Sunset Restaurant at Islip Town Beach

Sunset is a laid back beach bar/​grill simple as that. We had a veggie pizza and baked crabs which were perfect to munch on while grabbing a drink and enjoying (listening to, not participating in) karaōke. The flounder is my favorite here, very fresh, just a little squeeze of lemon and good to go. Definitely plan on paying this place another visit once the warm weather is back to enjoy the live music and, of course, the view.

Had dinner at new Sunset Grill in Islip. Great food warm friendly service. Lobster roll excellent great flavor will be going back!

First time since they moved from the beach to Main Street, but I am already loving it! It is a bit pricey for some items like flounder or salmon, but very tasty. The atmosphere is like being at a beach. I had the broiled flounder with brown rice and veggies. Had tea to wash it down with and finished off with the best damn cheesecake in the world. The whole dinner was awesome! As I stated earlier, pricey, but good. I highly recommend it.

A hidden gem nestled in Islip Beach… Great Food at fair prices. The portions are very generous so bring your appetite. Everything is made to order so be patient, trust me your patience will be rewarded… Whether its the great breakfast pizza or blueberry pancakes for breakfast or huge paninis for lunch… everything, including the amazing view and the service, was fantastic and well worth the trip! I would definitely recommend!

Before I mention the food… Hey guys!!! BOLT DOWN THE UMBRELLAS. Someone could have gotten badly hurt today as three of them took off in the wind like dominos… including ours… which picked up with the wind. stood on our table… while I tried to hold onto it. not a huge crowd. no one hurt. but as my husband exited the bathroom he saw the one coming toward me while I ducked and covered my head.
The food. husband’s burger looked good… no complaints. My lobster roll… I know where I have to go to get a great one. Kingston’s Clam Bar, West Sayville. Yours was disguised as an overflowing lobster roll with your secret ingredient at the bottom… shredded lettuce!!! No thanks.
We may try again before the weather gets cool… but consider less celery and NO LETTUCE!

Do NOT go for breakfast. While their day service has been excellent the few times I’ve been, My wife and I just waited over an hour after ordering and didn’t even get the orange juice, water and coffee we asked for, never mind our breakfast. Multiple tables had to get up and leave after waiting 20 minutes and more for drinks. Needs a serious overhaul of organization for the morning crowd.

Horrible food, was gross the lobster roll was bad, like I am gonna get sick bad, the mosquitoes were brutal the only reason this place has one star was the waitress was extremely, nice and fairly new at her job
The beer was warm no matter what kind you ordered
if this was damaged during sandy they should have knocked it down
not to mention the band playing couldn’t carry a tune if they had a pickup truck
paid my 70.00 bill and left with out eating
2 warm beers
Glass of wine
A lobster roll
And chicken burrito bowl
Hey chef I think you need to cook the rice first
DO NOT GO !!!

So happy to have found this place! Nothing fancy, with its plastic tables and chairs and paper and plastic tableware. None of that matters here… it’s still charming and inviting. The deck overlooks the great South Bay and Islip Beach, which is dotted with friendly beach goers and their umbrellas. A stage houses their nightly bands. The owner Sal is ever present, and may just visit your table to ensure your satisfaction and welcome your input. Now on to the food: delicious! Dinner last week consisted of linguini with red clam sauce, which was spiced beautifully and contained just the right amount of sauce and garlic. The garlic toast was yummy, with its melted cheese on top. The fried flounder sandwich was cooked perfectly… not over-​fried as it so often can be! And a NICE sized piece of fish too boot! The rigatoni vodka was perfect. Not drowning in sauce, and packed with flavor! We ordered a pizza for the table. It’s homemade goodness a real treat.
Today, we gave it a try for breakfast. I had the egg and grilled veggie sandwich. The over medium eggs were cooked to perfection. The veggies consisted of lightly grilled zucchini, mushrooms, peppers, and onions, all atop fresh lightly toasted Italian bread with melted cheese. Absolutely delicious. Two people around me asked what I was eating, because it’s presentation was lovely as well! My husband had another sandwich on the menu that he was equally impressed with. Sal swears by his pancakes. Many around us were eating them and raved. We will try those next time. We will definitely be getting as much of Sunset Restaurant in as possible before the season draws to a close!

This place was great for the price and for being on the beach I just wish they had more seafood selections and the security gives you a hard time on the way in if you don’t live in islip. However we will continue to come here throughout the season as my son loves the beach and it has a great set up and the food selection they did have is very good

I heard about this hidden gem from my sister-​in-​law, who is a chef and raved about Sunset’s food. We went for breakfast a few weeks ago and found out her reviews were accurate!
We enjoyed everything we ordered — Blueberry pancakes, breakfast pizza & an egg sandwich. We didn’t realize that they would be such generous portions so we ended up taking half of it home. Iced coffee was very good too and the staff was friendly!
The atmosphere is very casual, similar to the Town of Babylon Beach Huts. Similar prices too.

Really nice place right on the beach !!! Great Restaurant Scene !!! Beautiful Beach !! Great atmosphere !!! Food was pretty good but WAY OVERPRICED !!! $ 12.95 for my chicken pannini that came with nothing included !! Had to pay $ 4.00 extra for my French fries. My husband got a cheeseburger which came with the French fries for $ 11.95, but he wanted bacon on his burger so that was an extra charge of $ 3.95. An order of fried calamari was $ 12.00 & 2 cans of soda was $ 3.00. Beers cost $ 6 for coors & $ 7 for corona. Mixed alcohol drinks were $ 7.00 & tasted VERY watered down, so when I ordered my 2^nd drink I told the girl no ice, she even put extra vodka in it & it STILL tasted watered down, so I don’t know what’s up with that lol lol. Cheap vodka? Watered down vodka? Anyway the owner Sal is very nice, & we loved the atmosphere of being right on the beach, they even have beautiful REAL palm trees on the deck, we felt like we were away on vacation on a tropical island somewhere.

Great place to bring the kids and relax on the beach and enjoy their food. They just started serving breakfast, too. So many locals walk down or bike their way to the beach. There’s a gazebo and large covered area with plenty of tables to have a seat while you’re watching the sunrise or sunset. There’s also 3 small BBQ grills similar to the one’s you’ve probably seen at most state parks. You’re allowed to bring store bought food and drink to the tables outside of the restaurant. Although, bringing «outside food» to the deck area of the restaurant is NOT permitted. If you’re looking for a «Hamptons style» restaurant, this isnt it. Think Captree food but a lot better (Panini sandwiches, pizza, breakfast, etc). Visit their Facebook page for hours of operation and a look at their menu!

This is not a typical sit down restaurant. You order from the establishment to the right of the deck, you can then be seated at one of the tables that overlook the beach and bay. The owner Sal actually brought out our meal and mixed drinks, which honestly exceeded my expectations. I ordered the large chicken panini anticipating a small would leave me hungry, when it arrived I was surprised at how big the portion was. In speaking to the owner Sal you really get a sense of his dedication to providing great customer service. Will definitely be visiting again.

Awesome atmosphere and great food prices for on the beach eating! I have seen another review state that they did not get service, this is probably because it is not a sit down, waiter service place. You order food and drinks at the window and they bring it to the table you are sitting. The owners were there and were friendly, thanking us for our business and encouraging us to come back on the weekend for live music or Dj. We only had sliders and fries but the food was definitely great for the price and view!

Islip has a beautiful new outdoor restaurant on the beach. Last night was our anniversary and it could not have been more perfect. The food is fresh, tasty, big portions at a n affordable price. They make a crab on a half shell that I never seen anybody ever put out.
Excellent !