My New York Pizza

Absolutely the worst pizza I have ever had! I had guests over and none of us could stomach to eat it. I had to throw it away and actually went to Walmart and bought several Totino’s Pizzas to cook at home. EVERYONE said how much better the Totino’s pizza was. And that is not a high standard!
When the pizza arrived the cheese was coagulated. Immediately we were all turned off. I tried cooking it longer to get the cheese to blend and make the soggy crust crispy. No such luck.
I am a big supporter of local businesses but I simply can not write a good review for such poor quality.
Think about… it had to be pretty darn bad to pay $ 20 for a large cheese pizza to just turn around and throw it in the trash.
Would love to give this place a second chance but I don’t think I can stomach to nasty cheese.

Great pizza, great salad, great wings and great service. Clean and comfortable. We’ll definitely be back.

Best Pizza in Keller! This place is run by real Italians. If you’re eating pizza, then you must eat here. It’s BYOB, but that’s okay. I usually take it to go anyway.

I’ve been looking for a true NY Pizza since leaving the NY/​NJ area years ago. This place could be right off the parkway!!!

I called in an order for a veggie pizza. This was my second time to order it, and while I thought it was good enough to order again, it was so much better this time than the first. All of the veggies were crisp and fresh. The crust had a nice crunch to it as well. It wasn’t as flat as a typical New York style pizza is, but I liked the amount of crust. The owner was also very friendly when I picked it up. Try it!

We stopped by the other night for the first time and at first were not sure what to think. On the specialty pizza we couldn’t get half of one and half of another to try two different kinds. That was disappointing, but not a total loss. The woman that was working behind the register was a little rough around the edges in telling us we couldn’t split the pizza getting two different kinds. When we received the medium pizza it was actually bigger than I had expected and the taste was very good. It’s definitely above average and a nice break from the ever decreasing toppings at Papa Johns. It was somewhat pricey to me, but the better quality was in the taste. I may end up visiting again from time to time.

The crust is AWESOME, wings cooked perfectly as requested! Priced a little high I thought but I’ll just have to tone down my toppings. Delivery was quick. I will definitely order again. FYI BEST Blue Cheese dressing EVER NO FAKE CRAP

Love this place. Pizza is delish, salad is fresh. I’ve been here several times and have always received prompt, courteous service. I’m not sure what the other reviewers that received «poor» service were expecting… it’s a pretty simple transaction. You place your order, you pay, they bring it to you. Perhaps customers should start taking accountability for their own behavior, treat people as you want to be treated and stop crying about everything in an online forum.

We love this place though we don’t visit as much as we used to because we’re fat and getting fatter. Pizza is not on the meal plan. However, when we want to be bad, this is one of our favorite spots to do it. We usually get a single topping pizza (doesn’t really need to be loaded down with toppings) and have them bake it extra crispy. It’s really legitimately like NY pizza, right down to the tiny useless napkins and paper plates. I say that with affection. :)

Thin crispy crust a plus, everything else was sub par. Granted we are far from the east coast but when take and bake is way better than this you know it’s pretty bad. Bland, bland bland. Have yet to find a non chain pizza joint around here that is palatable.

The food is actually decent. Problem is the customer service is awful. I rarely write reviews, but honestly worst attitude ever here. We were charged for food we never had and forced to pay for it. The food was cancelled but weeks later when we went to pick up a pizza the owner yelled at us to pay for the past food and held our current food hostage. After this experience I looked at the other reviews, and noticed they did the same thing to someone else. In that review, a lady said they ordered delivery, it was never delivered and still required her to pay. I know economic times are tough, but it’s no way to treat people. You can’t make customers pay for food they never received. There wasn’t a person in the store when we went, and it’s not because of the quality of their good which is only ok, it’s the quality of the attitude of the owner.

Walked in there today. Menu is pretty large but I opted for the Calzone.
It was great. Talked to the owner while there. Not sure I get the negative reviews.
We’ll come back for take out and this is BYOB!

Best pizza in the Metroplex so far the owners are very attentive to your needs good customer service great delivery fantastic pizza

My family loves this place. The pizza is flavorful, we have has the meat lovers, pepperoni plain cheese, or our favorite sausage and jalapeño — all were good options, they tasted delicious and their pizzas are pretty good sized for the price. My husband also gets wings everytime we order and I’ve tried several of their salads. The food is always hot and fresh and we’ve never had any complaints. Also take note that they almost always have deals going on so ask if you’re calling it in. This is our number 1 pick for pizza.

I found this place on Unilocal and so glad I tried it. The thin slice pizza is great! They don’t slather the pizza with sauce and the cheese they use is so goooood. One night me and my wife tried the spicy hawaiian pizza and I was amazed how good it was. I haven’t tried anything outside of their pizza so I’m looking forward to it.

Ate here for lunch! 2 big slices with any topping + drink for $ 5! Pizza was reheated… The taste was pretty good, although it’s what you’d get for reheated. I would eat here again, however, because of the good deal! Seems like they have a lot of other tasty pizza flavors as well!

We order from this place a lot since we’ve moved and are glad to have found it! The pizza is fantastic and they usually have deals going on, even if you order by phone they will tell you the discount you are getting when they have a deal. Hubby really likes the gyros too!

We ordered delivery from «MNYP» and got a lot of food for a good price. The phone order process was easy and the guy on the other end was friendly. They quoted 40 – 45 minutes and arrived in 30 (nice!). The food was very hot, another good sign.
I thought the pizza sauce was good, and the cheese was a little on the skimpy side. The crust fell a little short though, it was dry and super crispy. Crispy is god when the crust is thin but this is «medium» and was stiff as a board. It tasted pretty good but, again, the lack of cheese and overly crisp crust did not go together.
The wings were excellent, crispy and fresh– how we like them. You could really taste the butter in the hot sauce, otherwise they were nearly perfect. We also ordered a greek salad that was fresh, crisp and tasty. They pile the veggie toppings on and wedge the feta cheese for you to crumble on your own.
We’re new to the area and are trying to find our «go to» pizza delivery place. MNYP is lower on the list, we’ll keep looking.

We stopped in My New York Pizza for a change of pizza pace last week. This is an order-​at-​the-​counter joint and you can help yourself to beverage refills. There’s plenty of booth and table seating.
We ordered a large meat lover’s. It came out in about 10 minutes and was plenty hot and cheesy. The pepperoni had good flavor and the big slices of ham covered lots of real estate. We managed to polish off the pizza and our only main complaint was that it was a little soggy from the grease in the middle.
Oh! And it’s a BYOB! Do that — especially if you don’t drink soda, like me.

For a quick slice or two at lunch time this place can’t be beat. While I think the 2 slices and drink deal for $ 5 is OK, there are plenty of new lunch specials now. I was told they are on the web site, but in looking at the menu, they don’t really jump out at me. Basically I heard a lot of options around the $ 5 to $ 6 mark.
Pizza still continues to be a solid performer, and I’m not getting any weird vibes (or odors) either. In fact the guy who told me about the specials was quite pleasant.