Lilman’s Pizza

This is one of the closest restaurants to us in Lewis Center so am happy to say it was very good! We tried the pizza, it’s thin crust and delicious. The potato skins were awesome as well as the Italian sub. The traditional wings were some Of the best I’ve had and I Love wings! Highly recommend giving this place a try!

Pizza is pretty good, but I really enjoy the wraps and sandwiches. The spicy burger is excellent, the chicken club is a favorite. Fries are good when they cooked right but have had them where they were really overcooked and not good. I like this place because they have lots of options for when not everyone in the family wants pizza. We Order from here at least once a month and the only complaint I have would be the almost burnt fries one time.

Only 4 reviews? We are fairly new to the Delaware area but have tried every pizza joint around our area (Cheshire) and this is our goto spot now. Delivery is fast, food is great and always hot, menu options blow everyone away. No joke their spicy burger is one of the best burgers I’ve ever had, I’ve had it 3 different times and consistently the same and perfect. Keep it up guys I enjoy having a beer at the bar when I choose pickup as well. Great neighborhood place, don’t change.

After getting delivery or pick up previously 10 times, we came to expect slow service. Today we went to eat inside for the first time. There was a party there and so all of the tables were being used. It was reasonably warm outside so we were ok with sitting outside. After waiting outside for an hour and 15 minutes we were informed that we couldn’t have our pizza the way we ordered it, indicating the pizza hadn’t been started yet.
We changed the order, but our food was terrible anyeays. Regret coming here, and guaranteed we will not return.

My family and I got carry out here and had pepperoni and bacon pizza. We also had Italian subs. Everything was outstanding, midwest style pizza and subs! The pizza crust reminds me of Papa Jo’s (cracker crust)! This is more of a bar than a restaurant, however, we always get carry out since we don’t live too far from here.

Had excellent take out Veggie Pizza last night. We hate green olives, so replaced them with banana peppers. Very crispy thin crust. Not a lot of atmosphere for eat-​in. Good place to head after Olentangy sporting events.

I’ ve been to this establishment more than a few times over the years. It used to be the old Nacho Mama’s, but you’d hardly recognize it if you’ve been there before. It’s a definite must stop every time you head up 23N.
Lilman’s pizza aka the Rest-​A-​Bar has a small town charm, good pizza and appetizers. Their wings are always great, they’ve got a nice crunch to them. My favorite sauce is garlic butter. It’s so bad for you, you can hear your capillairies pop when you eat them. They’ve got spicy garlic, but there is just something about garlic butter wings and pizza that just sounds right! They’ve got a good selection of beers, and always have a good crowd.
It’s a great place to watch the game on Sunday or just to swing in and grab a bite eat while on a long drive.