Casey’s General Store

I had ordered a pizza that they had on special… called it in and asked if it was the one on special… the guy said yes… it will be ready in 20… I said ok… got there and the night mgr. rang it up for $ 5.00 more… told him I was told it was on sale… the cool came out and said it was but this guy said to bad if you want it… this is the price… Need I say more… would not go back here for gas or food…

Great pizza, delivery available and it is nicely priced. I do highly recommend this pizza over the other pizza places in a mile radius. Especially for take out or delivery.

We eat here once every couple weeks (or whenever the husband has choice on dinner!). The pizza is thin and soft – what I imagine is NY style, although I’ve only been to NYC once for an afternoon/​evening and didn’t eat any pizza. :(lol. We always, always get the pineapple pizza… yum! The potato bites/​puffs are also really good. The staff is pretty scatter-​brained and may forget that you ordered breadsticks… it happens surprisingly often, but they’re always pleasant about fixing their mistakes.
My husband says the breakfast pizza (which he gets by the slice) is also amazing.

I LOVE Casey’s pizza and I was so excited when I realized I would be driving past it on my way home from work every day. The cheese is out of this world. The sauce and the crust are perfect. I love the spicy sausage with the fennel seeds. Casey’s pizza brings back fond memories of stopping for a bite on the long drive home from college. Now I can share that with my kids and they say it is their favorite pizza.
The only reason they are getting ⁴⁄₅ stars is I think it can be difficult at times to place a carryout order. The last time I did that the lady was yelling at the delivery guy about where he had to deliver the next pizza. Next time, I would prefer to be put on hold than listen to what is going on in the kitchen. That being said, Caseys one of the top places to go for a reasonably priced pizza.
I can not speak from personal experiene, but my husband who is generally unimpressed with quick easy food talks often about the amazing Casey’s breakfast pizza he had one morning before a fishing trip.

I love me some casey’s pizza for dinner! Most people think this is just a gas station, but honestly, it’s a much better pizza place than a gas station. It’s just a great place to pick up a pie for dinner, and while your there, why not get a GIANT soda, some doughnuts, a candy bar, and a lottery ticket.
They lose a star for two reasons: they need to be closer, and they need to have some sort of cheese bread.