Pizza Stop

Once in awhile their pizza crust is a little too hard but most of the time we enjoy their pizza. The only thing I wish they would improve is to be more pleasant to their customers like good business people should be.

Great pizza but when I tried to order a special from the website the guy on the phone said I had to print it. Who even has a printer these days? Anyway he wouldn’t give me the special so I ordered from somewhere else.

Overall the best pizza in Kenilworth. Love the sicilian and the buffalo chicken pie is one of the best I have had. You really can’t go wrong here.

Excellent local pizza joint. You can’t go wrong ordering a slice or a pie here.

Woohoooo! It truly is difficult to find good pizzerias that have both good food and good pizza (two very different feats). Pizza stop has accomplished 5 stars in both.

This is some of the best pizza in the area. If anyone remembers how good Pizza House in Cranford used to be, Pizza Stop’s pizza tastes exactly like that.
Their cheese garlic bread is also amazing, you get an entire loaf of Italian bread with lots cheese. Even their pasta is out of this world. Every time we go we end up ordering too much and getting stuffed, but its so good you want to finish it all.

Pizza is good but pricey (nyc prices) … the chicken is absolutely horrible. horrible horrible

The food is definitely good over here. I usually get a chicken cutlet sandwich (they never seem to have honey mustard though) and the buffalo chicken pizza.
My two complaints, though, are the prices and their hours. I’ve tried calling over there for pizza for Sunday football and have been greeted by an unanswered phone. Found out they are closed Sundays. Wow, really? At least in the Fall it’s probably the day you want pizza most!
The prices are a tad high too. For a whole chicken cutlet sub (including tax) expect to pay just over $ 10. It’s a good size, but other local places can rival the size and taste for $ 1 – 2 less. For my usual buffalo chicken pizza, expect to pay $ 16 – 17 after tax (used to be $ 15 but I think it just went up). Sure, it’s very good and a specialty pie, but again there are other local places with similar stuff for cheaper.
Parking is near impossible on the street, so turn down one of the side streets and just walk around the corner.