My Way Tavern

This place needs help. Fly in my salad. My favorite menu item (their wings) were soggy and a couple of them still had the little chicken hairs on the skin. GROSS. Had to ask our server 3 times for my drink (which never came) AND she couldn’t get our order right. We were a party of 2 (myself and my 6 year old) on a wednesday night. Our busboy apologized for her and said «things have been like this» for awhile now.

Came here for our anniversary dinner. So thankful they have Highland Gaelic Ale on tap!!! Ordered the chips & dip appetizer, the salsa is really really good. One of the May specials is crab cake sandwich topped with Chipotle aioli. Oh. My. Gosh. I’m from Maryland and always skeptical of any crab cake. These are amazing, I promise. Hubs ordered the Goodfella and finished it before I could ask for a bite. The crowd was as minimal as we’ve ever seen it, but it’s a Sunday. Our server, Summer, was amazing. Answered all of our questions, and if she didn’t know, she went and found someone who did. Love the extra effort!

Great food! The seafood Mac and cheese, tenderloin sandwich, creamed spinach and onion straws… PHENOMENAL! Hats off to the cooks! Whoa! Everyone in the family was happy! We’ve been to both locations (Raleigh was a blast!) love the layout of Raleigh and my husband prefer the Holly Springs layout.
Looking forward to trying some of the other intend on the menu too!
Good waitress and wings. Not a thing to complain about.
Seafood Mac and cheese leftovers were just as great of not better leftover!

My Way Tavern is a wonderful addition to the downtown Holly Springs community. Outside dining overlooks three town landmarks: the Mims house, Dewar’s Antiques and Holly Springs United Methodist Church. It is located close to Mims park where you can hike to the original springs surrounded by holly trees.
The food is outstanding and dining outside is lovely. The service is friendly, efficient and knowledgeable.
This is the watering hole for local town hall workers and politicians. It is a great community asset.
If I had one suggestion, and this is minor, is that the audio volume of the music played be cut down a bit… sometimes it is hard to hear what your dining partners and servers are saying.

It took 45 minutes for us to get our food on a Saturday night. We only saw our waitress one time in that span of time. We complained to another waitress who was passing by and she suggested we would «more than likely be getting our food…» and was very rude to us. The manager came and sat at our table and talked about how they were in the weeds, were unable to get food out, and then proceeded to do nothing for us to compensate. (I think he sat down with us and spilled his guts hoping we would be a shoulder to cry on but really… we were just too hungry to help him with his problems.) It would have gone a long way to apologize with some sort of freebie and would have cost them very little. (Since now we won’t be returning — ever.) We saw very little food being served which was a bad sign we ignored. The waitress left a weirdly gushing and nice note on our receipt which — while sweet — was just another strange aspect to the night there.
The food was average. The noise was spectacular. The manager was a tool. The wait was unforgivable.

Best restaurant and bar in Holly Springs! Great food and awesome staff! Huge assortment of beers. They have monthly food specials which are always fun to try. So far every item that I have tried has been delicious!!! This month’s special is a salmon sandwich that I could eat everyday it is so good!!!

Nice little tavern with great food and beer. There isn’t any fabric upholstery in the place, so it can be very loud when it’s busy or games are on TV. The staff is very friendly and skilled.

We love my way. It’s our go to place when we have visitors in town. I the babe sandwich and the guacamole burger.

Excellent food, great service, friendly and helpful staff. Unusual food (in a good way) for a sports tavern.
Extremely noisy, mostly because walls, ceiling and floors are hard surfaces. They could help the noise by covering 15% of the parallel surfaces with some sound deadening décor. We couldn’t easily have a conversation at our table of three people.
We went on a cold night which was a problem every time someone opened an outside door. Unfortunately the smokers had a habit of frequently opening and holding the back door open, which froze and smoked our table even though we were 20 feet from the door.
If we dine there again, we’ll ask for a table WAAAYYY in the back, hopefully away from doors and noise.

The fish and chips are fantastic and the service was great My new favorite place in Holly Springs

If you need to be saved from an absolutely awful, holiday-​induced hangover, the food and beers will bring you right around.

I’ve been coming to My Way since I moved here 6 years ago (around the same time they opened). The staff is awesome, the food is phenomenal, and if there is an issue they make up for it — no questions asked outside of «how do we make it better?» The beer selection is quite extensive and includes many local breweries! There is always something going on and if you have a question or want to personalize a meal, just ask! Best items on the menu are ANY of the mac & cheeses (I love the seafood mac), the wings are always on point, the meatloaf is delicious, and if you like sandwiches they have one helluva selection! For all of the restaurants I have frequented, My Way is the one I always come back to!!!

Great place for beer and food in Holly Springs. My Daughter and I got The Dean to split and for my side I opted with the delicious steak fries. I do like the fact that they split the sandwich for us in the kitchen. Unfortunately, service was slow and it was very loud inside.

We’ve been going to My Way since we started looking for houses in Holly Springs in October 2015. We’ve had several very good meals here and enjoy the atmosphere. The staff is always friendly and helpful with suggestions when you just can’t figure out what to eat. Even when the meal is not quite up to par (Cajun chicken pasta) the staff is quick to make it better offering something else up in its place. Don’t be afraid to try something new here.

We love My Way. It’s a great local bar with outstanding food. They have your above average typical pub fare along with amazing unique sandwiches and salads and some heartier dishes. The best is the Tavern Salad with grilled chicken and balsamic dressing. They also have some of the best Mac and cheese around. All different kinds. The staff is always super friendly and accommodating. Not only to me and my husband but my young son as well. They have golden tee, cornhole and live music regularly along with weekly trivia. Always clean bathrooms and reasonable priced. Great to stop in for lunch during the week or to hang out any night.

How have I not reviewed My Way already? Our very favorite place in Holly Springs, no question. They can always be counted on for a great takeout meal, and easily the best place to dine in for lunch in the area. Great beers, attentive staff, varied menu, good for kids (daytime), and food is well prepared. Obviously, it’s loud at night, but their takeout process is really on point. The menu has very few missteps… meatloaf has always been dry when we’ve tried it, but the many other delicious options more than make up for it. Some of our favorites: chicken parm, Hawaiian salad, all of the burgers, Mahi Mahi dinner, short rib, all sandwiches, the Mac!!! Now I’m hungry. There are so many new places coming to town, but My Way will always be our #1 pick in Holly Springs.

I have been to My Way Tavern a few times now and enjoy this place each and every time.
Our server, Christine, was great! She was extremely knowledgeable about the drink and food menus. I was debating another beer and she brought me a few samples of her favorites to try, she made excellent recommendations.
Boyfriend and I decided to split an order of the Baja Tacos with Pasta Salad and The Shorty with Fries. Our waitress had them split it up in the kitchen which was very helpful. Both entrees were tasty, my favorite was the pasta salad while Boyfriend’s favorite was the taco. The food is always consistently great here.
Great local spot, will be returning.

Great food and service. I would say that this is the best bar in Holly Springs. I think the food is great!

Pretty decent beer selection. They have 4 rotating seasonal taps that appear to change weekly. In addition they have like 10 – 15 standard local craft taps.
The buffalo mac and cheese is a house favorite — really it is. I know that’s a weird dish for a bar, but it’s all homemade and out of this world. Actually every one of their Mac and Cheese dishes is incredible.
We also like their homemade chips and chicken tenders. Both are fresh and not frozen.
Last, it can get really loud in here. Depending on what you are looking for that can be good or bad. When we take our kids there it’s great — nobody can hear the loud voices or the screaming. But the crowd can get a little much (bar scene crowd) after 7pm on the weekend so we try to go early.

This is one of my favorite places to eat in the area. The beer selection is good and the food is even better. I usually go for the seafood mac and cheese since it is probably the best thing they have. But dont count out the sandwiches which are amazing. When I opt for a sandwich the Don is great with a buffalo chicken stud. In the grand scheme of things if you get a sandwich you wont be disappointed.
As for the service they are very attentive and friendly. The staff is also very good about advising on beer selections as well. Since they have a number of seasonal’s its good to get a number of samples.
The ambiance is next to none and has a very inviting layout. It is one of the reasons I keep going back.