Pie Oh My!

Pie Oh My provided our wedding pies and we have no regrets. The pie flavors were interesting and DELICIOUS, they were easy to work with and delivery went smoothly. This is the ONLY place anyone should be going to for pie in St. Louis.

SO, SO GOOD! There was a really big selection of creative and more standard flavors as well as a number of size options. I opted for the gooey butter and Mexican hot chocolate mini pies. Both were delicious, especially the crust. The Mexican hot chocolate pie filling had a great kick to it.
The shop itself was really cute and had some space to sit and enjoy your pie and coffee. The service was friendly, too.
Unique, unexpected, and, to top it off, friendly and inexpensive. I’ll definitely go back next time I’m in the mood for pie.

Probably my favorite place for baked desserts here in St. Louis… you seriously can’t go wrong with anything here! I’ve been fortunate enough to try almost all of their delicious creations, and I have NEVER been disappointed. My favorites are probably their strawberry basil (a summertime regular) and their oatmeal chocolate (a decadent treat!). Great for occasions or «just-​because»!

Came across this adorable pie shop during a Maplewood street festival. The pies are amazing and very well made. There is quite a variety of flavors too. We had a pear and chocolate bourbon pecan– both were excellent! Orders ca. Be placed through their website 48 hrs ahead or you can just call in for next day pick up as well. Very sweet and accommodating customer service:

Awesome pies here, come and get the apple pie with the double crust! My host in St. Louis recommended this place to me, but he said that they always screw up the online orders. Hate online ordering systems myself, but I gave it a try. I was disappointed to see that they did not have the pear-​apple combo, but what can you do. Well, I had to wait two days for my pie, which is fine, and nice surprise the order worked perfectly fine. The pie cost $ 23 but it was YUGE. I figured that it made about a dozen servings, you could have easily satisfied a baker’s dozen even. But I guess that might have made the pie slicing difficult. The crust was perfect, not too greasy, sweet, salty, or over-​/​undercooked. All five of us were very happy with this apple gooey sweet yumminess, and we enjoyed for two successive breakfasts. I think the next time I might try a dutch crust instead of a double crust, and maybe the time after that I will order a double Dutch crust just to confuse the bakers…

My small pie was delicious. By not overwhelming the ingredients with sugar, the flavors were a gentle delight. I just wish I’d been offered water or something to drink, as we were dining in. There is only maybe enough room to seat eight people in the small room. Thus, you may want to plan take-​out or enjoying dessert as you stroll the interesting area.

Oh My, I cannot believe that I have yet to review Pie Oh My! I am going to keep this review short and sweet, because I am not sure I can say any more than what has already been said. Simply put the pies here are delicious and handmade, just like grandma used to make. Everything here is made from scratch in the small Maplewood storefront. Yes, the interior is small, but the pies here deliver big flavor. Yes, you can order a whole pie, however I recommend ordering several personal tart sized pies of each variety that way you can be sure to sample all the delicious pies. My recommendation is to arrive early for the best available selection of the smaller pies as they tend to go quick. The focus here is on carry out, however if you decide you just can’t wait to get home there is some limited seating available inside.
My favorite pies are the Apple Crumble, Chocolate Bourbon Pecan, and the Salted Caramel Apple. You simply cannot go wrong with any of these.

Apple Pear Pie?! Do you really need to ask? Pie Oh My! is my absolute top place tp go for a little something sweet or a gift to bring for a dinner party, etc. Smiling friendly faces are sure to great you as you walk in the door, swiftly followed by the subtle aroma of freshly baked pies and other delicious convections. The best course of action is to arrive as early as possible and leave time to ask questions and relate your likes and dislikes to those working the counter. They are definitely going to be your best friends in the work of trying pare down their seemingly myriad options to one or two selection to take home. As their options rotate according to time and season, as does any good bakeshop, going with whatever is freshest/​most sesaonal will always be the way to go but yield to the bakers advice, you won’t be disappointed.

Flavorful and fresh pies for a good price. You can taste every ingredient in the pumpkin chai pie. The coconut cream is also very fresh and light. Worth the drive.

This place is great, the pies are super fresh, super flavorful, and always a good variety and options to choose from. We try to make it back as often as possible to try the different creations.

I love their tart-​sized pies. Today I got a peach, a blueberry-​sour cream, and an apple cinnamon salted caramel? I don’t exactly remember that last one… VERY tasty. The staff is always friendly, they do a great job of explaining each of the choices, and it’s an open kitchen, you can see them all working hard!
I only take off a star because they’re on the spendy side. It’s a very occasional treat for me. But boy do I love them!

This is a really sweet (pun intended) and small pie bakery. I tried the blueberry sour cream pie and it was very good. It was very rich, creamy, and sweet with a tang. The crust was also very good. The prices are reasonable. There is some seating inside but not much. I think most people probably get theirs to go though, which is what I did.

Aww, maplewood! One of my favorite neighbourhoods to hit on a nice evening. Pie oh My is definitely one of my all time favorites to hit while I’m up here. I really recommend getting one of the mini pies because they’re just enough to satisfy a sweet tooth. The best part, they are small enough if you really want to try a second flavor, you don’t feel completely guilty getting a second one. The other thing I really like is that they make the pies in several sizes so you can always get the one you want.
I ordered a lemon lavendar blueberry pie. Yes, it sounds like it would be an overwhelming combination — but it really tasted like heaven. The hints of lavender really blended the lemon and blueberries together. The crust is exceptionally flaky and the pies are simply out of this world. They’ll be a hit at the next party. I can’t wait to come back here soon!

All I can say is wow! I’ve had a few different items here and each one has blown me away. I ordered an apple pie for my roommates birthday and we agreed that it was the best pie we’d had. It was the apple crumble without nuts, highly recommend. A couple other times I’ve just popped in and tried a whoopie pie (2 cookies with marshmallow in between) and a blueberry sour cream tart. Don’t let the sour cream scare you off, it was delicious! If I could get away with it, I’d get something everyday. This place is my go to for sweets.

I really like this place. Go there frequently for a little tartlet. There are always several good choices available in the small pies. We also did a special order for my wife’s birthday that was fantastic!
The secret here is the crust. Tasty and flakey, just about perfect. Have had the chicken pot pie, and it’s just about the best one I’ve ever tasted.
So, why not five stars? It’s just a little pricey. My 90 pound daughter can polish an entire chicken pot pie that costs $ 15, easy. Little pies are also $ 5, which seems $ 1 too much.

Very impressed here. While I only visit St Louis about six times a year this is a stop I always make. Great products, great people, and I most love the ability to call 48 hours in advance to ensure they will make the pies I need. Not many places offer that type of personalized service anymore.
Mallory helped me on the most recent visit. Super friendly and answered every question we had all with a bright smile the entire time.
The apple pecan pie could have had more pecans but the crust and overall flavor was great. The other sweet pies we’ve tried have also been pretty much perfect. I look forward to getting some savory pies on the next visit.
The shop is located on a side street in a nice neighborhood but there is plenty of parking and even a park if you want to wander over and eat outside. There are also a few seats inside if it’s too cold outside or you just want to absorb the atmosphere of this friendly and great smelling shop.

Finally found the truck at Faust Park! Recommend one of everything! Had the chicken pot pie, beef empanadas, the cherry pie and the blueberry sour cream pie. They had pies by the slice, minis, and tart size.
My favorite was the blueberry sour cream pie. I had a mini and returned for a tart. It has a lot of blueberries. The crust is light and flaky. The crumb topping was delish and plentiful, with pecans.
Highly recommend trying their fruit pies!

Oh my! This is EASILY the best pie I have EVER had. I’m not trying to be dramatic either… the world must know. So I’ve always been very indifferent towards pie and have chosen cake in it’s stead a many of times.
I sampled the chai, pumpkin, coconut, and chocolate pecan pie (I think I’m missing a few words on the last one).
My two favorite tied for first, the chocolate pecan and chai. They are both amazing. I’m a big fan of that whipped texture so I might give the chai a slight edge. That, and I’m a hugeeee chai fan. The chai is uniquely chai flavored and has the perfect mix of sugar and spice. The filling was perfectly whipped and creamy.
The chocolate pecan was also amazing. Before Pie Oh My! I may have said pecan pie is my favorite type of pie. Adding chocolate to is a total game changer. It was 5 times better… easily…I did the math.
The coconut pie followed closely behind. I loved the coconut. Soooo good and loved the filling as well. I just thought the chai was sooo unique as a flavor but I would easily get the coconut again.
My least favorite, which doesn’t mean I didn’t like it, was the pumpkin pie. It had some fierce competition in its’ defense. While it was great, I have never been a big pumpkin pie fan. All pumpkin pie fillings, homemade or not, aren’t that appealing to me. I prefer one of the other pies I tried over pumpkin pie any day of the week! This is more just a general preference thing.
ALL PIES ARE GUD. EAT MORE PIE.
The other amazing part, they are awesomely cheap. They are like, $ 3 – 6 depending on the size. SOME BAKERIES CHARGE THAT FOR THE COOKIES! Outrageous.
I have yet to order a full-​size pie but one of these days I will to impress everyone at the party.
While I took mine to go, the shop is very homey. You could sit there all day and have a pie eating marathon. That is the best idea I’ve had all morning!

Attention Pie Lovers: If you walk into Pie Oh, My and they have Apple Crumb Pie with Green Chilies available, buy it — You’ll LOVE it. I have had this pie several times and it is amazing. I stopped in yesterday for a pie fix and was excited to see they had my new favorite pie available. I was cooking a Mexican theme meal and a apple pie with green chilies made for the perfect dessert.
I also bought their new Cranberry Meringue, which is going to be a great hit for the upcoming Thanksgiving holiday. A flaky crust, tangy cranberry filling, a picture and flavor perfect meringue has me knowing what I will be taking to work with me on Thanksgiving day. Yes, I am one of those unfortunate folks who will be working on that day, but with pie in tow I’ll manage to make it through.
When I stop by POM, I can never just get one. I also grabbed a couple of their bite size pies for work lunches. I got a Maple Walnut with Schlafly’s Pumpkin Ale and a Pumpkin Toffee. The Maple Walnut did not make it to the lunch box. I’m not a fan of walnuts, but mixing them with maple and my favorite autumn beer had me wanting more. The Pumpkin Toffee is in the lunch box for today,
I was thrilled to see them offering quiche and since I hadn’t had breakfast yet, I bought one. The combination of sausage, onion and sun dried tomatoes made for a perfect morning treat. I’ll take it over a Egg White McMuffin any day.
They are offering candles made by Maven that smell like a pie is baking in your oven. It is so good to see all the Maplewood businesses work and support each other. As always, talking to Jane is a delight. Can’t wait for my next slice of pie.

Five star BUMP! Pie Oh My really has my heart. The crust has greatly improved and their individual servings and interesting, never before heard of flavors keep me coming back for something different every time! You walk in and are hit with a blast of warm, inviting and yummy smelling air. I love how they are open til 6 and it’s so convenient. I’ve been here several times.
Some of the best pies I’ve tasted on recent trips were:
— Sour cream apple crumb
— Blackberry
— Pear apple cranberry
— Blueberry pear
The blueberry pear was warm… OMG… I’m drooling thinking about it.
I’ll be back again and again! PIE!