Sal’s Pizza Place

Finally good pizza in Huntley! We’ve tried them all but last year finally discovered Sal’s Pizza Company in Algonquin. The best pizza & garlic cheese breadsticks. It was a 30 minute drive for us (Pingree Grove) and when I saw they took over Luigi’s in Huntley, I couldn’t have been more thrilled. I was slightly disappointed with our first order as I expected Sal’s quality. Slight burn & a little dry. I thought perhaps they were working out kinks & ordered again a month later. Everything I hoped for. Absolutely mouth-​watering, crunch of the crust, melt in your mouth, fresh cheese. Heaven!
Tip: Both times our pizza was ready at pickup (25 minutes). The first time I think they overestimated & perhaps that’s why it was dry. The second time, I went in 5 – 10 minutes early & it was still ready. Hot, FRESH, and the epitome of perfection. I’ll be picking up a few minutes «early» from now on.

Ordered delivery tonight for the first time. Will definitely be a returning customer! The pizzas were delicious — we tried both deep dish and thin crust. Just outstanding flavor! Delivery was fast and the customer service was great — from placing our order to our delivery person. Prices were also great considering they did not skimp on the toppings. Highly recommend!

This place is A-O.K. I ate inside and it was on the cold side. The waitress was nice and the pizza was good with lots of toppings. However, I thought the prices were a tad high.

I use to go the Sal’s in Algonquin and I am glad they have a location in Huntley now. I travel a lot for work and have been to many of the top rated pizza restaurants in the US, and I always enjoy coming back and having a good a pizza from Sal’s. I had eaten there before when it was still Luigi’s, which I enjoyed, but Sal’s is so much better. Their pizza has an excellent crust and is seasoned to perfection. They are generous with topping and put a ton of cheese on the pizza’s. This is my go to place when I need a local pizza.

Good thin crust pizza. Toppings are generous and the cheese is good. I won’t order mushrooms again, they seem like canned mushrooms and for $ 27 for a 16″ pizza, I’d expect fresh. Pizza was good the next day reheated in the oven.

Pros: pizza good with lots of ingredients.
Staff pleasant. Clean dining room.
Cons: a bit expensive but the toppings are robust so there is a reason.

Love their pizza and salads are quite excellent! It’s our go to place in the area for pizza.

Best thin crust pizza in the area. I’ve never dined in but the take out is great and the staff is very pleasant

I have been looking for a good pizza place around Huntley area for quite awhile, WELL I FOUND ONE. We tried Sal’s for the first time today. The pizza was the best I have had in a long time. There were lots of toppings on my pizza. It tasted like a good pizza should taste. Believe it or not I can’t wait to go back and have another pizza. Next time I’m going to try the deep dish, saw that another customer had some and BOY did it look good.
I guess you can tell I would highly recommend Sal’s Pizza. I will be back soon.

The pizza at Sal’s was 3 stars. Bland pizza with a good crisp crust. Luigi’s cheese was far better. If you must sit down for your pizza, then in Huntley Sal’s us your place. If you want a good pizza delivered go with Papa Savarios, or Tuffanos.

Great place for pizza in Huntley. This place is located downtown. Have been here a few times for pick up and the pizza is always good.

This is the best pizza in the area. The prices may be a little higher, but the quality is superb.
If you want cheap, get Dominos. I ate cold leftovers the next day and I was still in heaven.

First I just want to say that I miss Luigis pizza really bad Loved the pizzas and hospitality BUT this Isn’t about Luigis Sals pizza was just OK and prices are a bit too much.

Very bland, almost tasteless pizza. Basically cheese not of great quality with tomato paste on basic crust. Mushrooms tasted like they were canned. Asked about garlic for pizza, fresh or jarred… jarred was the response. Prices a bit higher than most. Lots of choices in area, may want to look elsewhere. Lou Malnatis. …Village Pizza… phenomenal options.

New owners are great as is the waitress Kathleen. The sausage pizza was to die for. It tasted just like Luigi”\‘s when he was making them good. Prices are much higher for pizzas which was disappointing. The pasta dishes were less than Luigi’s. This is the only sit down place in the immediate area with good pizza but wish he would reconsider keeping Luigis menu prices or as close to it as possible. All my friends that went to Sal’s loved the pizza now.

We weren’t fans of Luigi’s…the crust always seemed burnt. When we heard there was a new owner, we thought we’d give them a try.
We weren’t disappointed. The fiery shrimp appetizer tasted great, very similar to bang bang shrimp from Bonefish… but the portion was a bit small for the price.
The pizzas were pretty good. The order was correct, and it came quickly. The crust was still a little well done, but not burnt tasting like Luigi’s.
I did feel it was a little on the pricy side, too.
We’ll order from there again.

We went to Sals pizza for pick up. Excellent pizza. The inside is sorta drab cuz it’s an old building. But I was there for good pizza and that it was! Cheese sticks good too. I will return.