A-1 Pizza

Pizza is ok. Delivery is ridiculously slow ! They say 45 mins but ends up being over an hr and a half !

Pizza sucks, not nice staff, was told 40 minutes and it took an hour and a half. Not hot… Was supposed to be an everything pizza, looks like kitchen sink pizza. Won’t order again and would give it zero stars. Oh and found mystery meat on here…

Refused to take my order because I’m «too far away,» 2.3 miles from the restaurant. The guy who answered sounded stoned.

Delicious pizza!
I became a little concerned after ordering because of some of the other reviews but we were told 35 min and it came sooner. The pizza was definitely greasy but it’s pizza! Crust was delicious and texture just right. All 4 of us that shared the large pizza agree. We each got two large slices each also!

They’re food is alright. The good thing about them is that they’re open until 3am… NOT. I was on my way home with a night out with friends and got hungry so we decided to order from here but both of their phones were busy. When we got there it was around 2 in the morning and their phones were off the machines and they said the kitchen was closed. Maybe they shouldn’t advertise that they’re open until 3 am if they’re not going put in the effort of keeping their customers.

I wish I could put zero stars. Worst service ever! Called for delivery and was told 45 minutes, delivery guy calls 50 minutes later asks what town were in, says ok and then well after an hour we call back and they say they don’t deliver. We were never told and then given attidue by cashier, then higher up put on the phone. Horrible

My chicken francaise sandwich was plain and soggy. It was literally the chicken francaise juice poured onto both sides of the bread (baguette style) and then the chicken francaise put in between. No other herbs, lettuce, nothing.
The garlic bread and my husband’s meatball sub were ok. But the appetizer sampler was a soggy mess. French fries were bland and limp. Onion rings weren’t crispy in the slightest. Even the chicken tenders weren’t crispy. The mozzarella sticks were ok, but it’s pretty hard to mess up a mozzarella stick…
Also, the delivery time was supposed to be between 8:20 and 8:30 and it didn’t arrive until about 8:45. I would have been more than happy to wait the extra 15 minutes had the food been even a B-​. I’d rate my meal a D.

Pizza: 4 words. Greasy Soggy wet pizza.
Order a cheese pie — get 2 inches thick sloppy grease not only dripping, but pouring off your pizza pie. No decency to heat the pie a little longer so it wouldn’t be SOGGY. Soggy *greasy* wet pizza.
Also — we asked for extra sauce — none was given — in fact, what was given — was an attitude about how we were (trying) to eat the pizza in house even though we were quoted a ‘delivery price’ although that was not stated over the telephone — which had me waiting about 5 minutes to even take my order. There was no one else even in their ‘fine dining establishment.
Bottom Line: Don’t waste your time unless you’re one of their drunk after hours patrons who had enough ‘fast food’ and instead would like ‘pizza’ as if this isn’t fast food — drink, I mean, think again!!. Don’t waste your time unless you want to drink grease.

For a regular pizzeria i must say the food is delicious, I’ve eaten at expensive Italian restaurants and i must say the chicken franchase and chicken marsela tastes better here than at some of those pricier Italian restaurants and is priced reasonably with a full plate of food, you don’t get cheated with taste or foods portions here, highly recommended

Every time me and my fiancé go to concerts or whatever. We more than likely stay at the Hilton. And after shows. They’re pretty much the only thing open. And its leas than five miles away. We LOVE their pizza. Every time we order. We just have to have a slice. My lady had some sort of mozzarella chicken sub’s that she loved. And I’m a fan of their lobster ravioli. This is without a doubt our favorite pizzeria when we come to E. Rutherford!

Horrible. Quoted 40 minutes. Called after 55 minutes for an update. Told another 15 minutes, then guy gave me an attitude when I said it was already 15 minutes late. Pizza arrived 10 minutes later, cold and no flavor. Also price was high for a small pizza. Last time I order from A-​1.

I was skeptical of a pizza place that’s open until 3am with a name like A1 but holy crap was I wrong. Their pizza is delicious. Their shrimp fradiavolo is tasty as well and is a nice hefty portion. As a Philly native I just tried their cheesesteaks; it’s the best one I’ve had in North Jersey in the 2 years I’ve been up here. It’s a really good cheesteak and that would fool someone like me if you said it was from Pat’s or Tony Luke’s.
With such a friendly staff and great food I will continue to spend my money here.

This is the best pizzeria in all of New Jersey!!!

When visiting my cousins who live in Lyndhurst I always tell them not to cook I’ll stop at A1 and bring over a couple pies. They never argue !!! We love this pizza always fresh and the guys are always happy to see me. I’m there twice a month if they delivered to Newark it would be once a week !! at least haha !!!

My second time ordering from here and my very last. Never again! I had a coupon for their special #3 which is a large pie with 12 wings and a 2liter soda for $ 17.99. I called in told the guy on the phone i had the coupon and specified the coupon. No problem he said. Delivery guy shows up and the total amounts to $ 19.99 plus tax. So i mention hey the coupon is for $ 17.99.he calls the pizzaria up hands me his cell and the guy proceeds to say oh their menu had changed. so i simply say ok, just next time tell your customers over the phone about price changes especially when i informed him of the coupon i had while placing the order.
I proceed to sign the recipt… delivery guy rudely asks, oh are you going to give me a cash tip… .before even giving me chance to give a tip. So i respond, actually its free delivery as per the menu. the nerve of him asking! He wouldnt leave my steps and kept saying oh no you have to tip me you have to… I follow to tell him to get off my steps and its not mandatory not after this and slam the door. How dare he? Ive always tipped for deliveries even when free but not if I’m disrespected and i was misinformed about menu prices, they are lucky to have my money or anyones by any means.
The order of wings were a measly size of chicken wings. ive never seen wings so small before. They werent even cooked properly and they provided no dipping sauce for them. The pizza was decent as it was the first time. But after this type of service and lack of decency i will never order from there again. Plus when i called to complain about the delivery guy, they didnt seem to care much. The right thing from the start should have been to correct the amount to the coupon price since it did not have an expiration date. Instead of saying oh you know for next time… and they didnt provide a new menu flyer either. Bye bye

I stand corrected… I gave their pasta dish another try… penne in vodka sauce… improvement!

It isn’t the best pizza I’ve tasted but it is the best pizza place in Lyndhurst so I’ll give them 5 stars. They have $ 7.99 specials for large pie certain for Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. Students order 2 slice and a can during weekday lunch is $ 4.
We always order to go so I can’t comment for dining in.

Good place on the corner of Ridge — stopped in last night prior to visiting Cigar Emporium across the street. I got a plain slice and a Sicilian slice — both were pretty good. Granted, the place is small and a bit tight, the food is what counts — and it’s not bad at all.

Solid pizza spot open til 3am everyday. They have good specials before 10pm too. I usually grab a slice or a pepperoni roll when I’m hungry at the Cigar Emporium across the street. Service is quick and efficient. Never had it delivered though.

So I have ordered from here before and unfortunately never left a review. I ended up actually sitting down in here last night for a couple of slices so nows my chance to re-​review this place lol
Anyway, I ordered two white slices, fries, and the person I was with ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich.
The white slices were amazing — although I have had better, they were still really really good. I liked the fries a lot too because they were still crispy on the outside and nice and soft on the inside. As for the sandwich goes, it wasn’t very filled. like there wasn’t much meat but it did taste good.
The only reason I didn’t give this place five stars was because of my delivery experience.
They took a really really long time with delivery and I get it, they are super busy here especially because they are probably the only pizza place that I know of in my area thats open till 3am but still… Also, they are two towns over from me so where I used to live in Kearny I had JUST made the cut for how far they would go. Now im a couple blocks farther in and they wont deliver that distance :(big bummer.
Its pretty much your average pizza place — good specials and food. I would recommend to people in the area.