New York Pizza & Pasta

I give the place a 2 stars specifically for the pizza, everything else gets a 1 from me. Before you even step inside the restaurant, it looks depressing and run down. When you step inside you’ll be greeted by a hostess and they’ll seat you inside the dining room. When you enter the dining room theres old booths with holes and old looking chairs used in the 90s.
Our server was quick and attentive, very nice. When we sat down my friends decided we’d get the buffet. I mostly came cause I wanted to try the pasta, I was let down. As I scooped the pasta from the scoop onto the plate it was all oily and cold. not very fresh. I decided to eat it anyway cause I was really hungry, so I sat down and ate it and it was very plastic… Not fresh at all. I took two slices of pizza and it’s just standard pizza, nothing special.
TLDR I honestly could get the same pizza (if not better) at Dominos… just order and you don’t even need to come.

Love this place, love the chicken ceaser salad!!! and the pizza and bread sticks are great also! everyone is usually friendly, havent had a bad experience yet!

I have only ordered delivery so I can not offer a review of eating in. However, now that I know they have a salad bar, I will be stopping in! I love a salad bar. My delivery experience has been exceptional! I have to say they are some of the nicest people I have ever experienced! From the person who answers the phone to take my order, to the person who delivers the food; they are beyond polite, professional and friendly! I have ordered the pizza numerous times and it is great! The crust is thin and cooked just right, with an abundant amount of toppings. I hate a stingy pizza! I have also ordered the lasagna and antipasto. Both were also delicious! Way to go NY Pizza & Pasta in Indian Trail! You are doing everything right!

We are originally from CT and haven’t been able to find any good pizza places in the area– until now. This place has take out, delivery (certain miles), buffet and dine in seating. We dined in. Buffet is basic but you’d be missing out if you didn’t order off the menu. Amazing NY style pizza. The calzone was delicious! Appetizers were amazing. The best was probably the soups!!! They are to die for!!! Great friendly service (it is NC after all!)

I have been here for lunch several times. All the servers are nice. Nice selection for your salad. They have Stromboli on the buffet and it’s so good! Pizza is also delicious. My favorite is the veggie. They also have pasta. My favorite is the penne with garlic. It is so flavorful!

I love this place for lunch. The salad bar is my go to choice. The service is quick and friendly. Everything on the salad, pizza, and pasta bar is always fresh and good. A great place to come to fill you up. Worth the money.

Not sure about the pizza but the calzones were great until I saw a roach crawling beside me on the wall. On another day, I ordered for someone at work, the young girl answering the phones just hung up after I said thank u. That’s what really pissed me off. I think I’m done with this place.

My wife and I are originally from CT, and consider ourselves to be picky when it comes to pizza. A friend told us to try this place, we’re really glad we did as the pizza is very good, the service is always friendly and the best part is that it is close to home so when we need a quick fill in this is a really great option. I grew up eating New Haven style pizza (about 20 minutes from Wooster Street) and although I would not rate NYPP with those pizzerias, I would still say that this is a great option for those in Indian Trail.

I love this place! Everyone is really friendly and their food is amazing.
Everything at the buffet is delicious and fresh. I also looooooooove their calzones.

I have never tried the pizza here, but my family and I are huge fans of the meatballs. We order them quite often for large family occasions, or for spaghetti nights at the house. They are a great price, and taste absolutely delicious. The crew is very friendly, and attentive.

I wouldn’t come here for pizza, because the pizza is not NY style and didn’t look that great from what I saw available on the buffet. However, I will definitely return here for the calzones and stromboli. They offer one of the best calzones I’ve ever had, with a slightly crispy crust. Not heavy or greasy. Try the house special — pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, and onion — with mozzarella and ricotta. Only $ 6.49. Lunch service was speedy and attentive.

Pizza is average. One step above Cici’s as another reviewer commented. They don’t refill the pizzas often enough also… so if someone hordes the only topping combination you would eat… good luck. Salad bar crappy, small setup means lack of salad topping possibilities. No marinara on the buffet to dip crust, breadstick, or anything else into.
Sandwiches ordered off the menu (non buffet) are very decent. Chicken parm and meatball are both a lot of food for the money. Comes with a sad little bag of Ruffles as I recall =/​…buffalo wings are very decent for the money. Only 2 sauce choices for wings but you get a lot for the money. My GF doesn’t like going there, when I suggest it as I’m quickly reminded of a dead roach she found on the booth cushion. Waiters/​waitresses are super friendly, I’ve never had bad service there.

I remembered pizza being ordered for lunch at work once from a «New York» pizza place that was pretty good and since this place was close by I thought this was it. I tried the buffet and the pizza I had was NOT as good as I remembered but was decent. The salad bar was ok as well but the dressings were horrible! I tried the Italian first and then ranch and both were bad. The pasta didn’t look appetizing so I didn’t try it. Overall the pizza is probably just a level above CiCi’s.

As a Native Yorker, I always struggle with finding descent pizza spots in NC. NYPP was definitely good, as well as they’re wings. Nice atmosphere and they have a good buffet for those who prefer a variety of choices… Remember folks, finding NY pizza in NC will be a challenge… Operative word, NY, this is NC…

This is NOT New York pizza or pasta. It is about the same quality as Cici’s, if not worse. The pizza was very bad and bland, but edible if you are starving. Pasta was not edible at all. I should mention that the pasta options were penne with either completely flavorless marinara, or with oil and tons of gigantic chunks of garlic. Restaurant was very cramped, even though it was empty. There was one other table, and we were seated in the smallest little booth I’ve ever seen. Very cheap and tacky looking. The «buffet» was two small pizzas, and two small containers of penne. Everything looked like it was from about 1970 or so. I think the buffet is only around $ 5, but it’s not even worth that.

We have been on a hunt for pizza but all you can get around here is New York styple pizza and no one knows how to make deep dish or stuffed pizza. So we’ve been trying several places to find our go to place. For New York style pizza, New York Pizza & Pasta is the best we’ve had in this area and we’ve tried many places!!! The wings are terrible. It’s a great place to grab a pizza if you don’t feel like making food at home. I’m still not totally satisfied so I’ll let you know if I find anything better.

This place has been around for awhile and hasn’t changed much. The pizza is OK. If your sick of th chain pizza places and you want something more homeade then this will do just fine. If you want some really GOOD pizza, ask me and I’ll steer you in the right direction.

The other night after picking my kid up from day care and too tired to cook, I decided that I wanted pizza and was curious to try NYP&P. Since that evening, I’ve been back a second time because the pizza is pretty good. They serve large slices, have fresh toppings, great sauce — not what you’d expect from a strip plaza in Indian Trail.
BUT don’t forget that half of New Jersey and New York live now live in Union County and they’re opening some pretty fabulous restaurants.
A big surprise are the deserts. For $ 3, you can have a monster slice of cake or cheesecake and both are delish. There’s even a buffet for lunch or dinner.
I think what I like most about this place is that it’s a great place to just enjoy a slice, enjoy talking with friends, without the distractions of a million tv’s.

This place has a nice buffet that is worth checking out if you enjoy that sort of thing. The buffet has a salad, a few pasta items, several pizzas and stromboli. Although they call themselves NY they really aren’t, the crust is too think to be NY style. Even if it isn’t traditional NY pizza it tastes just fine and I’ve enjoyed both their sandwiches and calzones.

Dropping into this unassuming strip-​mall restaurant on a Friday night, we found one heck of a crowd. I mean they were absolutely slammed. Khan’s, which is just a couple of doors down, had almost no one inside. So I either the food was great, Khan’s is bad, or some combination of both.
We’ve been to Khan’s, and the food there isn’t bad at all, so we didn’t know what to expect. What we did know is that NYPP, as the server’s shirts proudly proclaimed, was absolutely hopping. So we decided to stay. Somewhat surprisingly, we found a table without so much as a wait. I guess everyone moved fast enough that it just worked out that way.
While they offer a menu, and they seem to offer delivery as well, the attraction at New York Pizza and Pasta is definitely their buffet. Spread out in a corner of the lobby area, it holds four or five pizzas of varying toppings, some form of breadsticks (often stuffed), a couple varieties of pasta, and a healthy salad bar.
What it doesn’t offer, unlike many pizza buffets, is a dessert selection. It’s not that they don’t have a dessert offering there — they do. But it doesn’t come on the buffet. You have to buy it separately, and it’s under the counter up front. The servers don’t really offer it, even if you ask. It’s like you pick it up on the way out. So it’s like they just don’t want to sell it, which is a little odd.
As to the food itself, very tasty. The cheese and the sausage and onion pizzas were excellent. The others were good, but a bit heavy for my taste. The pasta was good, and I have to admit that I didn’t even try the salad. But I did have plenty of the pizza. Yum.