Mad Mushroom Pizza

Not bad service, and the cheesesticks are excellent. The pizza and sandwiches are mediocre, needed perhaps a bit more flavor as it’s somewhat bland compared to the competition, but big kudos for the late hours for those of us who work nights!

Based solely on cheese sticks!!! We made a stop before basketball game. Had a couple beers and cheese sticks. Simply delicious

Call order a pizza, get told it’ll be 30−40… Call after an hour of waiting. Told the pizza would still be fresh, 20 more min, I receive pizza. Cheese has harden and the pizza is warm at best! Thanks for the let down guys!

I have to say, my expectations for pizza are not high. I lived in New York for two and a half years (and miss the pizza badly), but I am not hard to please.
However. There is no excuse for sweet tomato sauce on a pizza. The thin crust pizza was so sweet that our pizza-​loving 13-​month-​old wouldn’t finish even half her piece. The cheese amount was good, but there was a sad lack of toppings on the everything pizza. It was also doughier than I like.

We just happened to find this pizza place on. Unilocal as we drove thru Indiana wow. It was amazingly good. Hit the spot. I will go there again. Fast service. And. Great price
I also found it refreshing to see the young people managing this place do it so well. Good luck to them

We get pizza at least once a week from Mad Mushroom. I love the regular breadsticks and all the pizzas rock. We have friends come down from up north pretty often and they always make us order pizza from here.

I did not get the breadsticks ;). I know it’s a big deal there, but I took a chance.
Let me begin by saying I lived in NY for a couple of years and now I’m a pizza snob. I discovered Marco’s near campus and it’s pretty good, but they’ve been closed for almost a month due to a, hmm, «technical violation». So I gave this place a chance – and a chance it was considering when I called I was on hold for at least 5 minutes before I hung up and called again.
I ordered a small pepperoni and a small Gouda spuds pizza (I’m not really a gourmet pizza person so this was a chance). I wound up waiting 10 minutes AFTER the 25 they suggested on the phone, and the guy told me I was getting a med pepp because he made that by accident. But when he told me the total was $ 20 I thought for sure I must be paying for his mistake. When I finally got my pizza (and it didn’t seem like they had that many orders, though there were at least 4 guys there) it was a small cheese and a med spuds. Come on guys!
Anyway the Gouda spuds was good, but no Gouda taste. It was just a mozzarella, cheddar, potatoes (and mostly they’d all gone to the middle of the square cut pizza), bacon, ham, and onion. I think I was supposed to get ranch for dipping, but that didn’t happen. It would been good. The cheese was pretty bland and a bit greasy and oversauced, but I don’t think it was too greasy or too sweet like some of the reviews mentioned. It wasn’t a spicy sauce, but it wasn’t as sweet as Papa Johns either. Oh, and the pizza was pretty good the next day cold.
In the end I would go there again, and definitely get the Gouda spuds, but I’d check the pizza before I left and not be in a hurry.

Was getting decent quality food at good prices, but never again. Either them or their delivery service decided to send my order far away from where I live. No apology, explanation, nothing other than the one hour+ I had already waited it was going to be another 30 minutes. More than that had come and gone. Cancelled the order and I really don’t think I am doing business with them any more.

I am from Chicago, IL and a huge pizza fan. I eat alot of pizza and I can tell you this pizza palor is one of the better pizzas I had in Lafayette. I tried a few local pizza places down here and was in depair because they were all nasty until I got a magnet at a party for Mad Mushroom.
I love this pizza, it was so yummy even the day after. the crust is wonderfully soft and the garlic butter sauce that is put in the box is a perfect dipping sauce … thank you Mad Mushroom for bringing me joy in this little town :)

The pizza here is delicious. I have also had several of their sandwiches as well and try were equally tasty. I especially enjoy their gourmet pizzas and specialty pizzas if I’m not in the mood for a traditional style pizza.

I used to order from Mad Mushroom after having a particularly bad or stressful week at work. An emotional breakdown is the only way to rationalize consuming that much fat and calories.
The pizza sucks, but the cheesy bread is delish!

Every pizza I have tried from this place has been yummy. They have a crazy big delivery area too and at least one of their delivery guys is totally cute. If only I could remember his name. Oh well.