Paleteria Fernandez

Best ice cream that I’ve ever had. Everything is delicious here with so many flavors. Once you have ice cream here, any other ice cream will taste subpar. Beware, this ice cream is addicting and it will make you fat.

Spanish ice cream! That’s a first. Tons of really delicious looking homemade ice cream flavors lice rum raisin and 3 milks. Nice cones. Had two giant cones for $ 5.50 and was really tempted to walk back into the store for another cone, it was that good.

Good, tasty, Mexican ice cream. A nice addition to Mamaroneck Ave. and very cleverly placed next to Salsa Fresca.

A mexican style popsicle place.
A few memorable flavors include Mexican popular flavors such as Chongo, which is a cinnamon and milk, avocado Popsicles, and spicy mango, a water based mango and hot pepper popsicle
They also will dip bananas that are prefrozen in chocolate and then coconut or they will dip Popsicles in chocolate
You can also get fresh fruit covered with sweetened cream, hard ice cream, fresh fruit juice that they squeeze to order & milkshakes.

I have a new fix
I have a new habit
I am going crazy!!!
OMfreakingG!!!
This place rocks. I bought 10 Paletas de Agua– 2 of each:
Mango,
Coconut,
Guayaba,
Tamarindo,
Strawberry
Then I received a Free Paleta and opted for Gooseberry to try out– which almost tasted like a Jolly Rancher– I’ll definitely pass next time. Definitely not my favorite.
There are still tons more flavor to try,
When am I going again?
I need Paleteria Fernández fast!

Milk and fruit bars are both $ 2.50. Tons of delicious flavors and refreshing on a hot day. They also have unique flavors of hard ice cream such as vanilla with sprinkles mixed in.
Should give samples of the weird ones so customers that aren’t used to them can try it as the staff do not recommend any flavors even when prompted.

Freshly packaged, incredible milk bars. These are, without question, the best milk /​fruit bars I’ve ever had. The variety of flavors is unreal. Corn? And it’s good? Yes, the corn is actually one of the best flavors I’ve tried. The caramel pecan and strawberrys & cream are standouts as well. Don’t want to leave coconut out, either. They have ice cream as well, which is just as good as their bars.
Any and everything I’ve had here has been outstanding. The service is very friendly, as well. I feel good supporting a local, top-​quality business.

Paleteria Fernandez is an awesome place to get delicious frozen treats. Now most people come and get a cup or cone of ice cream, but you would be missing half of the magic. They have ice pops in a variety of flavors including tropical fruits like guava (with seeds!) and mango and milk flavored like chocolate and strawberries and cream. My favorites include cookies and cream, watermelon, and peanut. Parking is ferocious on Mamaroneck ave in town so find the municpal parking lots and walk over. If you buy 10 ice pops, you only pay 20 $ as opposed to 2.50 $ each. Check it out.

Stellar product and Very friendly staff, but despite good foot traffic, they’d likely do better with one storefront and wider distribution.

Disappointed when the one in Port Chester changed to include more artificial flavors and color in some of their flavors. Same here. Used to love the rum raisin. Got it at this location and it seemed to taste better from here!
Can get some healthier fruit options though. The price is good — $ 2.50 I think — and it is an awesome stop during this hot summertime!

Cash only!
The fruit bars and milk bars are fresh, creamy, and made with quality ingredients. There’s variety in how flavorful a given flavor is and since the bars are homemade, I suppose it is a bit hit-​or-​miss (but usually hit!)
I’ve tried the mango, banana, pecan, rum raisin, pistachio, pecan, avocado, chongos, and some others a number of times. The bars are ~$ 2.50, I think, and if you order 10, you get 1 free (I have a big family and these store well :)
You can have them dip any bar in chocolate that solidifies, but I would pass on it, as the chocolate is kind of bland…
They also have scoopable ice cream in the front of the store.
Overall, I would recommend this for a quick, easy, and somewhat unusual dessert stop. Enjoy!

The milk-​based paletas are to die for!!! Tried it for my very first time yesterday with my boyfriend! He had tried it before and highly recommended it for me. It brings me back to having these things called «limber» which only Puerto Ricans mostly know about! I bought a chongos, vanilla, cookies and cream and a pistachio paleta!!! they are all so good and natural. love love love. its far from my house but whenever I decide to visit this area again to shop, I am buying more! its a bit pricey ($ 2.50 per) but in my eyes sooooo worth it!