Two Bros Pizzeria

I probably come here once a week. Very solid pizza place. Excellent ricotta. Wish they changed their pizza selections a bit more but their normal selection is very good. A little expensive for entrees for a pizza place, but all pizza places are like that in my opinion. The guys and girls behind the counter are great. I think it’s the best pizza place in the area.

Excellent food and very friendly staff. Great for lunch or dinner.

Never been disappointed. We even cater in Christmas Day dinner for years now and there’s never leftovers. Great food.

Been coming here for many years. Not the only pizzeria we go to in the area but have to say that this one is the best in all of Hicksville and Levittown. Quality is always consistent and never disappoints. Always a crowd in both the takeout and dining areas and always enough staff to handle. Even on a Friday at 6 PM your not waiting too long. Want the best experience? Try ordering a pie or slices and eating in their dining room while fresh out of the oven. Delicious!

Great pizza!!! Another wonderful family owned business in the area!!! Never had a bad slice!!! The variety is a great one along with their salads!!! There are places around with comparable slices but nothing like Thor salads… You can do take out or dine in. Quick dime or full service I have experienced all here and was always happy. Their pick up system is great they use last four digits of phone… Can imagine if they used names they get very busy and must be many Tonys that go in for an order! This is a great system so order does not go home with the wrong Tony!

The food here is always good until I ordered a margherita pie today. A small margherita at that. I got a 10 inch pie with no fresh mozzarella or anything that would even resemble a margherita pie. When I asked why I didn’t get a margherita they told me this was a margherita bc of the sauce. They charge $ 15 for a small pie because they change the sauce. The kid behind the counter was extremely rude when we asked a question as well. Not to mention how destroyed the box was when we got the pizza. Still giving them 3 stars to be fair because there food is usually good and the pizza normally is also. Just had a very bad experience this time and they’ve lost my business over it. Good food good pizza normally, just don’t ever have a dispute and you’ll be fine.

My only complaint they don’t deliver — — — –ooooooooooooooooooooooooooiiioioooooooo­ooooooooooo iiiiiooiiiooooooooooiii njjjjiiiiiiiiigfreeew ry uuiitr u iiiiyfddr

The pizza was just as I remember. Growing up one of my favorite pizza places! The grandma pie and Sicilian pies are amazing
Garlic knots have a lot of garlic flavor so not for everyone but I love it!
Thanks two brothers pizza for excellent courteous staff members! We come back here very year during our vacations to NewYork!

If this review was solely based on their Grandma Pizza then it would easily be given 5 stars. I would say their pizza across the board pretty solid along with the other items in the pizza display case. The heroes are also solid and a good size.
Unfortunately the rest of the Italian food is nothing to sing about. I’m very curious if it’s even something basic as not salting the pasta water because it’s pretty bland when not drowned in sauce.
I recently ordered rigatoni with broccoli rabe and sausage in garlic and oil. Saying the dish was bland is an understatement. It also seemed like the sausage was fried and placed on top. Same with the broccoli rabe, it was just placed on top of the bland pasta. This is the type of fish where you want the flavors for the garlic and sausage to infuse the pasta and veg. Not to mention, the dish was screaming for slat and my personal favorite, crushed red pepper.
I would continue going back here but most likely only for the pizza itself.

Best pizza in town. The pizza here is delicious and I would highly recommend it to anyone that loves pizza. The buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken are amazing. Place has been around for a while and with great food like this it will continue to be.

Two bro has one of the best pasta dishes I’ve eating in awhile they make some of the best tasting baked ziti that i have ever had and cheesy to the fullest. They also make some amazing pizza that would make you take a slice or two home just to reheat for the next day. It has just the right amount of sauce and the perfect amount of cheese and the crust has just the right crunch for the excellent pizza it is.

BEST SICILIAN PIZZA EVER.
All their food, in fact, is made with high quality ingredients and attention to detail.
I grew up 2 blocks away from Two Brothers, and despite it being only one of many pizza spots around, we always ordered from them. Mind you, this must be 20 years ago. Now, though I’ve moved out of the area, I always make sure to stop there when I pass through while visiting. We bring a whole sicilian pie back home with us, even on long trips.

It’s usually hard to make bad pizza. But Two Brothers goes above and beyond and makes great pizza AND food. My family moved to Levittown a couple years ago and we found this place and we go here all the time.
We’ve used two brothers to cater our house warming party and my 21^st birthday party and the food has always been delicious.
We’ve gone out for dinner at their restaurant portion.
The service is great. There’s a waitress (I don’t know her name) who always recognizes us when we come in and she’s always super friendly and accommodating. I usually get the fettuccine Alfredo or manicotti. It’s hard to find good creamy fettuccine Alfredo most of the time. Most places make it really oily but not two brothers! I’m glad to say I’ve found a spot for my favorite fettuccine Alfredo!!!
My mom always gets the fish and my dad usually gets chicken or veil and they both have always loved their food.
Only thing: I wish they delivered!!!

Great place, open late, good pizza and entrees. The service is friendly and quick. I love their turquoise seating

I’ve been coming here since I was a kid. Always consistent, and always delicious! Their specialty slices are amazing, their chicken roll is to die for, and even just a plain slice is perfection. Highly recommend their penne alla vodka. Just about everything there is amazing and the staff is always helpful and patient. Love the owner! He’s so nice

Their buffalo chicken slice is one of the greatest things I’ve ever put in my mouth.

If you like paper thin grease dripping slices this is the place for you then. I will pass.

All my friends rave about this joint. i happen to be in the neighborhood and hungry so i stopped by. The selection was large and the place was somewhat clean. I got 2 slices and a diet coke. Is it mandatory for pizzeria employees to be miserable and never smile? guess so. The pizza was decent i liked it and it was hot and tasty. The people around me were nasty and loud and slobs though. typical long island trashbags. Would i go back? probably not,

Love how their pizza isn’t heavy or greasy at all. You think of pizza in general and have this idea of greasy stuff dripping through the slice and how you feel so heavy after a slice or two. Well, the pizza here definitely isn’t loaded with cheese but still tastes great. It is dripping with olive oil though, which I guess is better with all the mon & poly unsaturated fats. The mozzarella cheese blocks on the slice taste really fresh. And the place is pretty affordable.

The pizza here is quite good. I had a chicken parm slice & it was tasty & crispy since I brought it home & reheated it under the broiler. I like thin & crispy pizza the best. I will definitely be back to try other slices. I regret not trying a plain slice because that’s truly the best way to judge how good a pizza place really is. The taco pizza, the stuffed sesame crust pizza & the white pizza looked really good & I think I will definitely be trying those sometime in the near future for sure.