A Slice of Brooklyn

Went there this week and enjoyed my pepperoni pizza. The crust is very good. Staff is very friendly and helpful.

My boyfriend were staying at the Eden Resort for the weekend. On Saturday evening, we got pizza, wings, and a Greek salad.
The pizza was very good. I only had 3 wings b/​c he ate them up. The salad was good as well. I would order from here again.

A slice of Brooklyn, where you can get excellent pizza and other food service is great the chefs are very friendly and helpful highly recommend.

I came here solely because of Danny R’s review on 2÷6÷2015. Just moved here and the review was so moving I had to come. Anyone that feels so strongly about how awesome their place is and won’t tolerate jerks giving them the business is already a place I like before I even try the food. The pizza was huge, the garlic bread comes as a loaf and everyone at the house had nothing but good things to say about it. The entire pizza other than dough was made fresh as I watched and the place has a great air about it as long as you like New York. For some reason, this place has a lot of new york memorabilia all over.

Love the pizza here. Slice of Brooklyn is my family’s go-​to pizzeria every Friday night! The employees are always friendly and eager to greet customers. I recommend coming here whenever you’re in the mood for some good pizza.

Great service, tasty pizza and good tunes! We stopped here for the first time between doctors’ appointments with our one year old and newborn. The waitress was extremely helpful as we juggled our two babies. She opened the door when she saw us walking up, helped us with the high chairs, and was very friendly. When the pizza came she had the cooks slice a piece into smaller pieces for our toddler. The pizza was hot and delicious. We got the Bianca which had Gorgonzola cheese, spinach, tomatoes & sautéed onions. The crust was crispy and chewy– delicious. We enjoyed the Tom Petty & CCR they were playing while we ate, with the cooks singing along. When we said we needed to go in a hurry, our server was quick to help. She even brought a separate container for our toddler’s cut up pizza so that she could eat it at our appointment.
Overall the atmosphere was super friendly, both the waitress and the cooks. The pizza was delicious and we felt welcomed. We will definitely return!

My husband and I have been traveling to Lancaster for 15 years. We always try to find a great pizza place. We have finally found it!
We are vegetarians and there were many things we could order (we do eat dairy). The atmosphere is fun, the place is SUPER clean, but the best part is the food. Tasted wonderful!

I have eaten here at least once a week since they opened. Their pizza is amazing New York style with big slices. Tonight was a meatball hero. All I can say is Wow! The décor is awesome. The staff and owners make you feel like you are in Brooklyn and they are so friendly. I strongly recommend you try this great restaurant if you have a chance.

My family loves slice of brooklyn! There sicilian pies are amazing. Best calzones & pizza in lancaster.

Very cool atmosphere. Lots of cool comic book/​character memorabilia! We had their loaded French fries with bacon and sour cream and it was excellent. fresh spiral cut style fries. We would like to go back and try their sandwiches but today we had a plain cheese pizza. It’s thin but very good. 4 out of 5 stars because it could of had a little more cheese but all in all it was excellent and we highly recommend you try this! No chain here, local family owned pizza joint.

It’s really a shame that people are allowed to use the name Brooklyn for their pizza restaurant and then not act like true Brooklynites. The service was poor. The two men that waited on us were rude. They took several phone orders in the middle of our service request… as we stood at the counter. The woman owner was conversing with other people while she was supposed to be attending to the customers in front of her. The food was just okay. This is coming from a New Yorker… me. Graciousness goes a long way and lancaster is sorely lacking in graciousness. This restaurant is indicative of this fact. We encountered service staff; Ricardo, who at least attempted to be polite, and Julio, who was useless, and as stated above, rude. There are many better pizza places in the area. Don’t waste your money don’t subject yourself to the rudeness.

Completely disappointed with this restaurant. I will give the atmosphere a 5 star rating but outside of that where do I begin. The first thing we noticed at 7pm on Friday was very little customer traffic for a new place in a prime location, once we sat down it took the waitress about 5 minutes to at least greet us and bring menu’s, then another 10 before we ordered. I ordered the Manhattan cheese steak ($ 9) which should have been a $ 5 sandwich, bland and unappealing, my wife ordered a panini with italian ham and cheese’s and she said it was all fat and had no signs of any dressing, which our order took 25 minutes to get (don’t forget they weren’t busy) I really think they should regroup and fix this place soon or it will be another casualty in Lancaster county.

My husband and I visited The Slice of Brooklyn in Lancaster PA location Hwy 30 in Lancaster, Near Applebee’s. It happened to be their first day opening. The waitress was very pleasant. The owners came by to make sure everything was ok. The pizza was delicious. The crust was the best I had in a long time. They also have a variety of pizzas not to mention all the other items on the menu. The décor was very impressive. Definitely will go back. Wish them best of luck.

Great authentic NY style pizza made from a friendly down to earth staff that strives to put a smile on your face whether your dining in or taking out!
I have visited my cousins in Brooklyn every summer since I was 12 and since moving to Lancaster last year I have not found better quality pizza that matches that delicious Brooklyn taste. My wife and I eat from here at least once a week — Love this place!

NEVER AGAIN. This has *nothing* to do with good NY pizza. We would recommend just about anything over this place. The food is bad; the service is even worse. After they gave away our pizza to another table, we had to wait another 30 minutes… does it really take that long to cook a thin crust pizza? When it *finally* arrived, the pizza was awful. Did they offer to comp the meal? No, they offered cheap dessert. This place is a huge disappointment. There are many other decent pizza places in Lancaster, so don’t waste your time here.

Pizza is consistent and always good. Thin crust New York pizza. The wings eer great as well. One of the few places in Lancaster that has Arrancini. They don’t have it all the time but when they do, it’s excellent.

Omg the pizza is amazing. The best in Lancaster hands down. Will be my only place to get a pizza. Service is good and the décor is awesome!

By far the worst service I’ve ever had. I’ve just giving birth to my first child and being a new mother straggling with the high demands of a newborn I was unable to leave my home. I placed an order for delivery in which I live right down the street (1 traffic light away) and ask how long it will take, I was informed it will be 30 minutes. I phoned 1hr 15 minutes after placing my order was told the driver had just left as he had orders on the other side of town. As I questioned about the wait I was told off by women who answered the phone «if you lived down the street why didn’t you come and pick up the order yourself». After several more nasty comments from this women I explained that I will no longer want the order she then tells me «you still have to pay for the order». I’ve never in all my life been treated in such a manner. I will never again order or eat here again.

My husband and I recently moved into the area. We were pleased to find this pizza shop. The night of our move we got pizza and salad delivered. We had excellent Hawaiian pizza that night. The other night we orders the most amazing white pizza. This place is great. Friendly people and quality food! I don’t want pizza from anywhere else!

I tried them again due to the proximity of my house paired with the early sunset/​cold weather laziness that has inevitably set in.
I must say, this time around was a much improved experience for my «pizza snobbish» persona. I must have gotten the gluten free pizza crust by accident last time around, because this was indescribably better.
The cheese and sauce paired well with the slightly crispy crust. The pepperoni was flavorful, but not overwhelming. The grease, well there really wasn’t much of that, which is check plus plus in my book. Such a difference this time around, that I also picked up a personal cheese last night. Solid yet again.
Will be back in the future.