Wings Over Ithaca

One of the best place for wings! My husband and I always order a hangar 1 with F16, and a salad. These are enough even for my tomorrow’s lunch! Flavors with Cajun are alway fantastic! So yummy! Wings are better than boneless ones.

This place is awesome. Killer boneless wings.

Ordered wings for a Superbowl party and when I came to get them they’d obviously been made hours earlier and were just sitting under a heat lamp despite them having little to no business. After heating them up in the oven the boneless wings were fine but the regular wings were terrible because they’d overcooked the first time and they were hard and flavorless — there wasn’t even enough sauce on them to give them a sauce flavor. Yuck. To top it off the order was VERY expensive. I wouldn’t eat there again.

Just this past Friday my good friend contracted salmonella poisoning from chicken wings here.

I am usually a fan of the Wings Over brand, but this location didn’t live up to my expectations. The food was OK, but not worth the cost. The cheese waffle fries came regular with a very small cup of cheese on the side.

First of all delivery is fast which is fantastic! Never eaten in but they always deliver in under 30 minutes which I find amazing. The prices aren’t bad. The wings are good and they have waffle fries! Also you get to choose lots of different sauce options which is great if you’re like me and like some variety! I typically get the hanger 2 which is ginormous and leaves me enough food leftover for at least another meal. Great wings and it’s fast, it’s all you need!

DO NOT EAT HERE! FLIES IN THE FOOD!
I ordered the boneless wings and french fries. All seemed great until halfway through one of my boneless wings, I rotated my fork and noticed a FLY WAS COOKED INTO THE CHICKEN (see posted pics). The fly was clearly part of the food prep process, meaning no one noticed or seemed to care that they were cooking the fly into the actual wing.
Now here is the real disappointing part… I contacted the corporate office without any response then also had Grubhub contact the store directly. The store responded by saying they «couldn’t do anything about it» and acted like it wasn’t their fault. When mistakes like this happen, they made it infinitely worse by not caring at all. In contrast, Grubhub kindly offered a $ 10 voucher even though my meal cost $ 24.
This was my first time eating from here, and I will never eat here again. People not caring about food safety is a hard red flag. Please be careful.

Yum! This was my staple late night snack when I was in college (over 5 years ago) but it’s still a go to when I’m visiting Ithaca. The best part is that they deliver so whether you’re a car-​less student or a lazy ass, the food comes to you.
My favourite flavours are the garlic parmesan and the honey mustard.

So first the place is greasy, like all over everything. Tables, walls and even doors. The men’s rest room needs its door degreased so frickin bad, my hand stuck to the door like it was glue. Blah (I wasn’t even touching the handle)
Basically expect to battle mud Dragons, on the toilet, the day after eating here.
Wing selection is good, just really greasy. Would I go again? Of course when I am depressed and want to binge eat, not caring for the gastro intestional trauma the next day…

Go for the boneless wings. They are the best! Also I highly recommend the fountain soda over cans although both are available.
I think the best sauces are blackened Cajun, garlic parm, and all the hot sauces depending on how spicy you want to get!

Ordered wing last night at around 2:30 a river before the scheduled time over cooked and chewy not how I expected ny hangover meal to taste

Not the best, not the worst, but a decent choice for bone in wings in Ithaca.
The wings are big and meaty, but the meat doesn’t have great flavor. They should consider serving slightly less meaty wings or wings that have been brined.
I’ve liked most of the sauce flavors I’ve tried, except for the dry rubs and parmesan garlic. The dry rub wings just don’t get a good coating so you’re left with mostly flavorless meat. I didn’t like parmesan garlic on the chicken or fries. There’s something weird about the flavor.
The crinkle cut french fries are OK, but would be better if they were cooked longer. You can order them well done, but I’m not sure the cooks actually honor this request as they’re always slightly soggy.

met my chicken wing craving and delivered promptly!

Really great wings. Cooked perfectly. Great variety of sauses to choose from. Came here with kids and they loved it too.

HORRIBLE ! I officially give up ordering take out food in Ithaca.
This place is trash.
Trash wings, trash burgers, trash service.
I place an order for a mid– well done cheese burger with fries and a snack on size wings buffalo with ranch sauce.
First of all, the burger was 100% nasty. Soggy no flavor, tasted old.
The wings I found a hair in it, it was literally wrap around the wing like if someone did it on purpose. On top of that the wings were basically rubber !
To finish the stupid guy who drop my food off had my order upside down. The wing sauce spilled everywhere I had to open my food in the sink.
DONT EVER ORDER FROM HERE !! STOP THROWING YOUR MONEY AWAY PEOPLE !!

I was not impressed!
Ordered my wings well don’t with hot sauce on the side — and they didn’t do either! The Parmesan garlic powder tasted like it was just tossed on the fries and chicken, was def missing something. And the «boneless wings» and chicken fingers, not what we were expecting.

Well I have a complaint. We ordered 120 wings last night for our gathering through grub hub. We were supposed to get 6 flavors of wings and asked for them to be fried hard. When the wings got there they were not fried hard and we were missing a flavor (20 wings.) I called and let them know, they said sorry and they would get them right out. Mind you, it was late around 12:45. After 2 I called back, the manager had an attitude. I told him not to send them because I’d been waiting and it was not my home, I didn’t want to sit there all night waiting. I informed him I would not order from there again, nor recommend anyone else to. I am angry that I paid for 120 wings and didn’t not receive them all. I’m upset that Wings Over Ithaca didn’t make it right, nor did they really try to. They will never again get my business.

I had the wings here…
I had the hot and the garlic Parmesan…
They were ok, kind of mealy and chewy, nothing great.

This place is good for their lunch buffet. All you can eat boneless wings.
Their boneless wings are chicken tenders, so not your normal «boneless wing» which I actually like. There’s more chicken than breading and you get the actual chicken flavor even though there is not much flavor to chicken itself.
During Fridays we come here for the lunch buffet which for that and a drink runs just shy of $ 11 which isn’t bad.
They usually have 4 – 5 kinds of wings, coleslaw, pasta salad, blue cheese and fries. The wings can be a bit too saucy sometimes which is one of the reasons why this gets knocked a star. Plus their sauces, while good, aren’t great. Personally I like b-​dubs slightly more but that’s just personal preference.
The inside reminds me of a bar. Just table and chairs, not much atmosphere which is fine. They have a few tv’s in the place which is cool.
The reason this get’s knocked 2 stars is that I just don’t like their traditional wings. They are always soggy with sauce instead of crispy. I don’t know if just the last 2 times I got them they sat for a bit before being server or what but all I get is sauce and mush. I have to remember next time to get sauce on the side because they do pile on the sauce that much sometimes.
Now this can be corrected by me just asking for a side next time so I will update this review later on but really, they shouldn’t be drenching the wings in the sauce anyway. Too much is too much!
Overall this place is A-​OK and might be slightly above that and it is a place I will hit up for lunch again I am sure, but if it’s a toss up between this and b-​dubs, I am going to pick b-​dubs especially on Tuesday for .60cent wing nights. Also, overall their prices are slightly higher than b-​dubs I’ve noticed.

Great place to get wings. Lots of options for flavors, and at a great value. If you have a group you can get a combo which includes multiple flavors, in addition to fries and soda. My friend and I came here and got one of the smaller combos with two flavors — I believe he ordered garlic parmesan and Cajun teriyaki. Wings are very juicy and plenty of dipping sauce was provided. It came out to around $ 12 each, but we had so much wings and fries left over we had to take it home and finish it the next day, so it was definitely worth the money. They have plenty of TVs to watch sports so I imagine it would be fun to come here on a game day.
My concern would be the cleanliness of the place. It doesn’t really seem like they put much effort into it. When I arrived, there was an employee just sitting around watching TV in the dining area, and at least three people behind the counter, yet the used dishes were piled up in the corner next to the fountain drinks, and I noticed a lot of flies around it. They didn’t clean it up at all my entire time I was there. Perhaps it would be best to just take these wings to go?