On A Roll Deli

My favorite deli in the area! I wouldn’t go anywhere else. They have great food, great prices and provide amazing service every time I go in.

I was having some friends over for a luncheon when I lived in Highland. One of my
guests managed a five star Italian restaurant in Westchester County and knew exceptional
products from mediocre ones. I wanted to get some Italian deli for cold appetizers, so
I ordered some prosciutto (lean and flavorful), parmigiano reggiano cheese (nutty and crumbly, as it should be), roasted red peppers (done perfectly) and mushrooms stuffed with gorgonzola cheese (to die for). I also took home some mozzarella cheese for a caprese salad, with tomatoes, fresh basil, oregano and balsamic vinegar. Everything was outstanding, but the best reaction I could have imagined came from my restauranteur guest, who stated that it was among the best Italian deli she had ever tasted! I had to agree with that assessment as everything was amazingly good, and I have yet to find a deli to duplicate that experience.

Walked in there at 12:15 for lunch. I scanned the chalkboards for a sandwich and landed upon the Sicilian Combo — Prosciutto, Soppressata, Provolone, Capicola, and Roasted Red Peppers. It’s fantastic. They put a balsamic glaze on it to give it that extra zing. The meat is sliced nice and thin. The roll is fresh. The peppers give it plenty of juice so it’s not dry. Overall a great sandwich!

I always get breakfast and lunch sandwiches here. Very tasty!
Limited hours, so no dinner.

I’ve been to this deli several times. Every time, the service is inattentive, sloppy, or outright rude. They make good sandwiches but they don’t have a clue about customer service. I went by there about ½ hour to closing one evening after a long drive. They were preparing to paint after closing. They refused to serve me although they could have and they could have waited another ½ hour to get started as well. Maybe they are happy with the customers they have but my business is going elsewhere.

Had time to kill spent driving around the area and was driving around aimlessly looking for a place to grab a bite to eat.
Seeing the «On A Roll» sign, I made the U-​turn and stopped in.
It turned out to be a great decision.
This is a WORLD CLASS sandwich shop… and I’m a sandwich connoisseur.
This place is a real hidden gem for you folks in Highland. If I lived across the river, I’d buy the toll pass just to get across the Hudson as often as possible to eat here.
The staff seemed to know everyone that hit the door… and treated me like a regular even though I was 1,200 miles from home.
The sandwich specials looked great, as did the deli counter. If I was staying in town longer, I’d have bought some stuff from the deli counter to take with me.
As I was just in for lunch, I had one of their special combos. I actually can’t even recall what was in it — but it was spectacular.
Great ingredients — the bread and meat were terrific — and a great little setting to down the sammy while chatting with the employees.
I love this place. if I’m ever back in the area — or even anywhere close-​by — I’ll make a point of climbing the bluffs of the Hudson up to Highland to stop back in at On a Roll.
Can’t stress enough how much I enjoyed the staff here. They were really great.

Can’t believe this place didn’t have a page on Unilocal yet! I would have guessed it for a neighborhood fixture.
Just moved into town, and after driving past this place countless times, decided to stop by and give it a try. It’s a pretty old-​school Italian deli, where the scent of cheese and cured meats is the first thing that hits you upon entry. They have a variety of classic sandwich combinations, as well as a rotating cast of deli specials. I tried the italian combo, which has thin sliced Cappy ham, soppresata, pepperoni and provolone. Dee-​lish.
The interior is standard, just your classic deli set-​up with a few tables, a cooler case full of beverages, and a rack of chips. They have a whole variety of italian products for sale, including big jugs of olive oil, dried salami, and tinned italian tuna. You can also buy cold cuts and cheese by the pound.
The service was friendly and the prices are just right for what they sell.