Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics

I can’t say enough good things about this store. An amazing selection of balsamic vinegars and olive oils. The balsamic vinegars are so rich you don’t need as much olive oil to make a very thick dressing. Don’t throw those little pieces of paper away — they hold great suggestions for how to use their products. I have a full shelf in my pantry devoted to their products.
And FYI — if you can’t make it to Lititz, they offer free shipping for orders $ 100 and over.

Always a great experience here! Knowledgeable staff and owners offer suggestions as needed, but the descriptions on the vats are also quite helpful as to pairings or suggested uses. Olio has a wider selection than most stores of this type I’ve seen. The quality of the products in addition to the oils and balsamics is also outstanding and there are some unique offerings (honeys with varied flavorings, as an example). Don’t miss this place when in Lititz!

They have recently expanded their store so they are able to serve thier customers. Great selection of infused oils, vinegars and salts.
These are must haves for cooks!

I love this olive oil! Have been ordering from here since we discovered them in 2011, on a cross country trip to relocate. I wish there was a cheaper way to ship it, as it is a bit heavy but they do pack it beautifully. It would be nice to not have to pay as much in shipping cost as it is basically for the six pack of 2oz bottles. It’s a great gift, and everyone that I’ve sent it to, comes back for more. One way I’ve found to save on shipping is to order a larger amount and then split it up and use prepaid USPS boxes, you can fit alot in the small $ 5 box. Anyway, in regards to the olive oil, my very favorite is the Fig, you really have to try it. The selection is awesome, I especially like the white ginger as well, it works well with everything, especially because we live in Hawaii! Whatever your palette choice you can’t go wrong! Overall, shipping cost is justified by the great customer service and product quality! Happy dipping!

At Olio, you can taste what you purchase. It is the perfect way to sell a product. Every flavored oil and balsamic vinegar is available to taste and displayed in beautiful, shiny, clean containers with small disposable tasting cups. Very classy. I always feel like I’m at a fine wine tasting when I visit the store. There are suggestions for great oil and vinegar flavor combinations that are amazing. Some of my new favorites are (1) cucumber & melon white balsamic (2) lavender balsamic (3) mushroom and garlic olive oil and (4) habenero maple syrup! Too many to mention… try it and see for yourself.

This isn’t just an amazing place but an experience! Well worth the drive for products you wouldn’t find anywhere else.

Step away from the olive oil section of your grocery store and experience the many varieties of olive oils OOO&B has to offer.
In addition to the geographic varieties of oils, the infused and flavored oils are incredible. The garlic infused oil is incredible and I used it to make a wonderful bruschetta later. The variety of balsamic are fun to try also.
The owner was very helpful and made us feel welcome to sample as long as we wanted and provided additional information when needed.
This is a great little shop which foodies and non-​foodies would enjoy.

BEFORE I walked into Olio’s the mere idea of slurping balsamic vinegar or olive oil straight from a cup would have me on the verge of feeling ill.
AFTER I walked into Olio’s I’m always excited to go back and throw down a straight shot of Bordeaux Cherry balsamic or Roasted Chili Olive Oil. Wow, their selection is amazing. I think they have over 50-​taps combined now.
I made the owner explain why his vinegars and oils are so much better than the other stores with taps I’ve tried. He says they’re completely independent. Most of the other stores are part chain stores.
Either way, I can say their products really are fantastic. I’ve converted several people to the Olio way. The owner and staff and really nice, informative people who have an obvious passion for their business.

Cute little place in Lititz that features a vast array of different flavored oils and balsamic vinegars. It is worthy of a stop whether you live in Lititz or not. You can make up some great items to cook with or just top a salad!

Best Olive Oils in Pennsylvania! This was a fun trip to Amish Country! This gourmet olive oil store is in a little town called Lititz, PA. We had so much fun tasting the huge selection of olive oils and balsamics! You need to try the Moroccan EVOO paired with the Strawberry Balsamic… so yummy on salads! I’m not a local, so glad to hear I can order online!
Try it!

Fabulous find in Lititz. Very friendly and knowledgeable owners. Huge selection of high quality olive oils and balsamic vinegars from Italy, California, Greece, Morocco, Chile, Argentina, Turkey and Spain on offer. Many different sized bottles at reasonable prices. Owners encourage tastings and samples — so do try before you buy.
They also has a nice selection of cookbooks and other gourmet items.
I was vacationing, but if I lived there — I’d be in weekly. A must visit!