. Food is bland and specials are too large for me to eat without regretting it later (although reasonably priced). The pizza is inevitably coming out my pores within an hour of eating it.

The pizza is awful. Its akin to eating cardboard with some tomato sauce sprinkled on. I didn’t think it was possible to screw up an Italian hoagie but they proved me wrong.
Although I haven’t had any problems with the staff, the quality of the food is enough to keep me from ever going back.

They put little effort into their pizza and it shows. Cheese steaks are pretty good because they use Amaroso bread.

My office is around the corner from this place. So its a convenient place to grab lunch, I’ve ordered the hoagies and club sandwiches, which were perfect sized and flavorful. I can’t really comment on the pizza, but I do know that my sammies were pretty good for a small place.
The turkey club is pretty amazing for the price and all the hoagies are worth it, plus you can make two meals out of most of their sammies. I definitely will be trying more things on the item. But if you’re in the area, stop by and give it a try.

Eh, after today’s experience, I very unfortunately need to dock a star from my rating.
Ordered Italian, expected Italian, the receipt said Italian, but my hoagie turned up American when I opened it back at my office. I certainly wasn’t going to walk across town to bring it back since it was just a hoagie, but the experience *does* steer me away from future orders.

Owner was rude to us.
Food was nothing above average.
Probably not worth your time.

Nicky B’s pizza is our go-​to spot for delivery when we just don’t have the energy or time to cook. They have very good burgers and wings. The pizza is a little bit thicker than most of the other spots in the area and cooked to the point where it is a little crisp as well. If you enjoy this in a pizza, which we do, you’ll love Nicky B’s.
The only downside is that we have noticed some inconsistencies recently. For example, the hot wings used to be a little tangy but easily palatable by all. The last few times we ordered wings, the hotness has ranged from the convention we knew to fire-​breathing hot. Unfortunately, the times it was too hot were points where we ordered wings for a very large group and hardly any were eaten.
This is not enough of an inconvenience to prevent us from ordering there again in the future. However, in the future, we will likely need to ask how hot is hot.

They don’t make extra large pies. There is nothing mega about their mega fries, in fact there were barely any in the container. They’re over priced. And from what I can tell, they are they only pizza place within walking distance to me, so I’m stuck with it :(