The Lodge In Lancaster

Several members of my party, including myself, got fish and chips, they were out of fries, coleslaw, milk, soup, mayonnaise, and tartar sauce. Additionally the fish was cooked beyond crispy, almost fish jerky. Another member of my party got a salad and the cheese tasted spoiled.
However another member of my party got a burger and it was good, the iced tea was delicious, and the server was wonderful.

I went to a rehearsal dinner here, it was pretty good food — and filling. It has a feel of an old bed and breakfast. It also has a bar in the back that plays live music — small space, but really cute.

Appetizer menu selections are good– calamari and bruschetta were excellent. Good burgers and steak. Salads w homemade dressings– nice variety

I was very confused when I walked into The Lodge at 11:30am today. There was a dark and empty dining room to my left. A meeting was happening in a conference room to my right. I wandered down the hall, delighted by the rich architectural details of such a beautiful old building. Many nicely dressed people walked by smiling. I passed by a dark and empty bar on the left and continued until I reached a large room with dining tables and people. I stood in the doorway, surely looking lost and bewildered. I didn’t feel comfortable entering because there were signs for Rotary Club and I’m not a member. The only person who seemed like they worked there never even looked at me. They sat behind a table that was covered in strange badges or spools or something. I felt out of place and lost, and thought I had made a wrong turn. Surely this wasn’t the restaurant with the high reviews?! It looked like a high school gymnasium dressed up for a potluck supper. I left the building and walked around it to be sure I was really at The Lodge, and I was.

We have been here many times and every time it’s AMAZING!!! The fried chicken sandwich is always delicious, along with their fish (and I don’t even like fish). They make their own tarter sauce and dressings and all are wonderful! During lunch, they give you peanut butter and jelly cookies after your meal, don’t pass these up! A must try!!!

Pecan crusted chicken strips were fantastic accompanied with the sweet n’ tangy Thai chili sauce! Although I was a bit disappointed they were out of potatoes for potato skins, the friendly staff was able to improvise with French fries with all of the good stuff on top! Not quite the same but I still recommend this place for anyone who likes great food at fair rates all while hanging out in this very historical district! Live music too and great barkeeps!

No longer in business.

First time eating here!!! It was fantastic! Cool historical downtown building. The food was delicious! I had the blackened chicken sandwich!!! Yummmm the owner is very nice and down to earth! We all tried the brownie mint cheesecake! Out of this world… They are all homemade! We will definitely make this place a top priority on our dining out experiences :)

The food is great. Everyone here is super friendly. Classy atmosphere but not too classy to make you feel uncomfortable.