Zeiderelli’s Pizza & SUBS

Not a bad pie at all! This review is for catering/​delivery. Nice crisp wing, lightly sauced and bold flavor. The pizza was above average but nothing to go out of your way for.
They catered my NYE party and I was thrilled for the execution of everything. Even though I was too busy entertaining to enjoy it fresh, my guests really liked the buffalo wings and pepperoni pizza.
The food:
When I got to the pizza and wings, it was 3 hours post delivery but the dough still tasted good. Not like wegmans cardboard pizza dough.
The Wings had a nice crunch to it and not overly sauced which was nice.
I am excited to see what it would taste like fresh out of the oven. The owner was really nice and delivered the food himself. I will definately continue to do business with them for any future pizza parties.

STAY AWAY!!! Very disrespectful and rude. Tried to get them to deliver food and it was like trying to pull water from a rock. The person on the phone had an attitude and treated me like I was annoying him.

This is the best pizza place I’ve ever been to in PA. I travel to PA at LEAST once a year and have been stopping at Zeiderelli’s while I’m in the area for years. They make their own breads/​dough and I think that’s really what makes this gem stand out. I’m from the NYC metro area and I know good food in general, but especially good pizza. Not to mention the staff is always friendly and pleasant, which is always a plus for me!

We love this place! They deliver anything off their menu with no minimum charge, which is very nice. Loading up a newborn and a six year old can be quite the hassle, but ordering a ton of unnecessary food just to meet the delivery requirements can be an even more irritating hassle.
They are also super friendly. We stopped in just this past Wednesday to have a quick lunch with our friend’s 20 month old daughter and they even came out to ask if we would like her pizza cut up for her. It is nice to see someone go a step beyond.
And, of course, the food is absolutely DELICIOUS! The subs are fantastic, salads are great too… and the pizza rocks!
We love, love, love this place!

One of the better Pizza’s in the area, nice crust… wings are good too. They deliver pretty fast and use fresh products.

I have gone here for years but in last couple months they get my order wrong on a regular basis and I’m done. How hard is it to make a chicken cheese steak lettuce, mayo, and mozzarella cheese. I’m tired of them putting salsa and sour cream on cheese steak and them blaming there system every time. The sub, wrong and discussing as it were, was so soggy that it fell apart upon trying to pick it up. The pizzas have tasted like they were frozen. Definitely not fresh. Giuseppes on Simpson here I come! New place, better food, price and great service.

As part of my quest to find the areas best pizza joints, I stopped by Zeiderelli’s over this past weekend (⁴⁄₁₈) to try their pizza. As with all of the other pizzerias I have eaten at, I ordered one slice of cheese pizza, and dined-​in their establishment.
Food: This is very difficult for me to review, because they did forget about my slice of pizza in the oven, and so it came out a little toastier than I like it. The crust had a much darker shade of brown than I prefer, but it was taken-​out of the oven just before the point of no return. Regardless though, I probably would have thrown another slice in for my guest if it were my restaurant.
Aside from that though, I was very pleasantly surprised by what I ate. For me, the sauce may have been the highlight of the pizza. Some places put almost zero sauce on their pizza, and some places put waaaay too much. On this particular pie, Zeiderelli’s struck the balance very well. It had a fresh tomato flavor with some undertones of garlic, oregano, and basil. A very well nuanced sauce. (Sauce ⁴⁄₅).
As mentioned above, the dough was overcooked for my liking, BUT, I could tell that if done right and cooked fresh, this pizza dough could be in the upper-​echelon of pizza doughs. It had an interesting texture to it that isn’t typical of most pizza doughs I have had. I don’t know if this was a result of overcooking a bit, or if it is truly unique. I only order fresh, whole pizzas from places who pass my ‘initial eligibility requirements’. Zeiderelli’s has, and so I will order a whole one in the near future and update this review. (Dough ⁴⁄₅)
Cheese: This was a very close second-​place for ‘star component’. As I have mentioned in previous reviews, I believe that every component should be the star of the pizza, and be in complete balance with the other. For me, this cheese had something a little extra to it. Maybe it was the combination of flavor that amalgamated with the sauce, or maybe they use a superior cheese blend? I don’t know, but I really liked the complete package of sauce, dough, and cheese. (Cheese ⁵⁄₅)
Pizza: ⁴⁄₅
Service: This gets a little tricky as well. When I first walked-​in, I thought I had accidentally taken a wrong turn and ended up visiting a State Penitentiary. There were several guys working on that night, and all of them looked like a rag-​tag bunch of misfits. Despite that though, they provided good service, and at the end of the day; pizzeria staff doesn’t typically win any pageantry awards for ‘most refined gentleman’. I am sure they are fine people outside of work, but it was a little funny at first. Lastly, as I mentioned, if it were me, I would have fired-​up another slice. When my slice came out of the oven, the kid looked at it skeptically like, ‘should I make another, or should I serve this’. If you have to ask that question, the answer is always ‘make another’.
Service: ³⁄₅
Atmosphere: This is truly a take-​out shop. Although the inside has a couple of tables, they are cramped together and not particularly comfortable. This has a real ‘hole-​in-​the-​wall’ feel to it; but they produce great pizza. Be warned that this is not a place to bring your family and dine-​in. I would recommend takeout or delivery (if offered — not sure) every time.
Atmosphere: ²⁄₅
Price: For my slice of pizza, I paid about 2.25. For the quality of the product that I received, I would say that this was definitely worth what I paid. Additionally, they have some pretty decent pizza/​wing specials that I will definitely be trying in the future to get the complete-​experience. Despite being a little bit on the high-​end for a slice of cheese (I typically like to stay under 2.00), I still feel like I got a little bit more than I paid for in quality.
Price: ⁴⁄₅
Final Thoughts: If you are wondering if Zeiderelli’s has de-​throned my current #1 pizza place in Central PA, Boston Express; the answer is a resounding ‘no’. Though Zeiderelli’s is a definite second-​place recipient, they are still a little bit behind Boston express in balance and overall flavor. Though, a subsequent visit here will definitely be happening in the near future.

Had a cheesesteak sub which was pretty good, although the portion wasn’t. The small was incredibly small and the amount of meat was eh.

Pizza, subs, wings, delivery, take-​out, etc… all the usual items you’d expect on a pizza & sub «joint» menu, made with quality ingredients. Nothing fancy here, but you get what you pay for and it tastes good.
I like the steak stromboli a lot! Sunday is usually good for us with some cheese fries, a cheeseburger sub, maybe some Z Bread (or sticks), or a (HUGE) salad.
the pizza is the best in Lemoyne, so forget about the chain garbage up the street.
I was debating whether or not to give this place five stars because it’s not a real fancy place. But because I enjoy this place so much, I’m giving them the benefit of the doubt and going five stars all the way.

Small Italian sub for 3.50 is a great value and good quality. However I went for the pizza and it is about ad good as a good frozen pizza. Dominos is better.

This place had really good pizza and wings with great value. They deliver to the Harrisburg hospital, which is a plus as well.
We had the Hawaiian pizza which had bacon, ham and pineapple and it was great. Plenty of toppings and meat, which definitely makes this a 4 star pie.
The wings were decent, I got the BBQ ones and the sauce was just meh, not bad, but not awesome. I’d probably do them again, but give their other flavors a try. As for the wing itself, they were good size, meaty and not real greasy.
Good place if you’re at the hospital and need delivery. The driver even came up to the maternity ward to meet me. That’s service!

I haven’t tried the pizza yet, but the subs are good. The prices are extremely reasonable. I am looking forward to trying pizza from here soon. The atmosphere is very friendly, although I would suggest take-​out due to the small seating area. They offer great lunch specials as well.

First the negatives: They have a deal advertised online that not only did they not honor, but they did not inform us that they were not honoring. I found out once the deliveryman came with my food. When I called, they said «We are working with somebody to get that removed from the site.» They did offer to rectify the situation by dropping off a menu *rolls eyes* It doesn’t take much to remove text from your website, and it also doesn’t take much to proactively tell somebody that you’re not going to honor the special. I also asked for BBQ wings and they sent Sweet and Sour which were disgusting. I ate about 3 and threw away the other 17. The pizza was mediocre. Their customer service is terrible.
As for positives, they have good subs though are somewhat skimpy as far as meat is concerned. There are plenty of other pizza and sub joints in the area that I’ll be going to from now on.

Always good pizza/​subs and great guys behind the counter.

Great food. Quick delivery. If you want good old fashion type pizza and don’t feel like getting Papa John’s, Pizza Hut, or Dominos, go with these guys

Zeiderelli’s is a dumpy pizza joint run by a bunch of stoners. They bake their own bread dough, which is good, but their sauce sucks and they don’t put enough of it on their pizza. The sub rolls are great, but they overpower the skimpy ration of meats and veggies Zeiderelli’s puts on them.
Not bad, but overpriced for the quality. Absent-​minded help behind the counter.