NYP Slice House

Good pizza when I went there with a friend but I ordered delivery and it was cold by the time it got to us. They delivered it in about 40 minutes so I don’t see how it could get that cold so fast. Calzone that my friend got on our visit was delicious. So if you want to eat there or take out its good but avoid their delivery.

OMG!!! Perfect meal for the day. My buddy and I did the Bataab Memorial Death March and ordered this pizza because of previous reviews. THIS PIZZA WAS A MONSTER!!! We ran for 6 hours today and weren’t able to finish it all. Not to mention how awesome it is. They also called my phone and asked what room I was in at the hotel. I told them I could just come to the lobby and they said non-​sense thry would just bring it. Added bonus since my legs were so sore. Had it to my room in about a half hour. Oh and the Green Chili G-​bread is out of this world! Thanks y’all!

Pizza is always great here. Have never had a complaint about the service. Slices are huge.

7 Bucks for a slice of Pizza and a salad with a drink is a price that can’t be beat. Descent Pizza for the price.

I just moved to town and have been looking for good pizza. I have been to most of the places in town and this one is the my favorite. They serve authentic new York style pizza as a whole pizza or by the slice. They also sale Sicilian and Detroit style pizzas as well as sandwiches, calzones, strombolis, Gelato and canolis. In addition to the food they have some told the most friendly out going staff and great music. This is a weekly stop for me. I always order a slice of pizza while waiting for my large whole pizza and have some Gelato or canolis. I whole heartily recommend this place.

We got the free garlic bread thanks to the Unilocal app and it was delicious. The pizza comes in 3 sizes: Small, Medium and «OMG that’s huge», being that there are five of us we opted for the large. The pizza itself was somewhat thin and greasy and while this isn’t my favorite style of pizza it was still good. The pepperoni after it was cooked had shriveled up to the size of a quarter and the toppings were pretty sparse which is a bit ridiculous because each topping is $ 3 extra. I know you have to make money but when you cut the pizza into 1/8’s (I think) and I get a slice that only has 4 pieces of pepperoni on it that’s a bit sad.
They somehow managed to run out of beer and ice at the same time (this was fine for me as I drink soda and don’t care if it’s not cold). All this said I still like the place, I’d give it another shot and (sadly?) this was the best food and service we received on our weekend vacation.
One thing to note, when you have customers using the bathroom, you probably shouldn’t high five your buddy who doesn’t have gloves on while you’re wearing gloves and making pizza dough, i’m pretty sure you’re supposed to change your gloves when you do that.

Started off with the free garlic bread, that they upgraded with cheese because we ordered the 22 inch pizza. The marinara sauce was sweet which was great paired with cheesy bread :)
The pizza was enormous! We got the pepperoni and everyone liked it. We are visiting from out of town for the renaissance festival and will be back next year! Great service and food.

My husband and I are New Yorkers and we love New York pizza slice. We go there weekly we are regulars the staff is great the pizza just like home. They also now have wine and beer which makes it even nicer. My recommendation is to always get a whole pie hot right out of the oven is no other way to eat pizza. We can’t wait for the one to open over by Walmart off of Sonoma Ranch.

Best pizza in town! !!! Delicious! !! The crust… the chesse… the sauce.. super amazing! !!!

Picked up some slices of pizza and wow! The pizza was excellent. I would highly recommend the New Mexico and California. The service was outstanding. I had help walking out to my car with the pizza and drinks.

So delicious. Las Cruces finally has an amazing pizza place. I lived in NYC for 8 years. This is a similar style, but definitely better than your average NYC pizza joint. Cruces needs this place.

I’m from New York
Disappointed not much better than your chain restaurants. Place is to small to enjoy a slice or a pie.
It tries to imitate a real NY pizza. It just another eat and get out. Have no idea how they can stay in business.
There hole setup is wrong and over price.

Before I start this review, let me say, I have lived in New York City. I have lived in Park Slope Brooklyn and the Financial District of Manhattan. During my time there I also spent a lot of time in Queens and the Bronx.
I am a single young guy, so naturally, while I was there I ate a lot of pizza.
New York Pizza Slice House definitely competes with all of my favorite pizza joints in NYC. Quality crust. Quality ingredients.
I definitely recommend NYC Slice House.
Brandon Madrid

Amazing! Super amazing fantastic pizza! I had 3 slices and I shoulda got more. I’m only here for a few days on business and I’ll definitely be back…
Back again bitches! I’m now the Duke and o don’t even live here! Ya’ll need to step up your pizza game.

I like the vibes very chill… And I like that it not expensive like #1 pizza combo is 6.95 for a slice of pizza, garden salad and a drink! And they deliver!

Food wasn’t bad but all of our orders came out at different times, 5 minutes from the 1^st order to the 2^nd order coming out then another 10 minutes before the 3^rd and 4^th orders came out. 1^st order was a slice of pizza off the bar and the second was a salad — both could have been brought to the table at the same time the 3^rd and 4^th orders were brought out.

Good New York Style pizza. Great Value, slices are huge. Warning they do not accept American Express, will not be coming back for that reason alone.

It’s not New York pizza, which has a crust that almost isn’t risen at all, and slidy, greasy cheese. But it’s good pizza. We tried the white pie, the pepperoni, and the cheese pizza, and the meat calzone. Fast, friendly service. I recommend it!

Best takeout pizza in town.
New Haven pizza = magical. (And vegetarian!)
I haven’t eaten in the restaurant itself, but come on, it’s a pizza place. You get a pizza and you take it somewhere and you eat it and you revel in the glory that is pizza.
If you want authentically Italian pizza with a glass of wine, go to Luna Rossa.
If you want upscale dining with good pizza options, go to Zeffiro’s downtown.
If you want a good slice of pizza near NMSU, go to Zeffiro’s on University.
But if you want the best takeout pizza in town? Go here.

We stopped at the NYP Pizza Slice House for lunch on Friday. The quality of the pizza was probably 4*, however they only had bottled water, tea, and soft drinks. Since I like ice tea, that was a downer, especially when the only ice tea they had to offer was sweetened (sugar). Another problem was the fact that we usually like a salad with our pizza. The menu lists salads (house and spinach), but none were available on Friday. Maybe they haven’t been open long enough to serve that portion of their menu yet. They do have as the sign indicates, slices of pizza for sale. We are not opposed to revisiting them in the future.